Reply #13: I don't need to read it. I know it. And I only left out the beginning for brevity.

[Berry Cool]

You have made my point. The combination of a call to one's better nature, and a practical demonstration of self-sacrifice, is indeed what makes this scene so wonderful.

What you and I disagree on is the kind of compromise that needs to be made. George and Mary Bailey made a sacrifice and the people accepted only enough money to tide them over because there was a "greater good" known as the long term.

A case can indeed be made that this scene supports people who compromise on what they need most at the moment in order to get something they believe is for the greater good because they will not have to pay for what they need right now with their souls.

Yes, "The film seems to be saying don't get panicked into a compromise that hurts others, but rather make a different compromise that might help others." But this is NOT that kind of compromise. It is the "Mr. Potter is offering us 50 cents on the dollar!" compromise. It hurts everyone but "Mr. Potter." Because in the end, if we make it, he will win.

And THAT was my point.