Why does American Idol make them perform the song that got them voted off?

[Shell Beau]

Isn't that kinda shitty?

[merh]

1. I'm pissed

Sabrina was 1000000000 times better than Haley.

I hope someone signs her up, gives her a chance.

Haley suxs and should be voted off. :(

:grr:

[Shell Beau]

2. I am livid!! HAley should have left in the beginning! WTF????????

She was awful and Sabrina was one of my faves!

[merh]

4. This is ridiculous

gawd, I'm just sick. :mad:

[rzemanfl]

3. You have got to be kidding me, she was one of the best. n/t

[merh]

5. not kidding

:(

[rzemanfl]

6. Who else? n/t

[merh]

7. Sundance just got the boot!

:( He was one of the best male voices. Man the public is screwy :crazy:


Antonella was booted.

[Shell Beau]

8. WTF?

I have always loved Sundance!! Sanjaya has no place there. He has a decent voice, but he is far from good! I am so pissed!

[blue neen]

9. Sundance got ripped off.

His performance of "Mustang Sally" last week was fantastic.

I'm shocked. :wtf:

[Shell Beau]

10. And his Pearl Jam was WAY better than anything Sanjaya has sang!

x(

[merh]

11. I agreed with Jared and Antonella being voted off

but NOT SABRINA AND SUNDANCE :mad:

[Shell Beau]

13. Me too!!

x(

[S n o w b a l l]

12. I'm thinking I'm through with Idol this year...

After last week, then now this???? It's a joke!

[Shell Beau]

14. I am almost with you! I am hoping that there are some sensible people

left in the public and that Haley and Sanjaya will be voted off first!!

x(

[Strawman]

15. They should have people vote contestants off

Rather than vote for their favorite. Especially this early. Voting for 16 different people allows a cluster of joke voters to do what they did tonight. It's unfair and it's cruel. Even that Sanjaya kid who advanced looked embarassed. People are votng for him because he is bad as a joke.

[Shell Beau]

20. I agree. But then you'll have the vote off the best for a joke!

x(

[Strawman]

22. That would be harder

Cuz all the people who voted in good faith for someone decent would tend to concur about who was the worst

[bullwinkle428]

16. Prediction: Sanjaya's going to build momentum each week, after VFTW

decides to get behind him. Wouldn't surprise me to see him get to the final 6...

[Mike Daniels]

17. The probably sing the most recent song cause it's the freshest in their mind

and they don't have to relearn it.

They don't have a week to rehearse or relearn an older choice like they normally would leading up to the competition day.

[Mr. Blonde]

19. I was going to say

the band probably has a part in it too. They already have to keep up with a bunch of songs, this way makes it easier.

[Mike Daniels]

18. The probably sing the most recent song cause it's the freshest in their mind

and they don't have to relearn it.

They don't have a week to rehearse or relearn an older choice like they normally would leading up to the competition day.

[Shell Beau]

21. True! But woudln't it suck to have to sing the song that got you voted off

RIGHT after you got voted off?

[cmkramer]

23. One exception that I remember

Latoya London sang "Don't Rain On My Parade" which she had sung for Big Band Night a week or so before.