Sun Dec 25, 2011, 05:47 PM

What's the difference between a Carol and a Hymn?

Disquieting minds want to know.

And if you can't answer that one, How come nobody ever goes around door-to-door singing show tunes?

8 replies, 6704 views

Thread info Bookmark this thread Trash this thread

Reply to this thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

8 replies	Author	Time	Post
What's the difference between a Carol and a Hymn? (Original post)	Gidney N Cloyd	Dec 2011	OP
How about a guess?	PETRUS	Dec 2011	#1
Never thought about it before; but how about this?:	Aristus	Dec 2011	#2
Hymns are religious songs.	Pab Sungenis	Dec 2011	#3
A hymn is based on ancient legend. A carol is based on old songs.	HopeHoops	Dec 2011	#4
A Carol doesn't really mention God, and Hymms are for singing in church. Mostly.	Quartermass	Dec 2011	#5
Carol is a her and hymm is a him...	WCGreen	Dec 2011	#6
Finally a sensible answer!	Gidney N Cloyd	Dec 2011	#8
Here's my take.	7wo7rees	Dec 2011	#7

Response to Gidney N Cloyd (Original post)

Sun Dec 25, 2011, 05:49 PM

PETRUS (3,678 posts)

1. How about a guess?

Maybe carols are secular?

And on the other thing, I don't know what you're talking about. Practically every time somebody knocks it's Pirates of Penzance.

Reply to this post

Response to Gidney N Cloyd (Original post)

Sun Dec 25, 2011, 05:50 PM

Aristus (58,606 posts)

2. Never thought about it before; but how about this?:

We sing carols to each other; we sings hymns to God.

Make sense?

Reply to this post

Response to Gidney N Cloyd (Original post)

Sun Dec 25, 2011, 06:01 PM

Pab Sungenis (9,612 posts)

3. Hymns are religious songs.

Carols are Holiday songs.

Not all carols are hymns, and not all hymns are carols, for the snark WAS a boojum, you see.

Reply to this post

Response to Gidney N Cloyd (Original post)

Sun Dec 25, 2011, 06:15 PM

HopeHoops (47,675 posts)

4. A hymn is based on ancient legend. A carol is based on old songs.

Reply to this post

Response to Gidney N Cloyd (Original post)

Sun Dec 25, 2011, 06:41 PM

Quartermass (457 posts)

5. A Carol doesn't really mention God, and Hymms are for singing in church. Mostly.

Reply to this post

Response to Gidney N Cloyd (Original post)

Sun Dec 25, 2011, 06:46 PM

WCGreen (45,558 posts)

6. Carol is a her and hymm is a him...

Reply to this post

Response to WCGreen (Reply #6)

Sun Dec 25, 2011, 08:06 PM

Gidney N Cloyd (18,380 posts)

8. Finally a sensible answer!

But now what do we do with Tommy Tune and Opera Winfrey?

Reply to this post

Response to Gidney N Cloyd (Original post)

Sun Dec 25, 2011, 07:33 PM

7wo7rees (4,811 posts)

7. Here's my take.

Carols are hymns.

Hymns which are not carols are to be sung in groups, reverently, earnestly.
Carols are to be sung in groups joyfully, merrily on holidays/holy days.

Those "Christmas carols" that have no reference to the birth of Christ, a la Jingle Bells, Frosty, Rudolph, etc. are all simply Christmas songs.

Reply to this post

The DU Lounge (Forum)