IT'S ABOUT TIME!
The view of America from afar
Happy Memorial Day.
On our visits to Ireland and Italy, with a brief stop in England, Nina and I had no desire of engaging in any political discussions. This was to be a holiday.
We should have known better. There is no way to avoid politics if the visitor is seen as a representative of the most powerful nation in the world, the one that sets the agenda for everyone else, whether they like it or not.
Of course, it is all about Iraq. Nothing else matters these days in any discussion of America. In pubs, restaurants, hotels, on the street, in gas stations, in airports, in private homes, the subject almost always came up.
It is impossible to exaggerate the wide, and widening, gulf between the American attitude on the Iraq war and the view from our friends across the Atlantic. This is the people talking, not the governments.
According to polls, we in this country are about evenly divided on whether we were right or wrong to go to war in Iraq. Not so in Europe. The polls show an enormous majority, sometimes 85 to 15 percent, of people who believe it was a mistake. The numbers have remained constant for two years and more.
It is fair to say that our personal experience over a two-week period mirrored those numbers, but this must be added: Very seldom was bitterness expressed toward the American people. Only toward the governmental policies.
It was not anger, it was bewilderment. What were we doing? What was the strategic mission? If it was oil, why did we have to get so many Americans and others killed? We could have squeezed Iraq for all its oil without firing a shot. Was it religion? If so, surely history had taught us all that the mix of religion and policy was no-win. Ireland knew it better than most.
The gulf between the priorities here and there was also obvious in the news coverage.
While we were there, major news headlines were made and led TV news stories prepared on the "Downing Street Memo." That was the document in which British intelligence asserted in the summer of 2002 that they went to Washington to discuss the evidence of Iraq's complicity in terrorism. They soon discovered that evidence was not required. "The intelligence and the facts," said the memo, "were being fixed around the policy," which was to invade Iraq, even though there was almost no evidence of terrorism and evidence of weapons of mass destruction "was thin."
America was going to war in Iraq and that was that. Great Britain could go along or be left behind. Again, that British memo was written in the summer of 2002. This news in Europe was considered the "smoking gun" that Tony Blair had, indeed, "cooked the books" in making his case for war. And so had the U.S. government.
The other huge story was the visit by maverick British Member of Parliament George Galloway to a U.S. Senate committee hearing in which he aggressively and effectively scorched the halls of Congress with red-hot rhetoric on Iraq. Galloway had been accused by the committee of getting warrants for oil to sell from Iraq as part of the notorious "Oil for Food" program managed - poorly - by the U.N.
He presented a convincing case that he never made a "thin dime" from any such program, that he had documentation, that he had won a libel suit on the issues and was prepared to do it again.
But what caused the uproar in Europe - British, Spanish, French, Italian, Irish and German TV led with it - was his sharp and eloquent attack on America's role in the war, from the run-up to the present day. He said, and had specific contemporary quotes, that he had been right and we had been wrong at every step.
Even those in Europe who disagree with Mr. Galloway's fiery politics - and there are many - found his confrontation with our august Senate refreshing.
When Nina and I got back, I found that our newspapers had pretty much buried both stories, which were so important to 350,000,000 of our natural allies.
All that said, I was most disturbed by what a middle-aged man in an Irish pub said to me. "Why aren't you making things anymore? Americans used to make all the things we wanted. Now you don't make anything I want or need." That was the most troubling indictment of America I heard on our trip.
America, the temple of invention and industry, doesn't make things anymore.
Write to Nick Clooney c/o The Post, 125 E. Court St., Cincinnati, Ohio 45202
http://news.cincypost.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050530/LIFE03/505300301/1008/LIFE