Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Marthe48

(22,784 posts)
39. Too bad for students
Fri Nov 22, 2024, 12:33 PM
Nov 2024

I attended a suburban Cleveland school district that was almost all white. There were 2 Japanese students, sisters from the same family. Anyway, I remember that before there was an attempt to standardize education so Johnny in California and Mary in Alabama and Derek in Nebraska all learned the same information, kids who moved into our school system from somewhere else often struggled to catch up, or change their idioms. And even if they were a little better educated, they weren't spared learning the pecking order. In the 50s and 60s, a lot of poor whites moved North to get jobs at Good Year, steel mills and so on. In hindsight, it was probably like another planet. I remember my 6th grade teacher doing a short lesson on pronunciation. She mentioned it was creek, not crick. I had never heard anyone say crick before, and I was fascinated. I think the lesson was probably kindness from the principal, one that the other teachers shared with their classes. The kids in my class were long time students and I doubt any of them ever said crick, either.
Americans still do a lot of moving around. The lifetime average is currently 11 times. Can you you imagine the disruption when rwnj dismantle public education and reduces it to the whims of local fiefdoms? I bet the reasoning behind dismantling a national standard of education is to disenfranchise any minorities, any religions, and any person on the gender spectrum that is not exactly the stereotype of white evangelical Americans.
As much as people move, their kids are going to be exposed to differences, the hard way. Kids going into the military are going to have a rough time adapting to the structure of military life and learning about the variety of humans who join up. It is a 2 way street, for sure. I remember getting to know a farm family who lived in S.E. Ohio. I loved them dearly and stayed with them once for a week. As time went on, I realized that their education was different than mine. It didn't make them stupid, but they were definitely locked into being farmers and living the life of farmers. One of their cousins moved north and the local family was in awe of the change in status.
I'm sure we all remember the sitcoms of the 60s-Beverly Hillbilly, Green Acres, Petticoat Junction, and how the characters were stereotyped, either as snobby urban dwellers or naive country folk. Modern education changed that dynamic, and I think were working on nuances--getting kids to meet and acknowledge other colors, other religions, other sexuality, really a whole world of variety, way more complex than city slicker and country bumpkin. The rwnj will take us back to a land of stereotypes and no one will benefit. Another giant leap backward.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Dismantling of the US federal government per Putin's orders. Irish_Dem Nov 2024 #1
Musk, the Cryptoboys, and Putin's orders: Botany Nov 2024 #7
Crime of the century. And most brilliant war ever waged against the US. Irish_Dem Nov 2024 #22
Maybe not the war, but they are fast approaching it. (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Nov 2024 #34
Trump/Putin hate the United States and are doing their best to destroy us Walleye Nov 2024 #2
The fear alone of losing income.. Lovie777 Nov 2024 #3
But... but... isn't that Project 2025??? Martin Eden Nov 2024 #4
obeying in advance. or mopinko Nov 2024 #5
This fever dream of the rights odins folly Nov 2024 #6
Is this because it was created during the Carter Administration? LiberalArkie Nov 2024 #8
It's all about the money jmbar2 Nov 2024 #9
Closing the Department of Education will save no money other than a few salaries. Lonestarblue Nov 2024 #10
+1,000,000 chia Nov 2024 #28
and everyone's real estate taxes will go up since there will be no more funding mdbl Nov 2024 #32
local control creates small minded insular citizens who barely understand civilization bucolic_frolic Nov 2024 #11
"local control is best"? Not according to Ron DeSantis. CaptainTruth Nov 2024 #12
More un-educated people vote for GOP. LisaL Nov 2024 #13
In a country where half the population reads below a 6th grade level dlk Nov 2024 #14
Do they even have schools in South Dakota? He's got nothing to lose. n/t Greybnk48 Nov 2024 #15
How many sponsors are on the bill? nt in2herbs Nov 2024 #16
the long term plan is return to serfdom Javaman Nov 2024 #17
No, Linda ladeewolf Nov 2024 #21
Ken Kesey once told me, "Cream rises to the top . . . Journeyman Nov 2024 #31
Odd timing boonecreek Nov 2024 #18
they are trying to put killing of the DOE Quanto Magnus Nov 2024 #40
I expect a brain drain. barbtries Nov 2024 #19
Coming next: Department of Stupidity Wicked Blue Nov 2024 #20
This orangecrush Nov 2024 #24
Jesus, take the wheel. dchill Nov 2024 #23
I will just relax until it is actually initiated. FarPoint Nov 2024 #25
They want to make Americans uninformed and easy to manipulate IronLionZion Nov 2024 #26
Special needs kids will be among the most affected by this. Basso8vb Nov 2024 #27
Thank you, I was just about to post the same thing. gab13by13 Nov 2024 #29
I have been a SpEd for over 20 years evemac Nov 2024 #30
Having young people happy, safe, intellectually curious, and not hungry regardless of whatever..... Botany Nov 2024 #33
A real zero. Kid Berwyn Nov 2024 #35
They want loco control, not local. GreenWave Nov 2024 #36
So, does this mean all student loans will be gone as well? TBF Nov 2024 #37
The way to total control. republianmushroom Nov 2024 #38
Too bad for students Marthe48 Nov 2024 #39
Translation: stealing "federal education dollars" for "local control" BadgerKid Nov 2024 #41
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»GOP senator introduces bi...»Reply #39