Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
2016 Postmortem
In reply to the discussion: Bernie lost among democrats 54-46% according to exit poll. All primaries should be closed primaries [View all]JimDandy
(7,318 posts)63. Unfortunately, the Repub party in Idaho actually did force the state to register voters by party
in 2011. They filed suit and won:
IDAHO REPUBLICAN PARTY v. YSURSA, BEN In his Official Capacity as Secretary of State of the State of Idaho
INTRODUCTION
This case presents the question whether the State of Idahos use of an open primary system to determine nominees for the general election violates the Idaho Republican Partys First Amendment rights. Because the open primary permits substantial numbers of independent voters, as well as voters associated with other political parties, to cross over and participate in the Republican Partys selection of its nominees, the Court concludes that, by mandating such a nomination process, the State violates the Partys constitutionally guaranteed right to freedom of association.
http://www.sos.idaho.gov/ELECT/ClosedPrimaryOrder.pdf
This case presents the question whether the State of Idahos use of an open primary system to determine nominees for the general election violates the Idaho Republican Partys First Amendment rights. Because the open primary permits substantial numbers of independent voters, as well as voters associated with other political parties, to cross over and participate in the Republican Partys selection of its nominees, the Court concludes that, by mandating such a nomination process, the State violates the Partys constitutionally guaranteed right to freedom of association.
http://www.sos.idaho.gov/ELECT/ClosedPrimaryOrder.pdf
The defendant, a Republican, didn't put up much of a fight for the people of the State of Idaho.
That is why instead of 22 states that don't register voters by party, there are now only 21:
Alabama -- open primary
Arkansas -- open primary
Georgia -- open primary
Hawaii -- open caucus
Illinois -- semi-open primary
Indiana -- open primary
Michigan -- open primary
Minnesota -- open caucus
Mississippi -- open primary
Missouri -- open primary
Montana -- open primary
North Dakota -- open caucus
Ohio -- semi-open primary
South Carolina --open primary
Tennessee -- open primary
Texas -- closed caucus
Utah -- closed primary
Vermont -- open primary
Virginia -- open primary
Washington -- open caucus
Wisconsin -- open primary
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
123 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Bernie lost among democrats 54-46% according to exit poll. All primaries should be closed primaries [View all]
qdouble
May 2016
OP
Indiana was open- it is Cali that does not allow Republicans- it is a "hybrid system". Sorry if it
bettyellen
May 2016
#15
Yep, not one peep about open primaries before, until Sanders started clocking Hillary's block. n/t
JimDandy
May 2016
#36
Well since she has won most of the open primaries I think we have done just that!
ContinentalOp
May 2016
#46
Look at post 85. I broke down the Independent votes for all the states that were close in 2012,
RichVRichV
May 2016
#97
The idea is that if we let Republicans vote they will do the opposite. No sale.
bettyellen
May 2016
#60
Yes - let's only let Dems vote for the nominee. And let's not let Independents vote for the Dem
Nanjeanne
May 2016
#18
How, um, democratic of you. Yep. Let the nominee be decided by 26% of the electorate.
Luminous Animal
May 2016
#21
Some of those non-Democrats would vote for Sanders in the GE were he to be nominated.
Garrett78
May 2016
#22
She has won the majority of open primaries, so how do you figure he would win if they all were open?
ContinentalOp
May 2016
#49
The Democratic party does not need or want Independents! The party will summon them when ...
slipslidingaway
May 2016
#41
Unfortunately, the Repub party in Idaho actually did force the state to register voters by party
JimDandy
May 2016
#63
Slaughtered? Such vile, destructive language choices you guys choose. Why is that? nt
Live and Learn
May 2016
#51
Only if the GE is also closed to anyone not reg'd Dem (or living in Brooklyn)
GreatGazoo
May 2016
#53
I think closed primaries should be completely funded by the party that wants to exclude people
FrodosPet
May 2016
#64
All primaries and caucuses should be open. It would be far more democratic.
Tierra_y_Libertad
May 2016
#79
If all democratic primaries should be closed, then all democrats should pay for them
Chezboo
May 2016
#102
Bernie lost among democrats 54-46% according to exit poll. All primaries should be closed primaries
jmousso75
May 2016
#106
Spoken by another person who won't look too far back to properly judge history...
MrMickeysMom
May 2016
#111
What the hell is an "outsider"? Someone who didn't go through the secret Democratic rituals?
Armstead
May 2016
#113