Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ShazzieB

(19,319 posts)
38. I don't think so.
Mon Nov 11, 2024, 04:16 PM
Nov 2024

Sorry, but this touched a nerve for me. The idea of blaming the stupidity of American voters on obesity is disturbing to me. Fat people get stigmatized too much already. (If that's not what you meant to imply, please accept my apologies for misunderstanding.)

If I'm reading right, this was one small study done on a cohort of only 175 subjects. In my opinion, that's not nearly enough data to be conclusive or upon which to base any assumptions about the cognitive functioning of fat people in general. Besides, I know far too many smart fat people who vote blue and far to many stupid skinny people to find this convincing. Anecdata, I know, but I can't discount it completely.

I'm sure you had absolutely no ill intentions in posting this, but I'm afraid that some could come away with an oversimplified impression that fat people in general are stupid, and I wanted to register my discomfort with that possibility.

In case anyone wonders, I am a formerly obese person who lost a large amount of weight with the help of bariatric surgery. I'm now at a healthy weight, neither clinically obese nor as thin as many would consider "ideal." I am also not one bit smarter now than I was when I was fat. I swear! (I know, more anecdata, but still.)

I apologize if I seem to be overeacting, but as I said, this touched a nerve. Even though I'm no longer obese, I still have a lot of feels about the stigma fat people live with and the way many people are quick to form negative judgments about someone who is fat without knowing anything else about them. Please feel free to ignore me if I seem to be going overboard.

Peace out. ✌

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Yep. 56% of Americans read at 6th grade level. And right wing media talks and writes not only lies. Ninga Nov 2024 #1
Which, sadly, allows the ol KGB method easier to export to the US, especially when sick, greedy billionaires own media Attilatheblond Nov 2024 #7
Yeah, I thought allowing Farmer-Rick Nov 2024 #13
True Dat. Sadly. Evolve Dammit Nov 2024 #32
The decades long attack on the education system whopis01 Nov 2024 #41
No BigMin28 Nov 2024 #2
The burn it down, low-info, propaganda-inspired. yardwork Nov 2024 #3
I wonder if stupidity actually has weight and mass? Ocelot II Nov 2024 #4
Yes. And eliminating the Dept of Education will give stupidity even more weight and mass. ancianita Nov 2024 #9
That's the plan. "I love the uneducated." DJT. So much more malleable. Evolve Dammit Nov 2024 #33
Trump used the royal "we." dchill Nov 2024 #36
Interestingly, Weight and mass... littlemissmartypants Nov 2024 #28
I don't think so. ShazzieB Nov 2024 #38
I think you're fine, ShazzieB. littlemissmartypants Nov 2024 #39
I believe the correct unit is "maga" whopis01 Nov 2024 #43
Not sure about mass and weight, but it sure has a lot of inertia to it.... unblock Nov 2024 #47
That's beyond sad. Solly Mack Nov 2024 #5
Actually, I see this as helpful unblock Nov 2024 #6
Very interesting. H2O Man Nov 2024 #19
Yes... Farmer-Rick Nov 2024 #23
Simple EarthAbides Nov 2024 #35
Fetterman & AOC in 28 SomewhereInTheMiddle Nov 2024 #42
Part of the problem is getting the message out NewJeffCT Nov 2024 #46
Turn out the lights, We're F****d! surfered Nov 2024 #8
We play by the rules while the Republicans shit all over us. hadEnuf Nov 2024 #10
Yes, goddamit!!! LymphocyteLover Nov 2024 #17
This message was self-deleted by its author Hiawatha Pete Nov 2024 #11
You notice how none of these people put any actual policy reasons. It's just emotions. In It to Win It Nov 2024 #12
the closest to a policy I saw was Gaza LymphocyteLover Nov 2024 #18
Agreed, that's the only thing that came close. Republicans learned a while ago that emotions win elections In It to Win It Nov 2024 #25
Trump is a marketer, the only thing he was ever good at. Passages Nov 2024 #14
Yes, indeed. But I listened to him all the time during the campign and still have no idea how people teased any real LymphocyteLover Nov 2024 #20
I agree, to me he was the most obvious sleazebag liar. Yet, despite his horrific reputation he had a tv Passages Nov 2024 #21
he was shunned by everyone who worked with him before except a few horrible people who are pscyhopaths like him! LymphocyteLover Nov 2024 #24
Yes. I remember years ago Anthony Bourdain did a food spot involving NJ and he went after Passages Nov 2024 #30
Yes, people believed that BS about the economy NewJeffCT Nov 2024 #44
TSF is a marketer Seinan Sensei Nov 2024 #29
Yes, sleaze all the way. Passages Nov 2024 #31
Things have been getting worse since Nixon IbogaProject Nov 2024 #15
one big question here though is--- what % of her voters split their ticket like this? LymphocyteLover Nov 2024 #16
LOL. We are no longer heading towards Idiocracy, we're living in it. /nt spudspud Nov 2024 #22
Stupid, ignorant SECOND grade IQ !!!! Jethro Bodine Clampett is smarter than those white trash a-holes Trueblue1968 Nov 2024 #26
I've been shocked by smart people being played Easterncedar Nov 2024 #27
cheers for AOC, jeers for Mystal PedroXimenez Nov 2024 #34
The Ivermectin and bleach inoculated have spoken. dchill Nov 2024 #37
WTH??? liberalla Nov 2024 #40
So at the end of it all vercetti2021 Nov 2024 #45
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Elie Mystal: Welp, this m...»Reply #38