2016 Postmortem
Showing Original Post only (View all)Gaming the town hall debate -- How Dems react to tonight's debate really matters [View all]
We all know that President Obama needs a better night than he had in the first debate. But the entire Democratic political apparatus and Obamas own supporters also need a better night than they had last time. Who prevails this evening depends not only on how each candidate does but also on how their supporters react.
Mitt Romney cannot play it as if he has the election in hand. He doesnt. He still needs to overcome that indelible moment when he consigned 47 percent of Americans to the hopelessly dependent category. And he cant say anything goofy or unfeeling, his habit at so many points in the campaign but something he avoided in Debate One. My hunch is that Romney will try to surprise Obama again, as he did in their first debate by throwing off his right-wing, GOP-primary self and playing at being more moderate. Obama needs to be ready for a second Romney surprise.
.....
Finally, watch what Obamas supporters make of the debate. Keep an eye on the Twitter feeds and on what the more liberal commentators say in their post-debate commentaries. As the first presidential debate went on, the feeds of progressives went almost silent. After the debate, Obama-leaning commentators might have been even more critical of his performance than neutral analysts were. The negativity built and metastasized to the point where Obamas defeat looked far worse 24 and 48 hours later than it did at the time. To invoke a football metaphor, it would be as if post-game commentary had the power to spin a 24-to-14 defeat into a 38-to-3 catastrophe. That cant happen in sports, but it can happen in political debates.
My hunch is that this wont be repeated this time partly because Obamas supporters have been put in a fighting mood by the possibility of a Romney victory, and partly because Obama rarely makes the same mistake twice.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/post/gaming-the-town-hall-debate/2012/10/16/6b3ed27c-179d-11e2-a55c-39408fbe6a4b_blog.html?hpid=z2