General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTrump is working on a stealth plan to cut Social Security benefits and avoid 2020 backlash.
Last week, the Trump administration revealed that it is planning to employ the so-called chained Consumer Price Index (CPI) in a way that does not need congressional approval. Chained CPI might sound technical and boring, but anyone who has closely followed the Social Security debate knows better. It has long been proposed as a deceptive, hard-to-understand way to cut our earned Social Security benefits.
Trump plans to switch to the chained CPI to index the federal definition of poverty. If he succeeds, the impact will be that over time, fewer people will meet the governments definition of povertyeven though in reality, they will not be any less poor. The definition is crucial to qualify for a variety of federal benefits, including Medicaid, as well as food and housing assistance. The announcement was written blandly about considering a variety of different measures, but anyone who knows the issue well can easily read the writing on the wall.
So, what does this have to do with Social Security? Like the poverty level, Social Securitys modest benefits are automatically adjusted to keep pace with inflation. If not adjusted, those benefits will erode, slowly but inexorably losing their purchasing power over time. These annual adjustments are already too low, but they are better than no adjustment at all. The chained CPI would make these adjustments even less adequate. The top line of the following chart shows what a more accurate adjustment would look like. The line below it shows what the current adjustment does to benefits, and the bottom line shows what the stingier chained CPI would do:
Proponents of the chained CPI say that it is better at measuring substitution, but dont be fooled. The current inadequate measure already takes into account substitution of similar items. This is the idea that if the price of beef goes up, you can substitute chicken. In contrast, the chained CPI involves what are called substitutions across categories. If your planned vacation abroad goes up, you can stay home and buy a flat screen television and concert tickets instead.
RKP5637
(67,086 posts)how many Americans know what that means.
druidity33
(6,444 posts)the uproar when the Obama admin thought about doing this. That rat Geitner was involved i think...
johnnyfins
(809 posts)Honeycombe8
(37,648 posts)It's not so secret. I've heard descriptions of plans for "wonderful new programs" by Senator Cassidy (R-La) and others, but when I look at them, I can see it's a disguised way to partially privatize Social Security.
Death by a million cuts. Trumpers just can't get it through their heads that Trump and his ilk are the elite, not actors. Trump and his ilk have no compassion, knowledge, or caring for working people. They live in a bubble and have no experience of what it's like to be one of the little people, as Leona Helmsley called us.
NewJeffCT
(56,828 posts)Trump cutting social security
Achilleaze
(15,543 posts)Greedy, heartless bastards.
olegramps
(8,200 posts)They will do anything to prevent the wealthy paying their fair share. Just consider this fact: a working class person paying their social security pays an enormously higher percentage of the wages in to social security than a millionaire would be paying the same amount however, it would represent only a fraction of their income, but when retired both receive the same benefit.