Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

7wo7rees

(5,128 posts)
Fri Jul 30, 2021, 10:54 PM Jul 2021

Why don't Covid patients want to take the shot?

From Maarten Van Doorn's subscription email.

Facts don't change minds? Identity-protective cognition and belief polarization almost never happen, so they do
Falsifiable Friday #4

Maarten van Doorn
Jul 30

Comment
Share
Happy Friday! 😉

✝ According to Dan Kahan’s influential theory of “cultural” or “identity-protective” cognition, public disagreement over key societal risks (e.g., climate change, nuclear power) arises not because people fail to understand the science or lack relevant information, but rather as a result of the fact that people endorse whichever position reinforces their connection to others with whom they share important ties.

🤼 This is generally referred to as a specific form of motivated reasoning, namely, “identity-protective cognition”. Because espousing beliefs that are not congruent with the dominant sentiment in one’s group could threaten one’s position or status within the group, people are motivated to “protect” their cultural identities.

🧏?♂️This means there’s no point in conveying unwelcome facts and evidence. Because people will probably not use their brains to figure out which beliefs are best supported by the evidence. But to figure out how to best justify assessments of the evidence that fit with dominant position within their cultural group. Studies, experts, and so on, that do not agree with this position X are dismissed on the grounds that, since they conclude not-X, they cannot be genuine experts and sound studies.

➡⬅ Because we weigh the evidence so differently, we’re stuck in our opposing camps and don’t converge by considering the same information. So exposing the public to information about the scientific consensus will only further attitude polarization by reinforcing people’s “cultural predispositions” to selectively attend to evidence.

🦯 The idea that such identity-protective cognition causes groups to drift further apart – and away from the truth – is popular these days. The New York Times, for example, has claimed that “Americans’ deep bias against the political party they oppose is so strong that it acts as a kind of partisan prism for facts, refracting a different reality to Republicans than to Democrats.” The common suggestion being that there’s no point in bothering with facts anyway because people will just dismiss them if they’re inconvenient.

✍ In this week’ research-packed piece, I show that Kahan’s work doesn’t support the popular notion that people are often not sensitive to evidence as a result of motivated reasoning so fact won’t change people’s minds anyway. This is the exception, not the rule. New experiments show that the specific conditions under which motivated reasoning and belief polarization occur are much more constrained than often assumed.

Go to the essay
https://maartenvandoorn.substack.com/p/contra-kahan-on-motivated-reasoning

Comment
Share
You’re on the free list for Maarten van Doorn's Newsletter. For the full experience, become a paying subscriber.

Subscribe

© 2021 Maarten van Doorn Unsubscribe
Dorsing 24, 6581 RV Malden, The Netherlands

Publish on Substack


3 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why don't Covid patients want to take the shot? (Original Post) 7wo7rees Jul 2021 OP
Failure proves success. 7wo7rees Jul 2021 #1
Mark Twain summed this up like only he could. GulfCoast66 Jul 2021 #2
I'd summarize all that in just three words. PoindexterOglethorpe Jul 2021 #3

GulfCoast66

(11,949 posts)
2. Mark Twain summed this up like only he could.
Fri Jul 30, 2021, 11:25 PM
Jul 2021

It’s easier to fool a man than convince him he’s been fooled.

Rather or not he said this is debatable. But it’s true and is like something he would have said.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why don't Covid patients ...