Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

johnlucas

(1,250 posts)
Mon Sep 3, 2012, 01:13 AM Sep 2012

Message to Llewlladdwr & all other Southerners: Perspective on the South bashing. [View all]

There was a thread started by poster Llewlladdwr called And "Bash the South" time is here again where Llewlladdwr put up links to 2 DU threads titled Why Do So Many Southerners Think They're the Only Real Americans? by applegrove & Let's not pretend that condescension is unique to the North by marmar.
Both posters linked to one Alternet article written by Chuck Thompson.

I've been at DU for a few years now & I do see a lot of grief given to The South in general.
Some posters take it too far with the "let 'em secede" nonsense (which reminds me of the "let California fall off into the ocean" crap) but I wanted to reply to Llewlladdwr's thread to explain why the South-bashing goes on & how to stop it.
Unfortunately the thread was locked so I couldn't post my reply.

I put up this thread to give perspective on the issue.
I titled my original reply "I live in the South. They bash the South for a reason"

The South as a whole still will not get over its xenophobic ways.
Because they're so xenophobic, they champion the destroyers in the Republican Party trying to get back at those "Others" they fear.
The White working class/"middle class" should be side by side with our cause but as a whole they're not.
They prop up the guys most determined to destroy the safety net & the idea of reciprocation that a society needs to survive.

Some White folks of the working/"middle" classes are with us, sure, but as a whole the Republican Party shows through all the so-called "Red States" how many of these people willingly & enthusiastically vote against their interests.
How is Rush Limbaugh getting all these ratings? How Fox News able to exist as a "news" channel?
Why would anybody support such a xenophobic/war-hungry/destructive platform as the Conservative Movement?

They shouldn't have 40% of the vote locked up. At best they should get 5% since there will always be crazies & crackpots.
The South is one of the strongholds keeping the Conservative Movement & the Republican Party which contains it alive.

So until the South changes AS A WHOLE, people are gonna bash the South in frustration at the Conservatives'/Republicans' continued existence.
I wouldn't take it personally if you are NOT part of this xenophobic clique.
They're not talking about you. They're talking about the bigots who cause the country to regress instead of progress.

Didn't we just hear that story about a Class of 1973 Louisiana class reunion sending out 'Whites only' on the flyer?
Check the comment boards under the various publications of this story.
Can you pick out who's a White bigot & who's not based on the responses?

The South has got work to do to redeem its image & people like you are the ones who can redeem it.
Quit spending your energy being mad at your teammates rightfully bashing the ignorance held in the South & start spending your energy being mad at the Southerners holding that ignorance.

Here's another thing: It ain't JUST the South that's holding that ignorance.
Wipe it out EVERYWHERE but start in your own backyard first.
John Lucas
61 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
THANK YOU Skittles Sep 2012 #1
It's easy to lose perspective when you think you're being attacked johnlucas Sep 2012 #2
The problem is that SOUTHERNERS need to be doing the correcting... Fawke Em Sep 2012 #27
You SHOULD care. But take your anger out on the ones bringing The South down johnlucas Sep 2012 #36
Yes they do, but we both know they won't and we both know why. And until Y'all stop raising your Egalitarian Thug Sep 2012 #44
OK a million and one props to all the DUers in the red states K8-EEE Sep 2012 #3
We have the "John Birchers" out here (they quit calling themselves that, though) SoCalDem Sep 2012 #50
I grew up in Alabama Scootaloo Sep 2012 #4
it wasn't a long time ago when Texas WAS a blue state... rppper Sep 2012 #6
That was back when the racists had not yet fully left the Democratic Party. Odin2005 Sep 2012 #17
Thank you for this... BeeBee Sep 2012 #5
That's rightly so, johnlucas Jack Sprat Sep 2012 #7
1948 & 1964 is what changed johnlucas Sep 2012 #25
I do not even engage with them. Manifestor_of_Light Sep 2012 #8
Hmm .. but what about my vote here in Georgia? YOHABLO Sep 2012 #9
Ah yes, that stupid argument. Zoeisright Sep 2012 #13
Can you respect that the South is my home? Llewlladdwr Sep 2012 #10
the MAJORITY of people in your "home" are racist pieces of shit scheming daemons Sep 2012 #21
No they're not. Fawke Em Sep 2012 #29
Radio is a BIG reason why it continues johnlucas Sep 2012 #46
I have said the same thing MuseRider Sep 2012 #47
Disagree. area51 Sep 2012 #11
Guilty. Hulk Sep 2012 #12
Locking. UnrepentantLiberal Sep 2012 #14
Unlocking thread. UnrepentantLiberal Sep 2012 #15
That Birtherism is concentrated in the South tells me everything... Odin2005 Sep 2012 #16
Riiight. Orly Taitz is CA. Trump's in New York. DirkGently Sep 2012 #18
Read my post about The Southern Strategy johnlucas Sep 2012 #45
Bingo TroglodyteScholar Sep 2012 #19
There is a flaw in your rationalization of South bashing aikoaiko Sep 2012 #20
That tactic is the calling card of crappy call-out rhetoric here. DirkGently Sep 2012 #24
A better way of direction. Jack Sprat Sep 2012 #55
We're closer than before, sure, but it's still a major problem johnlucas Sep 2012 #26
I whole-heartedly disagree. Fawke Em Sep 2012 #30
Let me know when it's 75% or more in any Northern state. dawg Sep 2012 #33
Well good point but here's a few that approach that number johnlucas Sep 2012 #41
It's wrong to single out any one region. dawg Sep 2012 #43
While recognizing that there are certainly progressive sufrommich Sep 2012 #22
Yes! There is a very good reason that "exceptional southerners" are considered to be...exceptional Tom Ripley Sep 2012 #32
That apparently took nearly 30 years to work. Fawke Em Sep 2012 #39
It goes back further than that, Fawke. Jack Sprat Sep 2012 #51
Here is a position with a longer history of the southern strategy Jack Sprat Sep 2012 #53
The basic problem with all of these threads is that the South is not monolithic. alarimer Sep 2012 #23
And never has been Adsos Letter Sep 2012 #28
True. So people should consider making an honest active commitment to "small" again. nt patrice Sep 2012 #34
And yet my relative moved to NC with her dark skinned cuban boyfriend and was accosted repeatedly. progressivebydesign Sep 2012 #38
Love this!!! One thing: Changing the South "as a whole", if that's what we are waiting for before patrice Sep 2012 #31
Yes you must work within your circle of influence before anything else johnlucas Sep 2012 #57
It's all way overwhelming when you look at the whole thing. Need to start believing in small things patrice Sep 2012 #58
Oh, and one more thing...: Aristus Sep 2012 #35
We do call it out and make fun of it. Fawke Em Sep 2012 #40
Thank you. Keep up the good work. Aristus Sep 2012 #48
I respect that Fawke Em. Thank you johnlucas Sep 2012 #49
Beautifully put!! I'm on the West Coast and don't take insults about it personally. progressivebydesign Sep 2012 #37
Gotta tell ya, a huge amount of the people in my part of the south originated in the NORTH. 1monster Sep 2012 #42
Sad. How is it not bigoted to bash an entire region? Skip Intro Sep 2012 #52
Why are you taking it personally? We're calling out the bigoted mentality not the region johnlucas Sep 2012 #59
Since our efforts were futile last night Jack Sprat Sep 2012 #54
I think I missed the importance of 1968 & RFK johnlucas Sep 2012 #60
Here's something about the North South conflict moving into the Civil war flamingdem Sep 2012 #56
Charlotte NC and Boston MA cwydro Sep 2012 #61
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Message to Llewlladdwr &a...