Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

PandoraAwakened

(905 posts)
109. Recognizing & Combatting "Tropes"
Mon Oct 8, 2018, 04:58 AM
Oct 2018

A "trope" is a common (and usually overused) theme or device employed in written and spoken language. Its purpose in the context of politics is to persuade, distract, and/or obfuscate from truth.

Kudos to the OP for bringing up one of the most egregious tropes of modern American political history: "Move on for the good of the country," which inevitably translates into a cornucopia of INACTION, including don't investigate, don't legislate, don't think, talk, or write about _____________ (see other replies to this post for several excellent historical examples with which you can fill-in-the blank).

I have heard it bemoaned for decades that Democrats are bad at messaging and I've unfortunately seen this to be too often true. I think one of the main reasons for this is a failure to understand language devices, such as tropes. This is both a failure to recognize when a trope is being used to frame the narrative and a failure in understanding how to combat a trope to reframe the narrative.

If you are still confused as to what I am talking about relative to the topic of this thread, let me give you a different example that should help bring this into sharp focus: There are two Republican tropes used after every mass shooting to ward off gun legislation and, indeed, to shut down all future discussion of such: The first is the "thoughts and prayers" trope, inevitably followed by the "now is not the time" trope (a variation of the "don't investigate for the good of the country" trope). Now do you understand? These are simply disingenuous rhetorical devices employed to make everyone look away. It's really that simple, and as evidenced over and over again, such tropes are highly effective.

So, how do you counter tropes? Well, thankfully, Shakespeare, one of history's greatest manipulators of the English language, provides a very clear blueprint for taking down a trope: You ridicule the hypocrisy of the trope publicly, loudly, mercilessly, unceasingly, and without apology until the trope itself is the object of derision, laughter, and scorn.

The most recent, modern example of how this works can be seen in how students nationwide have employed the "We call BS" campaign against all tropes that uphold and sustain gun violence. As evidence of the effectiveness of calling a trope onto the carpet, note that newsrooms everywhere have tapped down on their anchors' use of the "thoughts and prayers" trope lest they become memes and objects of derision themselves across the social media landscape.

So, while I can see how well-intentioned people might easily fall for the fake emotional appeal to not investigate this or that "for the good of the country," once you come to understand this for the trope that it is, one that even Shakespeare heartily mocked repeatedly, then it becomes your duty to educate and enlighten fellow Democrats about this ploy.

If a Dem is playing along with the "just move on" trope, call out the trope for what it is (and you can do this without ever mentioning the name of the hapless Dem). Make fun of and laugh at the hypocrisy of the trope repeatedly and mercilessly until they stop letting others who are just a little more clever about the use of rhetorical devices continue to play them for fools.

At that, to those who still wish to see no evil, hear no evil "for the good of the country," I CALL BS! Let the investigations begin and MAKE AMERICA LAUGH AGAIN!


It's always off the table when we have the power. Voltaire2 Oct 2018 #1
This has to change. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #3
+1 OnDoutside Oct 2018 #8
+101010 populistdriven Oct 2018 #88
until the left stops ignoring 1500 coordinated radio stations we're playing defense certainot Oct 2018 #91
Gotta get people to buy what we're selling. MadDAsHell Oct 2018 #96
That something is called "money" DBoon Oct 2018 #101
+1 betsuni Oct 2018 #103
The Fairness Doctrine Roy Rolling Oct 2018 #113
mom and pop vs wall mart. the idea that it's demand is like suggesting 95% of americans certainot Oct 2018 #106
Pelosi took impeachment off the table when Dems won the 2006 midterms Martin Eden Oct 2018 #16
Again? Bear Creek Oct 2018 #17
Curious do you know what it takes to impeach and convict? still_one Oct 2018 #24
For impeachment, you have to lie about getting a blow job in the oval office. CentralMass Oct 2018 #30
Actually, impeachment is whatever the house decides it to be. However, I was asking the other still_one Oct 2018 #31
I understood. I was making the point that far more serious offenses have been overlooked. CentralMass Oct 2018 #34
I know Central, and you are absolutely right still_one Oct 2018 #35
+roflmao traladeda Oct 2018 #42
It doesn't matter. Impeachment hearings would have exposed the crimes against humanity. 3Hotdogs Oct 2018 #60
Ok, whatever up u say bud. I will be GOTV by canvassing still_one Oct 2018 #73
I guess the resignation of Bush Defender Gonzales and all the public hearings.. JHan Oct 2018 #82
Absolutely J. Convenient memories are amazing still_one Oct 2018 #83
People could do with remembering what things were like in 2006 JHan Oct 2018 #118
They sure could still_one Oct 2018 #119
How many Bush administration officials actually paid for their crimes? issuesDemocrats Oct 2018 #84
Do you recall the challenges Obama faced when he came into office.. JHan Oct 2018 #117
Post removed Post removed Oct 2018 #86
Equally curious, can you acknowledge there is a difference between... JHB Oct 2018 #63
No, because I disagree it would be "venal showboating" Martin Eden Oct 2018 #75
By "venal showboating", I had in mind the impeachment of Bill Clinton... JHB Oct 2018 #85
Two thirds in the Senate Martin Eden Oct 2018 #72
Be careful M.E. I was alerted for saying the same thing about Pelosi last year Submariner Oct 2018 #53
Exactly. The same shit I was alerted on --- that and other stuff that offended and was designed to 3Hotdogs Oct 2018 #59
Can you be alerted for alerting me to that potential alert? Martin Eden Oct 2018 #74
She has not posted to this thread so maybe we are in the clear Submariner Oct 2018 #87
Exactly! Duppers Oct 2018 #40
Al Franken Voices Of Reason Oct 2018 #114
People on this board attack me when I said Obama was wrong not to investigate. olegramps Oct 2018 #70
Message auto-removed Name removed Oct 2018 #2
So, no more excuses. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #5
Really? I hope you are enjoying your stay here still_one Oct 2018 #7
We have to investigate for the good of the country. smirkymonkey Oct 2018 #4
Exactly, most people don't know how bad it is. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #10
Gee, I guess those self-identified progressives who refused to vote for the Democratic nominee in still_one Oct 2018 #6
Your argument is a false equivalence. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #11
First of all the Democrats have indicated they will invetigate Kavanaugh if they win the midterms. still_one Oct 2018 #15
Good post Andy823 Oct 2018 #33
But "indicated" is not doing it. I doubt they ever will. LiberalLovinLug Oct 2018 #57
Meanwhile, lock her up dalton99a Oct 2018 #9
Play offense. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #12
Rethugs play by a different set of rules Martin Eden Oct 2018 #13
We have been on the correct side of the facts Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #14
Because if we bring 2 knives, it means we're trying to take their guns away. Volaris Oct 2018 #49
They are not baby seals. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #56
I'll take that description as it's accurate. Volaris Oct 2018 #58
Amen! I am sick and tired of the Dems being so easily silenced. pdsimdars Oct 2018 #18
Yep! n/t JoeOtterbein Oct 2018 #19
Republicans lie, cheat, and steal elections and then run over Democrats with a Mack truck. Lonestarblue Oct 2018 #20
M$M landed hard on Howard Dean for one yell. Duppers Oct 2018 #44
Still think Dean stood the best chance of sending Shrub packing Jake Stern Oct 2018 #52
Totally agree. Duppers Oct 2018 #64
I totally disagree karynnj Oct 2018 #90
I read the crowd noise was minimized to make the scream sound louder & more prominent CrispyQ Oct 2018 #67
Let's not forget that the corporate media watoos Oct 2018 #21
Thank you for saying this RockCreek Oct 2018 #36
2nd that. Duppers Oct 2018 #46
I hope Rachel Maddow and Chris Hayes Varaddem Oct 2018 #69
That's who they are. lsewpershad Oct 2018 #22
It keeps coming back to bringing a knife to a gunfight. Doodley Oct 2018 #23
https://progressive.org/op-eds/howard-zinn-despair-supreme-court/ Firestorm49 Oct 2018 #25
And we always do what we are told. n/t Polly Hennessey Oct 2018 #26
"No more Mr. Nice Guy!" BadgerMom Oct 2018 #27
"for the good of the country" as in "don't do this, or riots will happen; profits will be at risk" anarch Oct 2018 #28
I hope all the party leaders have learned a very important lesson elmac Oct 2018 #29
This is why McConnell/Trump are zentrum Oct 2018 #32
They are counting on it. Power 2 the People Oct 2018 #39
Completely Agree Scubamatt Oct 2018 #41
Exactly. zentrum Oct 2018 #50
+1 Power 2 the People Oct 2018 #37
Will never forget Reid saying he didn't believe McConnell's assertion that GOP's #1 job was to block JudyM Oct 2018 #38
There is a crying need for Democrats to go "full Avenatti." VOX Oct 2018 #43
The sad truth is that it's going to take a pit bull to defeat Trump. Jake Stern Oct 2018 #61
It's a fact. The Democratic candidate has to go straight at him and unload. VOX Oct 2018 #62
Amen Baitball. Let's put the Kumbaya shit in the closet. NoMoreRepugs Oct 2018 #45
We are fooling ourselves if we think winning in chamber KPN Oct 2018 #47
Every time we're told to let something go dflprincess Oct 2018 #48
Exactly this. shanny Oct 2018 #76
Ford's pardon of Nixon set the precedent of muntrv Oct 2018 #51
yes yes YES rurallib Oct 2018 #65
Exactly! shanny Oct 2018 #77
Yes, glad you mentioned this robbob Oct 2018 #95
I remember when Pelosi said "impeachment is off the table". riverwalker Oct 2018 #54
Rec & 100% agree. It's time to turn into assholes. n/t SpankMe Oct 2018 #55
9/11 rescued Bush's presidency. DemocratSinceBirth Oct 2018 #66
Careful. You will be called a defeatist. CrispyQ Oct 2018 #68
For the good of the country? TryLogic Oct 2018 #71
I'm old, but I so miss Senator Lyndon Johnson... rickyhall Oct 2018 #78
NEVER FORGET Grasswire2 Oct 2018 #79
They outshout us, every time. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #80
Kavanaugh was part of the Brooks Brothers assault that shut down the voting in 2000. SunSeeker Oct 2018 #97
Too bad he wasn't in the picture. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #98
Now you're beginning to hear the drumbeat of whining from thuglicans of .... LenaBaby61 Oct 2018 #102
Strongly Agree jimlup Oct 2018 #81
the media can do its job for once. pansypoo53219 Oct 2018 #89
They are fired up now, though it might be too little too late. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #93
You forgot telling Kerry not to investigate 2004 when Ken Blackwell helped them steal Ohio for Bush Amaryllis Oct 2018 #92
+1,000 Loubee Oct 2018 #94
IMO, you are putting this way too mildly... rwsanders Oct 2018 #99
Of course, if Gore had won any of 10 States that Clinton won, Florida would have been meaningless brooklynite Oct 2018 #100
I completely agree ellie Oct 2018 #104
YES!!! F THAT!!!! EndGOPPropaganda Oct 2018 #105
Which was utter garbage I would add. roamer65 Oct 2018 #107
Accountability for crimes HAD BETTER be on the table when we take back power. PatrickforO Oct 2018 #108
Recognizing & Combatting "Tropes" PandoraAwakened Oct 2018 #109
Jesus. So informative. Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #110
Still a newbie here PandoraAwakened Oct 2018 #111
Do you mind if I bring attention to your post? Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #116
No problem, please share as necessary PandoraAwakened Oct 2018 #120
Totally agree Ohioboy Oct 2018 #112
Right, and we are always playing defense with them because we allow Baitball Blogger Oct 2018 #115
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»They told Gore not to inv...»Reply #109