Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
arely staircase
arely staircase's Journal
arely staircase's Journal
December 8, 2014
As for the crucifixion and resurrection, the party involved wasnt Horus but Osiris, as per the above. Except Osiris wasnt crucifiedSeth initially had him nailed into a coffin. And he wasnt really resurrected, just revived long enough to be a sperm donor, after which he died again.
Then again, there really isnt a canonical version of the Horus story. Browsing through the stelae, I find a variant in which the child Horus is stung to death by a scorpion, then restored to life by the god Thoth. So OK, are there points of similarity between Jesus and Horus? Ill be big about it and say sure. Is one copied from the other? Get out.
But lets not fixate on Horus. The real difference between Egyptian mythology and the story of Jesus is that the former is clearly a fable full of beings with super powers, whereas the latter is told in realistic terms with the occasional miracle thrown in. The simplest explanation for this is that the New Testament is largely about a real person, with embellishments added to impress the rubes or make a doctrinal point. I venture to say this was the working assumption among a sizable fraction of scholars for a long time, and many still hold to it. But Id also say theres a hardening realization that, setting aside obvious supernatural elements, well never know which if any parts of the Gospel describe actual events and which are made up.
http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/articles/42717/straight-dope-debunking-the-jesus-debunkers/
Debunking the Jesus Debunkers
I first heard the claim that Jesus was a copycat of the Egyptian god Horus when I watched the so-called documentary Religulous. Horus supposedly walked on water, was born from a virgin, healed the sick, etc. Naturally, I was skeptical and tried doing some research but found only biased opinions that werent backed by much evidence. So whats the deal?As for the crucifixion and resurrection, the party involved wasnt Horus but Osiris, as per the above. Except Osiris wasnt crucifiedSeth initially had him nailed into a coffin. And he wasnt really resurrected, just revived long enough to be a sperm donor, after which he died again.
Then again, there really isnt a canonical version of the Horus story. Browsing through the stelae, I find a variant in which the child Horus is stung to death by a scorpion, then restored to life by the god Thoth. So OK, are there points of similarity between Jesus and Horus? Ill be big about it and say sure. Is one copied from the other? Get out.
But lets not fixate on Horus. The real difference between Egyptian mythology and the story of Jesus is that the former is clearly a fable full of beings with super powers, whereas the latter is told in realistic terms with the occasional miracle thrown in. The simplest explanation for this is that the New Testament is largely about a real person, with embellishments added to impress the rubes or make a doctrinal point. I venture to say this was the working assumption among a sizable fraction of scholars for a long time, and many still hold to it. But Id also say theres a hardening realization that, setting aside obvious supernatural elements, well never know which if any parts of the Gospel describe actual events and which are made up.
http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/articles/42717/straight-dope-debunking-the-jesus-debunkers/
Profile Information
Gender: Do not displayMember since: Sun Dec 11, 2011, 06:54 PM
Number of posts: 12,482