Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Lonestarblue

(9,977 posts)
19. Your are right that Texas has had huge influence on what is taught in most subjects everywhere.
Sun Sep 20, 2020, 09:45 AM
Sep 2020

To understand the Texas influence, you need to know some background. The US has a K-12 education system of open territory states and state adoption states (22 states mostly in the South and Southwest). In open adoption states, schools choose their curriculum materials. In state adoption states, like Texas, schools choose from a state-approved list of textbooks.

To get approved in a state, publishers must exactly follow the curriculum the state has established. The state board of education sets standards and approves text materials. Because of the cost of developing nationwide curriculum materials, Texas thus has an outsized influence on national textbooks. Part of this influence formerly related to money, as Texas used to purchase 110% of all textbooks anticipated to be needed for the full five years of an adoption period. In Texas, that’s a huge chunk of money. They no longer do this, and the rules for approval of books have also changed somewhat for the better, but Texas still wields enormous influence simply because of its market size. So does California, which does state approvals for K-8 only.

In the 1980s through the early 2000s, the Texas Board of Education was filled with rabid anti-science, anti-history nuts who believed more in a religious curriculum than in educating kids with the truth. We have less rabid people elected to the Board today because it was getting so much public ridicule for being flat-out crazy. The legacy of the past still lingers in textbooks, however, because publishers revise only a small portion of their content with each new edition because of cost. They mostly update for changes and to meet any new curriculum standards.

The upshot is that Republicans in the state-adoption states have controlled the writing of curriculum stands for each subject. Their conservative, religious, white views are what is represented in today’s textbooks.

"Trump read Howard Zinn" is as believable as "Trump is a Zen master". oasis Sep 2020 #1
or patriotic citizen, or loving father, or accomplished businessman... pecosbob Sep 2020 #2
Or human... N_E_1 for Tennis Sep 2020 #3
Stephen Miller read Zinn.... paleotn Sep 2020 #14
I figured Miller was his source. Trump's intellect oasis Sep 2020 #27
Yup. Unless the guy that designed menus at Epstein's place was named Howard, that's as close as dameatball Sep 2020 #16
The Goal: Multi-cultural "American" History goes down the Memory Hole. no_hypocrisy Sep 2020 #4
Well, I believe you already have to sign an anti-BDS clause to get a teaching job in Texas pecosbob Sep 2020 #5
BDS? Nexus2 Sep 2020 #6
You have to sign a clause saying you will not boycott Israeli made products or businesses pecosbob Sep 2020 #7
Thanks! Nexus2 Sep 2020 #24
When I first got my teaching license, Reagan was in office. no_hypocrisy Sep 2020 #8
jeezus BlancheSplanchnik Sep 2020 #10
Probably depends on where you teach. paleotn Sep 2020 #18
Trump is scattering bucolic_frolic Sep 2020 #9
In the archives of my brain, I seem to recall that during or shortly after George W's reign, Frustratedlady Sep 2020 #11
I recall that as well pecosbob Sep 2020 #12
Your are right that Texas has had huge influence on what is taught in most subjects everywhere. Lonestarblue Sep 2020 #19
Thank you. I did not know some of this. I'm glad to hear the current group isn't as bat shit crazy PatrickforO Sep 2020 #21
Thank you for taking the time to educate me on publishing textbooks in Texas. Frustratedlady Sep 2020 #28
You're most welcome. It's a topic dear to my heart since I spent my career in education. Lonestarblue Sep 2020 #30
Truth isn't something the right wingers are familiar with. llmart Sep 2020 #13
Truth lives, Donnie. paleotn Sep 2020 #15
Trump doesn't want history books to tell the truth about him. zanana1 Sep 2020 #17
Howard Zinn was a giant. I just wish the schools taught MORE of the unvarnished truth, PatrickforO Sep 2020 #20
trump is the worst propagandist in the land. barbtries Sep 2020 #22
That Trump even knows who Zinn is, is complete bullshit. AngryOldDem Sep 2020 #23
I'm not a huge fan of Zinn, but Trump has no idea who he is Azathoth Sep 2020 #25
How about some "re-education camps"? moondust Sep 2020 #26
Trump does not even know who Howard Zinn is. I am certain of it. smirkymonkey Sep 2020 #29
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump trashes Howard Zinn...»Reply #19