Reply #30: I think the new rules are fine.

[MGKrebs]

Even if they were permanent. There are many threads I just don't read because they are obviously (to me) just trying to be provocative with no real purpose or content. For some reason, these are also the threads that end up with 180 responses including 170 borderline attacks. Even if it ends up somehow on an actual issue, it is hardly worth it to wade through the BS to contribute.

LBN has special rules because I believe it is set up to achieve a specific goal. GD also has a goal- in depth discussion of issues (do I have that right?) Keeping the discussion relatively civilized and thoughtful seems like a reasonable path to that goal. Anything else that doesn't fit there also has a home- The Lounge.

I've been to "anything goes" discussion sites, and it is practically impossible to have a reasonable discussion.

You guys do a great job.