General Discussion

stopbush

(24,852 posts)

40. Why support make believe? It really doesn't help.

Thu Aug 20, 2015, 05:29 PM

Aug 2015

In fact, studies have shown that sick people who are religious and know people are praying for them do WORSE in their recovery than do those who aren't believers in prayer.

If we really wanted to help people like Pres Carter, we'd forego the make believe that is prayer because it's actually hurting the patient.

But, no, religion gets a special carve out in this country, no matter how destructive it is. Exactly how much are you respecting Pres Carter by engaging in prayer when it's been shown to be counterproductive in healing the sick?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

46 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Former POTUS Jimmy Carter Prognosis/Praying for POTUS Carter [View all] LovingA2andMI Aug 2015 OP

Cancer is actually thousands of diseases sharp_stick Aug 2015 #1

Thoughts and prayers for President Carter lunamagica Aug 2015 #2

Thoughts and prayers for a good man. WIProgressive88 Aug 2015 #3

Keeping Pres Carter in ones thoughts is a nice gesture. stopbush Aug 2015 #4

No more and no less than positive thoughts, well-wishes and hope. LanternWaste Aug 2015 #5

I was wondering who would be the first G_j Aug 2015 #16

Thank you narnian60 Aug 2015 #39

Carter is very religious BeyondGeography Aug 2015 #28

Why support make believe? It really doesn't help. stopbush Aug 2015 #40

Forget me, you should share your wisdom with Rosalynn BeyondGeography Aug 2015 #41

There's great value in the Carters spending time together. stopbush Aug 2015 #46

My mother and my favorite Aunt both died of it Ichingcarpenter Aug 2015 #6

I have met the former President several times on brief occasions... hlthe2b Aug 2015 #7

prayers and positive thoughts for this remarkable man. niyad Aug 2015 #8

with some tears I am recalling a stanza from "Amazing Grace" that seems so a propos CTyankee Aug 2015 #9

President Jimmy Carter liberal from boston Aug 2015 #10

That's a terrific verse and just perfect catrose Aug 2015 #11

+1000 narnian60 Aug 2015 #15

Emily Dickenson once wrote a condolence note to grieving family members CTyankee Aug 2015 #17

+1 jwirr Aug 2015 #19

Praying for this gentle man, who has been a gift to the world ... n/t secondwind Aug 2015 #12

God bless you Jimmy workinclasszero Aug 2015 #13

Thoughts and prayers for President Carter MoonRiver Aug 2015 #14

Love you Jimmy! G_j Aug 2015 #18

In the last few years I've come to believe that Jimmy Carter was an underrated president. WhoIsNumberNone Aug 2015 #20

A great man who exemplifies what it is to be truly human.. scarletlib Aug 2015 #21

"I'm looking forward to a new adventure" Glassunion Aug 2015 #22

His good works didn't stop with the presidency.^^^ Eleanors38 Aug 2015 #23

Jimmy is one hella strong man. Tipperary Aug 2015 #24

Unfortunately, you can't remove comments from DU threads. MineralMan Aug 2015 #25

The commenter can be Blocked.... LovingA2andMI Aug 2015 #30

Uh, no. You can't block anyone from posting in GD. MineralMan Aug 2015 #31

Obviously Reading this not a skill.... LovingA2andMI Aug 2015 #32

Again. You can't block any DU from posting in any thread. MineralMan Aug 2015 #33

You can only Ignore posters, which makes them "disappear" only for you REP Aug 2015 #42

And any thread started by moi... LovingA2andMI Aug 2015 #43

No; not your ("moi") threads; threads by others REP Aug 2015 #45

Yes. Sending healing vibes. tblue Aug 2015 #26

Brilliant man. Compassionate, and thoughtful. onecaliberal Aug 2015 #27

. Hiraeth Aug 2015 #29

and melanoma cancer is one of the worst.....my favorite brother AND sister both died of melanoma.... a kennedy Aug 2015 #34

Thank you to Jimmy Carter lovemydog Aug 2015 #35

Thoughts with a great man kwolf68 Aug 2015 #36

Sending prayers and good thoughts to my BuelahWitch Aug 2015 #37

"I was surprisingly at ease" loyalsister Aug 2015 #38

He has, as always, LWolf Aug 2015 #44