Pab Sungenis
Pab Sungenis's JournalDOMA had no severability clause!
Nowadays, bills are usually written with "severability clauses," which state that if one section of the statute is struck down, the others remain in effect. This became a major issue during the fight against the Affordable Care Act, because ACA had no severability clause so the Court could have killed the entire thing with just one ruling against one part of it.
I just went back and reviewed the text of DOMA. It had no severability clause!
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/104/hr3396/text
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
SEC. 2. POWERS RESERVED TO THE STATES.
SEC. 3. DEFINITION OF MARRIAGE.
No severability. I didn't bother to quote the whole thing, even though it's only one page. Go read it for yourself to verify.
So even though the Courts have ruled that Section III is unconstitutional, the entire Act died today. In fact, the full text of the Windsor decision at http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/12pdf/12-307_g2bh.pdf specifically states that "the statute" is invalidated, not just Section 3.
That means that full faith and credit comes into play! We won the whole enchilada, although it might take a couple of other court cases to force some states' hands.
Tweet from August J. Pollak
https://twitter.com/AugustJPollak/status/349894181528944640
The only way to fix the Voting Rights Act decision.
Proposing an amendment to the Constitution of the United States to safeguard the right to vote.
Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled (two-thirds of each House concurring therein), That the following article is proposed as an amendment to the Constitution of the United States, which shall be valid to all intents and purposes as part of the Constitution when ratified by the legislatures of three-fourths of the several States:
"Article--
"Section 1: The right of citizens of sufficient age of the United States to vote shall not be denied, inhibited, infringed, nor abridged by the United States or by any State.
"Section 2: Congress shall have the power to enforce this Amendment by appropriate legislation."
Only an Amendment establishing an affirmative Right to Vote can protect us.
For the "blame Nader" crowd today, remember....
...there was no way that a Republican appointed Justice would have retired under Gore. In fact, there were no vacancies during Bush's first term, so there would have been no changes during Gore's term.
If he had been re-elected (which in and of itself is not a certainty), O'Connor would never have retired. At best, he would have had one appointment with Rehnquist's passing, which would have probably been filibustered by the Republicans anyhow. And then who knows who he would have appointed to the Court?
So if you want to deflect the blame from where it belongs (the Third Way DLC crowd who insist the Left has nowhere to go) maybe you should point it at John Kerry, who ran the most inept Presidential Campaign since Walter Mondale. After all, if he had beaten Bush we wouldn't have had Roberts or Alito, either.
And there goes the Voting Rights Act.
Section 4 unconstitutional. Voting to strike it down are Roberts, Scalia, Thomas, Kennedy, and Alito.
Another disastrous SCOTUS opinion ("Adoptive Couple")
Alito writing for the majority (Roberts, Thomas, Kennedy, Alito, and Breyer) to gut the Indian Child Welfare Act.
http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/12pdf/12-399_8mj8.pdf
No Prop 8 or DOMA decisions today, per SCOTUSblog.
Court ruled the right way in the AID and enhanced sentencing cases, wrongly in the AMEX arbitration case. That's it for the day as far as decisions go.
The one thing I never forgave Frank Lautenberg for.
He not only refused to use his hold to keep Samuel Alito off the Supreme Court, but he gave him his imprimatur by introducing him to the Judiciary Committee. Even though he voted against confirming him in the end, he did nothing to stop the nomination.
Frank Lautenberg's spinelessness gave us Citizens United.
I grieve for the Senator, who did a lot of good in his early stint in the Senate, and for his family, but I can never forgive the damage he did to our democracy by kowtowing to Bush. I hope his successor has more of a spine.
Profile Information
Member since: 2003 before July 6thNumber of posts: 9,612