The DU Lounge

pressbox69

(2,252 posts)

48. Shane without a doubt.

Reply to red dog 1 (Original post)

Sat Feb 10, 2018, 08:51 AM

Feb 2018

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

99 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

What's your favorite western? [View all] red dog 1 Feb 2018 OP

Silverado pdxflyboy Feb 2018 #1

"Silverado" is the perfect western! yallerdawg Feb 2018 #24

Silverado was a great western red dog 1 Feb 2018 #26

Right from the beginning... yallerdawg Feb 2018 #74

You can now vote for Silverado red dog 1 Feb 2018 #73

Silverado is now up there as a poll option red dog 1 Feb 2018 #72

So much excellence. mahatmakanejeeves Feb 2018 #2

Tombstone (1993) SummerSnow Feb 2018 #3

I'm your huckleberry! red dog 1 Feb 2018 #27

One of mine too. ProudMNDemocrat Feb 2018 #30

... Docreed2003 Feb 2018 #83

Blazing Saddles Tribalceltic Feb 2018 #4

Gene Wilder.. i had such a crush on him!! samnsara Feb 2018 #9

He died way too young, red dog 1 Feb 2018 #15

me too!! mucifer Feb 2018 #78

+1! lastlib Feb 2018 #47

Once Upon a Time in the West FiveGoodMen Feb 2018 #5

Same here👍 GWC58 Feb 2018 #7

The Outlaw Josey Wales left-of-center2012 Feb 2018 #6

+1 Alpeduez21 Feb 2018 #17

This! Va Lefty Feb 2018 #18

+1 We got us the Josey Whales! nt earthshine Feb 2018 #36

Cat Ballou! samnsara Feb 2018 #8

True Grit. Cracklin Charlie Feb 2018 #10

Outstanding cast. Always surprised Kim Darby didn't get good roles. mpcamb Feb 2018 #94

1930s and 1940s B-westerns are my guilty pleasure. FuzzyRabbit Feb 2018 #11

I thought about putting Tombstone up there, since it's a great western, red dog 1 Feb 2018 #14

Tombstone! nt flying rabbit Feb 2018 #85

The Jeff Bridges True Grit was fantastic. Codeine Feb 2018 #21

How about some TV mini-series? FuzzyRabbit Feb 2018 #12

While I do like Robert Duvall, I don't think TV mini-series belong in the poll as choices red dog 1 Feb 2018 #16

I voted for "Shane" but my actual favorite is "MacKenna's Gold" Glorfindel Feb 2018 #13

Wow! What a cast! red dog 1 Feb 2018 #23

Never saw this one TuxedoKat Feb 2018 #81

The Sea of Grass TuxedoKat Feb 2018 #82

Would McCabe and Mrs. Miller count.... dhill926 Feb 2018 #19

It definitely counts as a western red dog 1 Feb 2018 #25

Il buono, il brutto, il cattivo. nt Codeine Feb 2018 #20

"Red River" original version with John Wayne and Montgomery Clift. Paladin Feb 2018 #22

McLintock. Personally, not big western fan, but my late wife loved this and we watched it often. Hoyt Feb 2018 #28

The Cheyenne Social Club House of Roberts Feb 2018 #29

The man who shot Liberty Valence mainstreetonce Feb 2018 #31

It's now poll option # 6, (so you can now vote for it) red dog 1 Feb 2018 #63

Jeremiah Johnson, Dances with Wolves, remake of True Grit CanonRay Feb 2018 #32

Not your standard western ornotna Feb 2018 #76

It inspired me to move out west. CanonRay Feb 2018 #84

My attention span is too short for movies but I like to watch TV westerns like MiltonBrown Feb 2018 #33

"Gunsmoke", "Bonanza", "The Rifleman", "Rawhide", "Wanted, Dead or Alive," "Rin Tin Tin" red dog 1 Feb 2018 #34

All good ones. The only TV western I didnt like is Laramie. MiltonBrown Feb 2018 #35

Tombstone Leighbythesea Feb 2018 #37

I like 'The Shootist' Generic Brad Feb 2018 #38

The best performance he ever gave... First Speaker Feb 2018 #39

Definitely. Pope George Ringo II Feb 2018 #54

The Man From Laramie... First Speaker Feb 2018 #40

The best #1 Western is: "High Noon".. truly great film !!! Stuart G Feb 2018 #41

Who Shot Liberty Valance n/t hibbing Feb 2018 #42

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance is now up there as poll option # 6 red dog 1 Feb 2018 #64

"Destry" comes to mind as does "Cat Ballou" rurallib Feb 2018 #43

Little Big Man MrScorpio Feb 2018 #44

Agree. Always like the story-within-a-story format. mpcamb Feb 2018 #93

Great minds and all that Mr. S Dyedinthewoolliberal Feb 2018 #95

+1 geardaddy Feb 2018 #99

Lots Of Good Ones But Not My Fave ProfessorGAC Feb 2018 #45

I do think you should consider "Lonesome Dove". blue neen Feb 2018 #46

+1 n/t. rzemanfl Feb 2018 #52

That was my choice. I'm surprised it wasn't on the list. Such a wonderful Western! Nay Feb 2018 #91

The acting, the writing. blue neen Feb 2018 #92

Shane without a doubt. pressbox69 Feb 2018 #48

The Big Country TuxedoKat Feb 2018 #49

Great one. Years ago there was a terrible print being used on TV. Gidney N Cloyd Feb 2018 #68

Lots of favorites, but Evil Roy Slade starring John Astin, is at the top. MerryBlooms Feb 2018 #50

What? No three amigos? unblock Feb 2018 #51

Young guns Proud liberal 80 Feb 2018 #53

Blazing saddles Jane Austin Feb 2018 #55

My Darling Clementine and Fort Apache n/t sarge43 Feb 2018 #56

Nobody voted for My Darling Clementine yet, so it may be coming down soon, red dog 1 Feb 2018 #62

Maverick Cartoonist Feb 2018 #57

The Maverick movie was one of the best treatments of a TV show I can think of, western or otherwise. Gidney N Cloyd Feb 2018 #67

I picked... Mike Nelson Feb 2018 #58

I always enjoy GP6971 Feb 2018 #59

My two are the Man Who Shot Liberty Valance and The Ox Bow Incident. argyl Feb 2018 #60

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance - When the legend becomes fact, print the legend. Brother Buzz Feb 2018 #61

You can now vote for Liberty Valance red dog 1 Feb 2018 #66

No Country for Old Men is about as close to Western as I get jmowreader Feb 2018 #65

DJango JonLP24 Feb 2018 #69

Some of my faves not listed: Silverado, Hondo, Monte Walsh (orig), Life & Times of Judge Roy Bean Gidney N Cloyd Feb 2018 #70

Silverado is now up there as poll option # 10, (so you can now vote for it) red dog 1 Feb 2018 #71

Omelet NotASurfer Feb 2018 #75

Purgatory jodymarie aimee Feb 2018 #77

Ride The High Country should be on the list. El Supremo Feb 2018 #79

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance TeamPooka Feb 2018 #80

Destry Rides Again, My Darling Clementine, anything John Ford ... kwassa Feb 2018 #86

"Home From the Hill" (1960) Tikki Feb 2018 #87

I can't resist: area51 Feb 2018 #88

Sam Peckinpahs western films work for me... VOX Feb 2018 #89

Big Jake Shrek Feb 2018 #90

The Professionals. Burt Lancaster at his finest. kairos12 Feb 2018 #96

"High Noon" is coming up later this month on one of those over-the-air mahatmakanejeeves Feb 2018 #97

Gunfight at the OK Corral (1957) red dog 1 Feb 2018 #98