General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhat was Archie Bunker's job? Or occupation?
A friend said that the people who support Trump are while old blue color workers. In short, Archie Bunker. But, he added, Archie Bunker is dead by now...
RandySF
(86,367 posts)jaysunb
(11,856 posts)murielm99
(33,095 posts)He moonlighted as a cab driver.
question everything
(52,417 posts)In those days, union members were quite conservative, I think, did not appreciate the opposition to Vietnam
David__77
(24,860 posts)Union members and leaders could be quite right-wing, indeed.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)GP6971
(38,415 posts)but loading dock yes. Longshoreman made way too much money for what the series depicted.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)"I don't work. I'm the foreman!"
dflprincess
(29,418 posts)until he bought a bar.
Whatever he did I do recall it was a union job (I seem to recall an episode that involved a strike). He was a WWII vet so chances are he would be dead (as is Carroll O'Connor who was quite a liberal).
And, sadly, he was a blue collar guy who had gone over to the dark side, supporting Nixon and telling Edith's cousin, Maude, (Yes, Bea Arthur's Maude) that the country was ruined by Franklin Delano Roosevelt.
Freddie
(10,144 posts)Carroll O'Connor was Irish - like born, raised and educated in Dublin Irish - and he was brilliant as the quintessential American of the day. And yes, very much a liberal.
Orange Free State
(611 posts)...and grew up in Queens, so I guess he was well qualified to portray Archie, accent and all. He did graduate from the University of Dublin.
I understand thatNorman Lear wanted Mickey Rooney to play Archie Bunker. Would have been different for sure, given Rooneys leanings. I think he was far right.
bottomofthehill
(9,425 posts)Which is why he was so good at Archie. He was able to draw on a lot of the people and houses he grew up in. He joined the merchant marine in wwII and did not return to Ny after the war
LeftInTX
(34,853 posts)I didn't watch TV much back then. (Well I've never watched TV very much)
I remember Maude being on All in the Family, but just assumed she was one of their neighbors.
angrychair
(12,545 posts)Carroll O'Connor the person, who played Archie Bunker, was a dyed in the wool liberal. Associating Carroll with the trump ilk is likely enough to raise him from the dead in anger.
I always had a rolling theory that the Carrolls portrayal of Archie was was one of many of Steven Colberts inspiration for his character.
question everything
(52,417 posts)which people tend to do.
And as I asked here earlier, shall we boycott them because of their recent actions?
Weinstien has brought great movies to us, often art movies that, were it not for him, we've never seen.
I was thinking specifically of Wind River - about the disappearance of native American women that no one cares. It was really a touching beautiful movie. We saw it last month and, yes, we groaned when the credit rolled at the end and we saw Weinstein's name. And I wonder whether the movie will not be recognized by any award ceremony because of this association.
On the other hand, Gary Cooper has been admired by generations and yet he named names when appearing in front of McCarthy. So I will not watch any of his classic movies.
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)such an ignorant and stupid conservative that I doubt any right-leaning actor would have enjoyed the role.
While it is true that there were people who shared Archie's POV, the show made sure to highlight Archie's ignorance and stupidity by having him utter one idiotic line after another. Archie Bunker needed to be played by a liberal who was in on the joke. Carrol O'Connor was the perfect choice to portray Archie Bunker.
radical noodle
(10,692 posts)changed some conservative minds. When they heard the stupid stuff they said come out of Archie's mouth and be laughed at, it made those attitudes pretty unpopular. I really think we need another All In The Family show. Stupid Trump voters should be laughed at for their ignorance.
eShirl
(20,446 posts)question everything
(52,417 posts)not when he was ranting and raving, arguing with "Meathead."
Rhiannon12866
(258,986 posts)He took over Kelsey's bar during the last year of All in the Family - and this show continued after Jean Stapleton left the show.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0078562/
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)in which Archie invites a friend whose son had been killed in Vietnam, and Michael invited a friend who had fled to Canada to avoid the draft.
My question is, why wasn't Michael drafted?
David__77
(24,860 posts)He was in college when the show started. My understanding is that that allowed for deferment at least sometimes.
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)Igel
(37,614 posts)Or perhaps he simply wasn't drafted.
It wasn't the case that every eligible male who registered was drafted. They had a lottery; days of the year were ordered from first to be drafted to last, by random drawing. Within that, they drew letters of the alphabet to determine order. If your number (birthday) was pulled, then you'd be called up in alphabetical order according to the random drawing.
My brother joined the service in 1966 because he'd be drafted. Turned out that he wouldn't have been drafted after all; his lottery number was so low that he wouldn't have been called up.
(And the real reason: It's a tv show.)
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)Canoe52
(2,963 posts)I was number 85 or so, thought I was going for sure, but they only called up to number 50 something that year. What a relief that was.
LoveMyCali
(2,047 posts)because he was a college student.
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)the show mentioning it.
Canoe52
(2,963 posts)Orange Free State
(611 posts)lunamagica
(9,967 posts)radical noodle
(10,692 posts)Then they had baby Joey and that would have given him some way around too. Later they had the lottery, so that could have been the luck of the draw.
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)hexola
(4,835 posts)I assume Meathead had a college deferment....?
JI7
(93,908 posts)Willie Pep
(841 posts)Over Christmas I got to listen to some of my Trump-supporting relatives and some of them are well-educated and make good money so not all Trump supporters are blue-collar workers.
Kablooie
(19,121 posts)JHB
(38,339 posts)...Carroll O'Connor was the actor.
padfun
(1,927 posts)They are a good portion of the Trump cult.
AllaN01Bear
(29,808 posts)Mike Nelson
(10,943 posts)...question has already been answered. I would only add that the bigotry shown in the character has no one job description. Today, everything about "Archie Bunker" suggests he would favor a Democrat - but he would be a Trump supporter.
I was surprised to speak with a far right relative about the show, recently. I thought he would have hated "All in the Family". No... he loved the show, identified with "Archie" completely, and put-down the "Meathead" and liberals. He saw a completely different show...
MichMan
(17,408 posts)Last edited Wed Dec 27, 2017, 10:43 AM - Edit history (1)
This was a really groundbreaking show that did address many social issues of the time that up to then were considered off limits. Whomever cast the characters was a genius.
While Archie had his flaws and was very opinionated, when you got past his gruff exterior, he had a good heart
Kick in to the DU tip jar?
This week we're running a special pop-up mini fund drive. From Monday through Friday we're going ad-free for all registered members, and we're asking you to kick in to the DU tip jar to support the site and keep us financially healthy.
As a bonus, making a contribution will allow you to leave kudos for another DU member, and at the end of the week we'll recognize the DUers who you think make this community great.