Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hunter

(39,496 posts)
58. I don't think anyone should be supporting manned spaceflight, NASA included.
Thu Apr 17, 2025, 09:50 AM
Apr 17

When my grandfather was an engineer for the Apollo Project sending humans into space was a grand adventure into the unknown.

Now that we have a much clearer view of the technological demands of keeping humans alive and functioning in space, and our robotic technology has advanced to the point where we've had rovers functioning on Mars for many years, it seems to me that sending humans into space only get in the way of actual scientific research.

I've been saying this for many years so I'm pretty sure this isn't the case of an all female space crew triggering me. If I recall correctly, I once compared returning humans to the moon to a "Here, hold my beer," party stunt or an Evel Knievel motorcycle jump. It makes no sense to me.

It also reminds me of a past time when I was living in a garden shed, riding a bicycle everywhere because my car was broken, foraging through dumpsters for food, and attending meetings of the local Sierra Club where they'd talk about their trips to Machu Picchu and their brand new "green" cars.

At one point I had to laugh at the absurdity of it.

What was I doing there among people whose environmental footprints were huge compared to mine? What was I hoping to accomplish? Why was I supporting this group with both my presence and my meager student membership fees?

I think that's my biggest complaint. The environmental impacts of sending humans into space are huge. The environmental impacts of commercial space exploitation are equally unacceptable.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Poor rich Lady snowybirdie Apr 16 #1
"harness the waste and put it into space"? What unicorn planet did she visit? How stupid is she? Bernardo de La Paz Apr 16 #2
Why don't they just send Eloon and Bezos up and get rid of them. MISSION ACCOMPLISHED! madinmaryland Apr 16 #15
Send trump, his entire cabinet and ALL of the GOP ouse &senate politicans in o the moon. They can live there Trueblue1968 Apr 16 #18
Great Idea. Even better include the turd, vance, The Fock brothers and Sen.McConnell. rich7862 Apr 16 #41
Bad enough we dump waste in the ocean... bluesbassman Apr 16 #20
these clueless out of touch rich fucks trying to justify their existence Skittles Apr 16 #3
The ones in the spaceship or on the ground criticizing? newdeal2 Apr 16 #6
I don't care what they think Skittles Apr 16 #8
But, but, but... "If you get enough people who are interested, it doesn't have to be that expensive." demmiblue Apr 16 #7
because going into space is what is on our minds right now! Skittles Apr 16 #19
This! FalloutShelter Apr 16 #28
Yup. " Me! Me! Me! " NewHendoLib Apr 16 #4
Exactly. Looks like a publicity stunt for folks sliding toward the B list. dutch777 Apr 16 #51
Like the other rich people who went up it is rich people throwing money around. They or the others were not crew Srkdqltr Apr 16 #5
Worlds most expensive carnival ride n/t Cheezoholic Apr 16 #9
"You can't criticize me until you've been up in space, too!" Whyisthisstillclose Apr 16 #10
lol I assume she is talking about the other rich celebrities who criticized her Meowmee Apr 16 #12
This woman is sickening. A self-involved influencer delisen Apr 16 #17
Never cared Rebl2 Apr 16 #33
She almost said something interesting once BeyondGeography Apr 16 #11
I'm With Anthony Bourdain MayReasonRule Apr 16 #13
Can't stand her and her response to this is not good at all. beaglelover Apr 16 #14
I can't stand all the scolds lecturing people how to spend their money. WarGamer Apr 16 #16
When someone with major resources decides to do something unique, interesting, and enjoyable... Girard442 Apr 16 #23
Clueless and classless. nt Maru Kitteh Apr 16 #26
no one is telling them how to spend their fucking money Skittles Apr 16 #34
Sure they can spend their money on whatever they want senseandsensibility Apr 16 #37
I'm surprised Oprah didn't push her aside, and go in her place. rsdsharp Apr 16 #38
It's probably pretty damn scary... WarGamer Apr 16 #43
Getting between Oprah and a camera or microphone is pretty damn scary. rsdsharp Apr 16 #46
True, but we don't insist that people praise us for it. yardwork Apr 17 #62
She has nothing to be ashamed of. I hope she enjoyed it In It to Win It Apr 16 #21
She is fan clubbing for musk so I hope she gets what she deserves questionseverything Apr 16 #44
Elon Musk can afford to destroy America, should he? delisen Apr 16 #22
The space flight was gross and this response is clueless. Scrivener7 Apr 16 #24
So fucking sick of rich people singing the praise of their own "accomplishments" Maru Kitteh Apr 16 #25
Watching rich people riding a giant penis is entertaining. Emile Apr 16 #27
. MorbidButterflyTat Apr 16 #40
In this instance mnhtnbb Apr 17 #60
"Every time a flight goes up, they get some type of information that can be used for something else," milestogo Apr 16 #29
None Rebl2 Apr 16 #35
Maybe she got a phone number from Bezo's gf. milestogo Apr 16 #39
Hey, Gail! PJMcK Apr 16 #30
Gail Rebl2 Apr 16 #36
What can possibly get done in 11 minutes? AStern Apr 16 #31
These people are so out of touch Prairie Gates Apr 16 #32
"....Blue Origin's goal MorbidButterflyTat Apr 16 #42
You can't force your opinions on someone else. They are not wrong for believing that Tribetime Apr 16 #45
How disrepectful to all the female and POC astronauts who earned their ride through their life's work. meadowlander Apr 16 #47
Sending humans into space is pointless. hunter Apr 16 #48
In the US only NASA should be allowed to do this. valleyrogue Apr 16 #50
I don't think anyone should be supporting manned spaceflight, NASA included. hunter Apr 17 #58
I don't agree. valleyrogue Apr 17 #59
NONE of these space flights/explorations should be in the private sector. valleyrogue Apr 16 #49
I gave up on Gayle King years ago. We're wondering what did GP6971 Apr 16 #52
I never really had an opinion on Gayle King... Mike Nelson Apr 17 #53
Listen Gayle, you went on a vertical plane ride. no_hypocrisy Apr 17 #54
It's weird that no one really had a problem until a bunch of women went. Renew Deal Apr 17 #55
I wasn't aware of that, and that might be the issue. yardwork Apr 17 #63
Gayle King, like her flight companions, all live in a bubble. Passages Apr 17 #56
Hmmm . . . let me see. Suddenly, after winning the Powerball, I'm a rich lady. What shall I do? Vinca Apr 17 #57
This bad idea just keeps getting worse. yardwork Apr 17 #61
Oh, good grief! hamsterjill Apr 17 #64
They all came back so I guess Blue Origin's goal was not met. Autumn Apr 17 #65
yikes, but why is she worried about the backlash? ecstatic Apr 17 #66
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Gayle King Defends 'Expen...»Reply #58