American sitcoms are dealing with race more than ever, but too often the jokes reinforce stereotypes [View all]
https://slate.com/culture/2018/05/american-sitcoms-are-dealing-more-openly-with-race-but-not-always-getting-it-right.html
On CBSs Mom in the same week, a tipsy female character watches TV with a Hispanic man and says, Everythings in Mexican. He responds in Spanish, without subtitles, then he and his wife exit the scene as they continue speaking in Spanish, still without subtitles and over a laugh track. The Spanish language is reduced to a comedic prop, the meaning of the dialogue irrelevant with the implication that the humor lies in its loud foreignness. Were laughing at, not with.
Meanwhile, on NBCs Will & Grace, Will says to Joyce, Wow, youre tan. Joyce responds, Like Moana, but thin like Pocahontas. Contrary to popular misconception (perpetrated by quips just like this), Polynesians like the Disney character Moana are naturally dark-skinned, not tan versions of white. Such statements inaccurately imply an identity that can be easily appropriated while also subtly fetishizing brown womens bodies, the darker realities of skin color washed over to suit the punchline for a white gazepart of the reason why blackface is considered such an explicitly racist offense.
These references are not intentionally offensive, and some are probably even meant to be positive or inclusive. The fact that theyre comedic also makes them more challenging to debate, making critics seem like bad sports unable to take a joke. Mutual laughter can unite audiences, and sometimes comedy is meant to be controversial. But comedic context can also be a way of deflecting criticism about undeniably disparaging undertones. This becomes especially damaging when the laughter or controversy satisfies one group at the expense of another, creating more walls than connection because, as experiments have shown, messages of bias picked up through humor can lead to discriminatory behaviors.
(snip)
Furthermore, the same researchers found that not all stereotypes are created equal. Different groups have different degrees of immunity from humorous jabs, which means minorities and marginalized communities are more likely to suffer from discrimination than whites and other socially secure groups. Groups with more malleable social reputations, like gay men, are more likely to face increased discrimination because of comedic routines than those whose social standings are already fixed.
(more at link)