Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

HuckleB

(35,773 posts)
24. Persistent Anti-GMO Myths by Steven Novella
Mon Aug 11, 2014, 12:22 PM
Aug 2014
http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/persistent-anti-gmo-myths/

"One persistent theme in my writing about scientific topics is that, to optimally serve our own interests, public discourse and decision-making on issues that are highly scientific should be informed by the best evidence and scientific analysis available, not on lies, myths, misconceptions, or raw ideology. I am therefore attracted to topics where I think the myth to fact ratio is particularly high.

Genetically modified organisms (GMO) is one such issue. The propaganda machine seems to be way out in front of the more sober voices trying to correct the record and focus the discussion on reality. I also see GMO as the ideological flip side to global warming denial. In the latter case we seen industry and free-market ideologues sowing confusion and misinformation. They also do the ideology shuffle – a dance in which, whenever they are nailed by the facts on one point, they state that their objection is really based on some other point. They never really acknowledge the point, just side-step it.

Anti-GMO activists, in my experience, operate the same way. They have marshaled every possible point they can against GMO, whether or not they are true or valid. When one such point is exposed as a myth, they simply slide over to some other point as their “real” motivation for opposition, but never give any ground.

...

Like any new powerful technology, GMO needs to be studied, monitored, and regulated, which it is. I do not agree with arguments that it is inherently risky, even transgenic GMO, and so far the technology has proven extremely safe. Cries of Frankenfood and impending environmental disaster are little more than ideologically driven fearmongering.

..."



Novella does a good job covering many of the usual anti-GMO attacks, as well. It's a good read.
I can see why persons such as yourself would desperately want to try and marginalize her- KittyWampus Aug 2014 #1
Repeating some of her claims that have been debunked, does not make them accurate. HuckleB Aug 2014 #3
The OP starting with a rather bizarre critique of the targets own OP headline lost me right away.... Fred Sanders Aug 2014 #7
There was nothing bizarre about the OP critique. HuckleB Aug 2014 #8
Vendana Shiva is no huckster... hedda_foil Aug 2014 #2
The evidence shows otherwise: HuckleB Aug 2014 #4
Well, I was going to read her article but you only vanlassie Aug 2014 #5
I'm confused. HuckleB Aug 2014 #6
I think the point is you aren't presenting the full story tkmorris Aug 2014 #20
Actually, I am presenting the full story. HuckleB Aug 2014 #22
ALL CAPS DELIVERY ALREADY SAYS WHAT THIS IS ABOUT JackRiddler Aug 2014 #9
I Love It! HuckleB Aug 2014 #10
Hey, so... NuclearDem Aug 2014 #11
A Victory.. Cha Aug 2014 #13
So the judge failed to understand the science of the matter... HuckleB Aug 2014 #15
Everyone else other than you are wrong? awards for Vandana shiva wisechoice Aug 2014 #17
Check in here if you ever heard of more than two of those "awards" prior to reply #17 Orrex Aug 2014 #18
These "awards" are not based on science. HuckleB Aug 2014 #19
The All Caps is simply copied and pasted from the article. HuckleB Aug 2014 #14
you and Sid are like defenders of the realm in regards to woo.... dionysus Aug 2014 #12
More power to their arms! (nt) mr blur Aug 2014 #16
Oh geez, you're goring a DU sacred cow... SidDithers Aug 2014 #21
She also played a big role in, and was supportive of, Mike Adams recent Nazi-GMO rant. HuckleB Aug 2014 #25
Scientists call her a huckster while non scientists trust her. Iron Man Aug 2014 #23
Luckily, many non-scientists can see beyond the facade she portrays. HuckleB Aug 2014 #26
Persistent Anti-GMO Myths by Steven Novella HuckleB Aug 2014 #24
Another piece the debunks Shiva's usual deceptive claims. HuckleB Aug 2014 #27
Shiva lies and lies again! HuckleB Sep 2014 #28
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»VANDANA SHIVA, BULLSHIT A...»Reply #24