Gun Control & RKBA
In reply to the discussion: SAFE Act: Gun groups say data shows low compliance [View all]sarisataka
(18,539 posts)Ghandi I believe, that goes -'War is inevitable if one side wishes it.'
What to do when your side wishes it?
In a similar vein, when people wave signs saying 'War is not the answer" my reply is what was the question?
As for winning hearts and minds- think of the mosaic pictures. Many little pictures go into making up the overall picture. Soldiers do not control the overall picture but, to agree with you somewhat, they are a part of the overall picture. All they can influence is their own tiny little photo.
To continue the analogy, it is all of the civilians who are supplying the film for the photos. You may protest the picture, disagree with it, criticize the artist but you are still involved, like it or not.
You keep coming back to "heroes". I have never met a person who seeks that title out. You seem to hold the soldiers responsible but that is also a part of the system. If a troop is told go march in a parade s/he marches in the parade. Some do enjoy the attention but they do not consider themselves "heroes". If you don't want to salute, fine; I never asked you to. I hate dog and pony shows. Culver's military discount is enough for me; I like frozen custard.
"We're fighting for our freedom." I bet you have seen that on TV. Have you ever watched Bull Durham? Kevin Costner gives the new pitcher this advice:
Ebby Calvin LaLoosh: Got to play... it's pretty boring.
Crash Davis: 'Course it's boring, that's the point. Write it down.
Correct me if I'm wrong but you seem to have the impression that if simply no one joined the military there would be no more war. That is a false hope for three reasons:
1- as you alluded, and I have argued, people join for many reasons. No one is joining thinking about meta issues and world peace.
2- a percentage to believe in patriotism and service. they may not agree with everything we are doing but believe in the long run it will all turn out good.
3- if somehow the recruit pipeline would dry up, the draft would be reinstated.