HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Joyce White Vance: If you... » Reply #10

Response to Crunchy Frog (Reply #2)

Thu Dec 10, 2020, 07:39 PM

10. I suggest you read (or reread) the relevant consequences of the Partition of India in 1947

Those immediate consequences being multiple refugee crises, large-scale violence, vast numbers of missing people, and famine, as well as post-partition migrations resulting violence too. What precise mechanisms would be used to avoid these issues? And would those mechanisms be legal, military, or extra-judicial law-enforcement in their nature?



"It's either separate from them or be devoured by them..."
What then specifically leads you to believe there are two and only two valid options to choose from when so many additional possibilities exist?



It seems to me (not *is*, but *seems* ) that you're taking a rather simplistic, or at least shallow view, of an inherently complex problem, ignoring the inherent consequential issues. If you can objectively address the aforementioned issues and the legal/social/financial/military mechanisms used to achieve them peacefully, I'd certainly like to hear them.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 71 replies Author Time Post
mcar Dec 2020 OP
Karadeniz Dec 2020 #1
Crunchy Frog Dec 2020 #2
niyad Dec 2020 #4
CTyankee Dec 2020 #33
Big Blue Marble Dec 2020 #36
CTyankee Dec 2020 #41
mentalsolstice Dec 2020 #60
dawg day Dec 2020 #5
bdamomma Dec 2020 #6
HUAJIAO Dec 2020 #32
handmade34 Dec 2020 #7
Big Blue Marble Dec 2020 #9
TomSlick Dec 2020 #25
Crunchy Frog Dec 2020 #59
LineLineReply I suggest you read (or reread) the relevant consequences of the Partition of India in 1947
LanternWaste Dec 2020 #10
mcar Dec 2020 #12
Crunchy Frog Dec 2020 #53
fescuerescue Dec 2020 #26
TomSlick Dec 2020 #27
mcar Dec 2020 #43
Sucha NastyWoman Dec 2020 #42
csziggy Dec 2020 #62
Crunchy Frog Dec 2020 #63
oldsoftie Dec 2020 #64
Hortensis Dec 2020 #3
mcar Dec 2020 #11
appalachiablue Dec 2020 #8
rickyhall Dec 2020 #13
Turin_C3PO Dec 2020 #15
keopeli Dec 2020 #31
electric_blue68 Dec 2020 #40
BobTheSubgenius Dec 2020 #18
rickyhall Dec 2020 #20
drray23 Dec 2020 #30
BobTheSubgenius Dec 2020 #14
Turin_C3PO Dec 2020 #16
trof Dec 2020 #17
BobTheSubgenius Dec 2020 #19
trof Dec 2020 #24
mcar Dec 2020 #45
AleksS Dec 2020 #21
trof Dec 2020 #29
electric_blue68 Dec 2020 #46
AleksS Dec 2020 #57
mcar Dec 2020 #47
hurl Dec 2020 #22
Cha Dec 2020 #23
misanthrope Dec 2020 #28
mcar Dec 2020 #49
oldsoftie Dec 2020 #65
mcar Dec 2020 #66
Caliman73 Dec 2020 #34
albacore Dec 2020 #38
Caliman73 Dec 2020 #52
albacore Dec 2020 #54
Caliman73 Dec 2020 #58
Joinfortmill Dec 2020 #35
bringthePaine Dec 2020 #37
albacore Dec 2020 #39
ooky Dec 2020 #44
JoeOtterbein Dec 2020 #48
mcar Dec 2020 #50
JoeOtterbein Dec 2020 #55
ecstatic Dec 2020 #71
SpankMe Dec 2020 #51
mcar Dec 2020 #67
Blaukraut Dec 2020 #56
LeftInTX Dec 2020 #61
pwb Dec 2020 #68
ecstatic Dec 2020 #69
dalton99a Dec 2020 #70
Please login to view edit histories.