Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hlthe2b

(106,571 posts)
5. I was assigned this topic as a junior high student for an essay that we were given
Thu Oct 20, 2022, 04:35 PM
Oct 2022

the entire term to research, consider and write/present prior to the end of the school year. I took it very seriously and portions of my piece were excerpted for the then-local newspaper that published both sides of the debate. Mine presented the anti-DP POV, focusing largely on two issues: 1) whether the government--any government had the right to kill its citizens-- the risks of such authority being extended beyond any possible rationale under a non-democratic change in government; and 2) the inability to prevent wrongly accused from being executed, no matter the precautions.

I've never wavered. Since then both issues that formed my argument against the DP have not only come to pass but have become clear beyond what I could have imagined at the time. In a word, TEXAS!

So many like to conflate opposition to the DP with believing all are able to be rehabilitated OR conversely that there are not some who are truly deserving of it. Neither is true for me. My reasons now are as they were highlighted in my treatise then. The act is singularly permanent and mistakes that arise can never be made right. But even more frightening is the thought of what we those in power can unleash who seek its terrorizing impacts to control more than those presumed guilty of murder.

I'm against it in nearly all cases, temporary311 Oct 2022 #1
No government should be allowed to kill its subjects unblock Oct 2022 #2
+1000 USALiberal Oct 2022 #14
I understand why people think it is right in some cases Skittles Oct 2022 #3
Other than a Corporate Death penalty for malfeasance or criminal actions, no. haele Oct 2022 #4
By a corporate death penalty iemanja Oct 2022 #9
Dissolution of the corporation, and loss of licences for the officers. haele Oct 2022 #20
I was assigned this topic as a junior high student for an essay that we were given hlthe2b Oct 2022 #5
Killing people should not be within the purview... dchill Oct 2022 #6
It's for evil people caught red-handed with multiple pieces of corroborating evidence bucolic_frolic Oct 2022 #7
I am against the death penalty in all cases. It is state murder. Both my husband and I have Demsrule86 Oct 2022 #21
oppose IcyPeas Oct 2022 #8
The fact that Russia is in the "Abolished in practice" category and.. Xolodno Oct 2022 #16
Oppose in all cases. PufPuf23 Oct 2022 #10
I oppose because innocent people are killed. gab13by13 Oct 2022 #11
Exactly and just one innocent person killed is horrible and not worth a billion murderers dying. nt Quixote1818 Oct 2022 #22
I am a peaceful man gibraltar72 Oct 2022 #12
It's never necessary, I can't believe anybody on this board is pro death penalty USALiberal Oct 2022 #13
There are some people who do such horrendous things that they should forfeit their lives. Chainfire Oct 2022 #15
I am against the death penalty, but as long as the majority support it in a democracy JCMach1 Oct 2022 #17
"People should see and understand the consequences of their choices." WhiskeyGrinder Oct 2022 #19
Referring to voters... But more of a modest proposal, but one I believe in JCMach1 Oct 2022 #23
Ah, I see. Strongly disagree, though. WhiskeyGrinder Oct 2022 #24
Idiosyncratic thing... I just think if you support killing in the name of the people, JCMach1 Oct 2022 #29
I think too many people would get off on it iemanja Oct 2022 #31
Abolish it. WhiskeyGrinder Oct 2022 #18
A great many people in favor of the death penalty are a-holes. I don't want to be in their boat. Tetrachloride Oct 2022 #25
The death penalty serves no redeeming purpose except perhaps Disaffected Oct 2022 #26
Oppose, except for genocide and mass murder n/t Just_Vote_Dem Oct 2022 #27
I'm okay with it in theory Zeitghost Oct 2022 #28
Yeah, that's where I am. LeftInTX Oct 2022 #33
Some criminals just aren't suited for life w/o parole LeftInTX Oct 2022 #30
In ultra rare occasions I'm okay with it sky_masterson Oct 2022 #32
It should be abolished. Solly Mack Oct 2022 #34
I think criminal punishment reflects who we are as a society iemanja Oct 2022 #35
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What are your views on th...»Reply #5