Democratic Underground

Ask Auntie Pinko
January 11, 2002


Dear Auntie Pinko,

I'm a real liberal kid in high school in a real conservative part of Maryland. Recently I got in an argument about the Confederate flag and how I believe it is a symbol of hatred while my friends call it a symbol for states rights. Please clarify what the rebel flag really means to America.

Nick,
Annapolis, MD


Dear Nick,

America is made up of millions of individuals, and our Constitution guarantees each of us the right to assign whatever meaning pleases us to various symbols - like the Confederate flag. This is why, although Auntie Pinko personally assigns a definitely uncomplimentary meaning to the Confederate flag, I am in complete support of an individual's right to put those silly-looking flag decals across the back windows of their pickup trucks, display it in front of their trailers, embroider it on their ball caps, etc.

This right to assign our own personal meanings to various symbols, and to behave accordingly, is part of the freedom guaranteed to each American by the First Amendment. And this discussion is especially timely right now because of the current popularity of another symbol - the American flag - and the heavy baggage of meaning being loaded onto it by would-be thought police, the media, and commercial opportunists who see a golden opportunity for fast bucks.

In other words, Auntie Pinko would protect your friends' right to display and honor the Confederate flag for the same reason I would expect them to protect my right not to display the American flag, and not to pledge allegiance to that symbol. My personal religious and ethical beliefs do not allow me to extend to an inanimate object - even one which symbolizes the most noble of human ideals - anything that resembles the worship I reserve for the Divine.

And that, Nick, is the essence of why I believe America, as a country, is worthy of my loyalty and my diligent observance of the responsibilities of citizenship. Those responsibilities include: educating myself; giving time and effort to participate in the democratic process; paying the taxes that promote the public well-being; and being prepared to offer the deepest personal sacrifice to which I can morally commit if government by the Constitution of the United States is in immediate and present physical danger.

They do not include: paying homage to national symbols, offering unquestioning support to political leaders, assuming that anything my country does is morally right simply because it is my country, or believing that the economic and political interests of my country are superior, better, or more important, than other countries' interests or than the ability of the planet Earth to sustain human life.

So, Nick, while Auntie Pinko might question the taste of those who honor the flag that flew over the defenders of human slavery, she will never question their right to do so. That is what the Confederate flag means to this American, at any rate.

And thank you for asking Auntie Pinko!

View Auntie's Archive

Printer-friendly version
Tell a friend about this article Tell a friend about this article
Discuss this article

 

Do you have a question for Auntie Pinko?

Do political discussions discombobulate you? Are you a liberal at a loss for words when those darned dittoheads babble their endless rhetoric at you? Or are you a conservative who just can't understand those pesky liberals and their silliness? Auntie Pinko has an answer for everything! So ask away!

My name is:

My hometown is:

My email address is:

And here is my question: