Reply #2: Who would meet your standard? Political assassins? Isn't that what they want?

[leveymg]

You say we're all responsible for torture because we're Americans. Every single one of us. Any exceptions? Not one? If we're still a torturer regardless of any legal action we might take, what choice does that leave us? What of those who commit political violence against the state? Hardly seems logical to assert that armed insurgents are guilty of complicity? But, consider this - if political violence does not succeed at overthrowing the regime, it will likely justify even wider torture and other abuses. No, that's just playing into the hands of those who want to expand repression.

I don't think your political construct is valid because it doesn't allow for any constructive choices, at all.

Is there anyone who measures up to your impossible standard of moral righteousness?