Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

unblock

(54,540 posts)
13. The car can't choose to kill the driver over someone else
Tue Jan 18, 2022, 11:10 PM
Jan 2022

The life of the driver counts no more or less than the others

*the driver* ought to choose self sacrifice, if they were making the decision

But the *ai system* is not sacrificing itself to save anyone

The *ai system* has no basis in that moment to identify with the driver and self-sacrifice to save the others. To the *ai system*, they're *all* others.

It has no basis on which to choose to kill one to save the others.



I have my cheeky answer though, which is what I think Elon musk would do:

The ai system should hit the building, killing the driver, but record data showing the human driver disengaged autopilot and took over seconds before the crash and selflessly veered away from the pedestrians, killing himself and dying a hero.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Your job to save others bottomofthehill Jan 2022 #1
Oh, boy, first one I could not answer. Polly Hennessey Jan 2022 #2
It is tough Renew Deal Jan 2022 #3
Wait. What did I just say. Oh, dear after more thought it would be the brick wall. Polly Hennessey Jan 2022 #5
The answer is easy... hit the republican. nt Lucid Dreamer Jan 2022 #38
If you speak with a self-driving car system engineer C_U_L8R Jan 2022 #4
People are designed the same way. Renew Deal Jan 2022 #7
It should hit Elon Musk DBoon Jan 2022 #6
More to the point... Takket Jan 2022 #8
That makes sense Renew Deal Jan 2022 #9
Kobayashi Maru nt. BlueIdaho Jan 2022 #10
Would you buy a car that is programmed to kill you? The Revolution Jan 2022 #11
What if, even if programmed to kill the driver... ret5hd Jan 2022 #15
That is the right question to ask. Renew Deal Jan 2022 #21
Serpentine and hit them all Hassin Bin Sober Jan 2022 #12
Best reply yet! "de-AI-th race 2050" ret5hd Jan 2022 #17
Lol. Machine Gun Joe Viterbo Hassin Bin Sober Jan 2022 #24
The car can't choose to kill the driver over someone else unblock Jan 2022 #13
These are in my neighborhood every day. n/t ChazII Jan 2022 #14
My son and I had this conversation. Corgigal Jan 2022 #16
I was thinking about ForgedCrank Jan 2022 #19
I could never ForgedCrank Jan 2022 #18
The Three Laws of I Robot... madinmaryland Jan 2022 #20
All other systems in a car are designed to protect the driver EarlG Jan 2022 #22
Mitch Mc Connell. roamer65 Jan 2022 #23
Well at least there's no choice for hitting the dog. milestogo Jan 2022 #25
Simple. WarGamer Jan 2022 #26
I like how the default is death. Of someone. flvegan Jan 2022 #27
Best option is not listed Diablo del sol Jan 2022 #28
The best option is not to leave the road Disaffected Jan 2022 #29
This message was self-deleted by its author sarcasmo Jan 2022 #30
Couldn't I, as the passenger, rownesheck Jan 2022 #31
There really isn't enough information to make a proper decision. PTWB Jan 2022 #32
You have to assume the computer is behaving prudently. Renew Deal Jan 2022 #33
the passenger made the decision to own and ride in a self driving car... let them take the risk Demovictory9 Jan 2022 #34
Not a realistic scenario. lagomorph777 Jan 2022 #35
It is basically edhopper Jan 2022 #36
There should NOT be totally autonomous operations on public roads. Lucid Dreamer Jan 2022 #37
It should LetsGoBiden Jan 2022 #39
If some drunk pedestrian runs out into traffic on the highway, the vehicle should self destruct... PTWB Jan 2022 #40
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»If an autonomous vehicle ...»Reply #13