President of Royal College of Psychiatrists urges caution over calls for people suffering from depression to be prevented from working as pilots.
Professor Simon Wessely, who is president of the Royal College of Psychiatrists and an adviser to the British army, urged civil aviation authorities and airlines to avoid repeating the panicked reaction that has often followed similarly shocking cases, such as the crimes of the Manchester GP Dr Harold Shipman.
I have dealt with some pilots with depression and when they recover they are still monitored. But the two I have dealt with returned to very successful careers. Why should they not? What does cause trouble is saying that if you have ever had a history of depression then you should not be allowed to do whatever. That is wrong, as much as saying that people with a history of broken arms shouldnt be allowed to do something.
He said: We are all concerned. There are two reasons why: there isnt a link between depression and aggressive suicide, if that is what this is. There isnt normally such a link. And second, because of some of the ridiculous things that are said....(more @ link)
Lubitz, 27, was suffering from vision problems which may have compounded a psychiatric condition from which he had suffered for at least six years.
Investigators will be examining the theory that severe stress - caused by a fear he might lose his job as a consequence of failing eyesight - may have driven him to commit suicide by flying an Airbus into the side of a mountain in the French Alps on Tuesday.
The New York Times reported on Saturday that Lubitz had sought treatment at Dusseldorf University Hospital for his eyesight.
The hospital said on Friday that Lubitz had attended the hospital in February for an evaluation and then returned on March 10 for further treatment.The hospital has refused to say why Lubitz had sought treatment but significantly ruled out claims it was for depression. That would lend weight to the claims that Lubitz had gone to the eye clinic, which is situated inside the hospital....(more)
The revelation of the possible trouble with his eyes added a new element to the emerging portrait of the 27-year-old German pilot, who the authorities say was also being treated for psychological issues and had hidden aspects of his medical condition from his employer.
It is not clear how severe his eye problems were or how they might have been related to his psychological condition. One person with knowledge of the investigation said the authorities had not ruled out the possibility that the vision problem could have been psychosomatic.
Like after 9/11, the common desire after a human caused (or not) tragedy is to look for a precipitating reason to prevent it from happening again.
Unfortunately too often there is an over reaction causing pain and trouble for many other people. Like after 9/11. And I fear now.
By definition, people who kill others without cause, without needing to to save their own life, are mentally ill. Some have been treated for mental illness. Many have not. But most people with mental health issues are no danger to anyone.
Please. Please. Please.
Use this as an opportunity to open your minds, to learn about what mental health is and isn't. To recognize that we walk among you every day. That there are a huge number of people with mental health issues and only a teeny tiny fraction of us will EVER cause you or anyone trouble.
There are different types of mental health issues as well as different degrees. There are medications that help, and medications that cause problems.
We are here. And over there. We are all over.
Why do we not talk about our mental health? Why do you not know that we have sought help? Because we get that look. We get told we should not work in our professions. We get told to "suck it up, everyone has it hard". Or "you have such a good life, what do you have to be sad about"? Because it is better to be seen as quirky, or happy all the time, than depressed because if we acknowledge to others that we are depressed, too often we get passed over at work because how can you depend on someone who is depressed. Or how can you trust them? We get told anti-depressants are the devil and only always cause problems and anyone who takes them is denying that.
We are here. Please do not try and marginalize us, me, because a murderous asshole killed a plane load of people and happened to have mental health issues. The vast majority of us are just regular people. Like me.
I do not understand their motivations, their mental health, their actions. It doesn't matter what form the murders take or whether individually or at one time.
I just do not understand how someone would, how someone could, think that it be a good idea to kill a bunch of others.
Explain it to me like I am dumb because I just do not understand.
My heart is heavy.
Men from four communities stood before the governor, the state Supreme Court and a joint session of the House and Senate to receive the medals. Looking on from the upstairs galleries were more people from the Arlington, Darrington, Oso and Sauk-Suiattle Indian Tribe communities.
The medal, one of Washington states highest honors, is awarded to those who have set aside personal risk to save lives. To award them in this instance, lawmakers this year passed and the governor signed a bill allowing the Medal of Valor to be given to a community rather than just a single recipient.
That scale seemed to sum up the sweep of honor necessary for the Oso landslide, the deadliest in U.S. history....(more)
I hope this won't jinx it.
Not a single severe thunderstorm or tornado watch has been issued anywhere in the U.S. by NOAA's Storm Prediction Center so far in March, as of March 18.
"This has never happened in the record of SPC watches dating back to 1970," said Greg Carbin, Storm Prediction Center warning coordination meteorologist in a SPC news release Tuesday. "We are in uncharted territory with respect to lack of severe weather."
There had been only seven reports of severe weather large hail, high winds or wind damage nationwide this month, through March 18, all occurring on March 11....(more)
Crosspost from elsewhere on DU, words fail me.
San Francisco, CA A video was submitted to the Free Thought Project Wednesday, which shows what life looks like when you live in a police state.
San Francisco rap artist, Yung Lott was filming a music video at a public park in Bayview-Hunters Point, when their production was rudely and unlawfully brought to a halt.
As the video begins rolling the group is quickly interrupted as swarms of SFPD officers surround the group and demand they all put their hands up and get on their knees.
Cameraman, Brian Storm posted video of the raid on his Facebook page and it quickly began to go viral.....(more)
The Hillary Clinton email flap shows each person how their view of her is right.
It shows the supporters why they should support her and her non-supporters why they should continue to not support her?
We just got our power bill and in the stats it give this and last yr's month average temp.
2014 was 38
2015 was 47
No wonder the cherry trees, daffodils, etc etc are blooming already.
I mean which is the stupidest, but the most serious, dangerous.
Profile InformationGender: Do not display
Member since: Sat Oct 16, 2004, 10:10 PM
Number of posts: 115,656
- 2022 (2)
- 2020 (2)
- 2019 (1)
- February (1)
- 2017 (104)
- 2016 (89)
- 2015 (90)
- 2014 (15)