Manning Up: The Just Actions of a ‘Fan of Sunshine’ [View all]
http://www.commondreams.org/view/2012/12/02-3
Whatever ones views about his alleged actions, you would need a pretty hard shell not to be moved by the case of Bradley Manning. Hero to some, traitor to others, this diminutive soldier has endured an unprecedented level of mistreatment, languishing in a largely incommunicado pretrial state for more than two years and facing repeated episodes of humiliation and degradation. Compounding this case is Mannings status as a gay solider, for which he had experienced repercussions well before gaining international notoriety as a purported Wikileaks source for some of the whistleblowing sites most damning allegations about governmental and military machinations around the world.
Being accused of revealing the emperors new clothes is likely to land one in hot water, but Mannings treatment has crossed all bounds of fairness, decency, and legality. Having ones life stripped down (literally) to its most basic functions, being confined in a space barely the size of a standard bathroom, having to formally ask even for toilet paper while standing at attention, and getting access to the outdoors for only 20 minutes per day is the sort of thing that could drive anyone mad. The fact that the military has justified the conditions of Mannings confinement by asserting that he was a suicide risk is a specious argument; being in such a state can cause one to seek any way out, and putting all options on the table is more a sign of sanity than the opposite.
We can speculate how any of us would hold up in similar circumstances, which hopefully well never have to find out. But the art and science of breaking down the human spirit is quite well-developed by now, and the harshness of Mannings confinement is likely intended as a warning and deterrent to anyone else even contemplating blowing the whistle on the architects of empire. It is thus all the more important and impressive that Manning has endured this brutal captivity -- doing so through methods like dancing in his cell, working out with imaginary weights, and making faces at himself in the small mirror on the wall. Indeed, as Michael Ratner of the Center for Constitutional Rights observed upon attending the recent hearing on Mannings confinement, the testimony Manning gave showed him to be dignified, articulate, smart and self-aware
. His incredible sincerity and strength was visible to all. We are lucky to have people with the courage of Bradley Manning.
Where Manning found this resolve will likely be a subject for biographers someday, but early signs indicate that the military itself may have ironically contributed to it. From his first days as a soldier, Manning seemed to be ill-suited for the role, at least in the eyes of some of his colleagues. In an interview with The Guardian, an anonymous soldier who served with Manning recalls the situation: The kid was barely 5ft -- he was a runt. And by military standards and compared with everyone who was around there -- he was a runt. By military standards, hes a runt so pick on him, or hes crazy -- pick on him, or hes a faggot -- pick on him. The guy took it from every side. He couldnt please anyone. And he tried. He really did
. A lot of people let him down. He is not the first one they let down and he is not the last one. If we subscribe to the school of thought that says our scars make us stronger, then Mannings early duress may have steeled him for what would come later.