Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Jim__

(14,075 posts)
7. Some swing states are trying to use gerrymandered districts to change the electoral college.
Fri Oct 4, 2013, 10:45 AM
Oct 2013

That is, certain states (swing states) would not throw all the electoral votes to omne presidential candidate but would allow each congressional district to cast its own independent vote. This could cause serious problems for Democrats in presidential elections.


From US News:


A handful of states—unsurprisingly, battleground states controlled by the GOP at the state level but captured by President Obama in the presidential races—are considering changing the way they allocate electoral votes, basing the outcome not on the popular vote across the state, but those within each congressional district. The winner-take-all system almost all states now have is surely not entirely fair, since someone who got 49.9 percent of the vote could walk away with no electoral votes. But assigning electors by congressional district is even less fair, since it would typically diminish the power of voters in big cities (which tend to go Democratic). In Pennsylvania, for example—a commonwealth Obama won by five points—the new scheme would have assigned Republican Mitt Romney 18 electoral votes, and Obama only five.


The national popular vote would not affect gerrymandered House seats, but it would address the potential issue with presidential elections..
Gerrymandering......without which: DFW Oct 2013 #1
The Big Question: HOW??? Yupy Oct 2013 #2
Well we may be stuck until 2022 but.... LynneSin Oct 2013 #3
State Races Are Most Important Right Now!!!! redstatebluegirl Oct 2013 #26
In Canada, electoral districts are determined by an independent commission JBoy Oct 2013 #10
republicans always have to cheat/game the system for votes. Sunlei Oct 2013 #4
National Popular Vote fredamae Oct 2013 #5
Some swing states are trying to use gerrymandered districts to change the electoral college. Jim__ Oct 2013 #7
NPV is a start, anyway fredamae Oct 2013 #9
Didn't this come up about a year ago? Rstrstx Oct 2013 #12
Wow-I hadn't heard about that fredamae Oct 2013 #13
Yes. That US News story is from January. Jim__ Oct 2013 #14
That only fixes the way the nationwide office - president - is elected muriel_volestrangler Oct 2013 #23
No-POTUS Elections... fredamae Oct 2013 #25
Using your numbers: rgbecker Oct 2013 #6
AND if Corbett and the GOP Republicans have their way LynneSin Oct 2013 #8
Not sure if even that would work modrepub Oct 2013 #18
Obama would have won it in 2008, but in 2012, Romney won it 50.4% to 48.5% muriel_volestrangler Oct 2013 #24
Poor Jerry Mander is going to be ribbed for this incessantly. Kablooie Oct 2013 #11
This is exactly what happened in NC. mnhtnbb Oct 2013 #15
This is such an important issue but I don't see much action on this matter Yupy Oct 2013 #16
You are ignoring the main problem. former9thward Oct 2013 #17
But didn't the Supreme Court overrule that in their previous ruling a few months ago LynneSin Oct 2013 #19
No, the majority minority districts were not contested. former9thward Oct 2013 #20
We lost in 2010 because we stayed home instead of voting 4dsc Oct 2013 #21
Correct but because we stayed home and didn't vote.... LynneSin Oct 2013 #32
Honestly Dwayne Hicks Oct 2013 #22
Agreed. We had a Green in the State House who had his district gerrymandered out from under him, but GreenPartyVoter Oct 2013 #27
Money causes the corruption in politics. Money allows the gerrymandering. lonestarnot Oct 2013 #29
Money and an insane desire for power. GreenPartyVoter Oct 2013 #30
Couldn't agree more underpants Oct 2013 #28
Unless otherwise legally overturned, voter registration and GOTV ffr Oct 2013 #31
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»The biggest issue with ou...»Reply #7