HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Do we really need the Sen... » Reply #6

Response to GentleAlien (Original post)

Mon Mar 1, 2021, 05:12 AM

6. I'll answer

Biden Can Single-Handedly Run The Reconciliation Process: Parliamentarian Experts (VIDEO)

Two experts in the arcane rules of the Senate said on Monday that, as president of the Senate, Biden has the capacity not just to overrule any ruling that the parliamentarian may make but also to cut off efforts by Republicans to offer unlimited amendments.

“Ultimately it’s the Vice President of the United States [who has the power over the reconciliation process],” Robert Dove, who served as Senate parliamentarian on and off from 1981-2001, told MSNBC this morning. “It is the decision of the Vice President whether or not to play a role here... And I have seen Vice Presidents play that role in other very important situations... The parliamentarian can only advise. It is the vice president who rules.”


The title “Senate parliamentarian” is so distinguished that one might easily assume it dates back to the 18th century. In fact, the post was created in 1935 in revolt against John Nance Garner, the vice president who famously said his office wasn’t worth “a bucket of warm piss” and who apparently worked out his frustrations by rendering as president of the Senate questionable parliamentary rulings. Only three people held the post before Frumin and Dove’s 28-year do-si-do. According to Dove, Vice President Hubert Humphrey routinely ignored his parliamentarian’s advice. Might Vice President Joe Biden do the same with health care? Dove sees it as a “more plausible” prospect with Biden than it might be with other vice presidents because Biden (like Humphrey) is a former senator who can draw on personal familiarity with Senate procedure. He’s also (I would add) kind of a know-it-all, an annoying quality in many contexts but a potentially useful one here.


These articles are from when Biden was VP but the excerpts answers your question.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 33 replies Author Time Post
GentleAlien Mar 1 OP
Irish_Dem Mar 1 #1
Demsrule86 Mar 1 #18
Irish_Dem Mar 2 #26
Demsrule86 Mar 2 #28
GentleAlien Mar 2 #25
Irish_Dem Mar 2 #27
SCantiGOP Mar 1 #2
Fullduplexxx Mar 1 #7
SCantiGOP Mar 1 #13
Fullduplexxx Mar 1 #15
Fullduplexxx Mar 1 #17
Demsrule86 Mar 1 #19
Demsrule86 Mar 2 #29
Fullduplexxx Mar 2 #31
moonscape Mar 1 #3
Celerity Mar 1 #5
Budi Mar 1 #4
GentleAlien Mar 1 #11
Demsrule86 Mar 1 #20
LineReply I'll answer
AZProgressive Mar 1 #6
Sgent Mar 1 #8
GentleAlien Mar 1 #9
Sgent Mar 1 #12
Demsrule86 Mar 1 #21
GentleAlien Mar 1 #24
Demsrule86 Mar 2 #30
Demsrule86 Mar 1 #23
WhiskeyGrinder Mar 1 #10
librechik Mar 1 #14
GentleAlien Mar 1 #16
Demsrule86 Mar 1 #22
LetMyPeopleVote Mar 6 #32
GentleAlien Mar 6 #33
Please login to view edit histories.