Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mia

(8,360 posts)
Tue May 21, 2019, 08:17 PM May 2019

Artist Kate Kretz was BANNED from Facebook for this piece. WARNING

The MAGA hat crowd are in denial about the racist front that they project.

Thankful that a Facebook friend saved the art and the artist's statement before it disappeared.



A Cautionary Tale on Art, Censorship & Social Media
by Kate Kretz - May 20

I’m one of those artists who’s been plugging away in the studio for the past thirty years. Part of the Art World’s middle tier, I am perpetually hovering on the edge of my “big break”, but I no longer hold my breath in wait for it. I have work in a few important collections, and a 25-page CV. I’ve won Arts Council grants in all the states I’ve lived in, I have a few nice exhibition catalogs, and have been in museum shows across the country and abroad. I hope to move up a few more rungs on the art world ladder before I die, but that’s far less important to me than consistently making work I am proud of.

Presently, all but the top 1% of artists are struggling. Several artist grants have dried up, and sales have declined, leaving creatives to expend more energy simply trying to make ends meet. So many middle-tier galleries have closed that a large number of artists like myself are managing our own careers full-time while making art. Social media has been a tremendous help in this area: I can create a new work, post it, get instant feedback, and often, within a few weeks or months, get offers to exhibit it. While a few hundred to a few thousand people might see my art “in real life” during the course of an exhibition, a strong, well-photographed image placed on social media can reach ten times as many eyes through multiple “shares”.

As artists look for new paradigms to cultivate audiences for our work, we gravitate towards platforms like Facebook. Many artists are introverts, or suffer from social anxiety. For them, social media is a godsend, because they can share what they make without awkward personal interactions and dreaded small talk. (Someone like Van Gogh, for example, would have loved it.) I’m an artist living outside of NYC, with a teaching job, a compulsive studio practice, and a child, so I rarely have time to socialize. I post on Instagram, despite the fact that I find the calculated branding, slickness and “following” games off putting, but most of my social media time is spent on Facebook. I like the longer conversational format, the ability to post multiple images / albums, and the opportunity to trade pictures and links back and forth in extended conversations. It’s become my primary source of social interaction with my peers, and my art career “distribution center”.

When it comes to my studio practice, I have always believed that art is supposed to tell the truth about things people don’t want to talk about. Within that realm, eight years ago my focus shifted from the personal to the political. I was thinking about the world my newborn daughter would grow up in. I was overwhelmed by the daily news and was starting to pick up on cultural rumblings all around me that were quite unsettling: that drove me to research and creation at an unprecedented, feverish pitch that continues to this day. My practice is now devoted to calling out injustices against disparate parts of our community, investigating overlaps to suggest that, although the victims may change, the perpetrators are often the same. I have named the ongoing series “#bullyculture”, because I believe that the U.S. cultivates aggression and entitlement in a myriad of ways, both overt and subtle. Much of the work in this series foreshadowed both the 2016 election and the #metoo movement by several years.

The series is difficult and provocative: it requires warning signs when exhibited. Early work on the fetishization of guns resulted in threats to me and my family. Some have said or implied that I am “asking for” whatever happens to me as a result of making this series. In response, I maintain that 1.) I have never heard anyone tell a male artist that he was “asking for it” (that term is, after all, the language of abuse), and, 2.) none of the art I have produced is more disturbing than the things happening in real life that inspired me to make the work. I am simply embroidering, burning wood, drawing or painting… not hurting humans, animals, or the earth, like the perpetrators featured in my work. Get outraged at the injustice, not the art calling it to light.

Within the larger “#bullyculture” context, there are sub-series: the one that currently engages me is called “The MAGA Hat Collection.” I have been ordering MAGA hats (all knockoffs, with the exception of one), ripping them apart, and then sewing them back together into traditional symbols of hatred. The works are meant to both call out wearers who claim the hats to be innocuous, and to sound the alarm that history is repeating itself.
45 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Artist Kate Kretz was BANNED from Facebook for this piece. WARNING (Original Post) mia May 2019 OP
Banned for that?!?!?! WTF? ProudLib72 May 2019 #1
It was just Facebook. Her website is still publicly available with everything intact. TwilightZone May 2019 #2
Good to know. mia May 2019 #4
Isn't "censorship" on Facebook a thing with conservatives right now? gratuitous May 2019 #18
She has a series of people named "Gunlickers" in Google images: Judi Lynn May 2019 #36
Wow. Her website is outstanding! Thanks, so much! Love the "lie hole" series! n/t Judi Lynn May 2019 #37
Fuck Facebook. They helped get Trump installed. Zuckerberg's plan. triron May 2019 #42
Where does her "Cautionary Tale" say she was banned from FB? maxsolomon May 2019 #3
Preface to the artist's statement. mia May 2019 #6
Ok, but you didn't link to it. maxsolomon May 2019 #29
Do you have a link to this artist's webpage? Control-Z May 2019 #5
Artist's webpage mia May 2019 #7
Thanks for the link. Her art is incredible. JudyM May 2019 #35
I must have spent an hour looking at her work. Haggis for Breakfast May 2019 #43
Right, me too. Visceral. Such talent and dedication! JudyM May 2019 #45
Do you have a link? davekriss May 2019 #8
Do you mean to the artist's webpage? mia May 2019 #9
Thank you, yes, I meant the artists webpage davekriss May 2019 #23
I just posted this image to my Facebook page... JoeOtterbein May 2019 #10
Yes. Please do. mia May 2019 #11
34 minutes still up here! nt JoeOtterbein May 2019 #15
I'm getting curious if will be still up in the morning. I can't wait to see! nt JoeOtterbein May 2019 #16
I hope that it will still be there. mia May 2019 #17
One hour and still up! nt JoeOtterbein May 2019 #19
wtg joe Captain Zero May 2019 #12
You got it Captain! (as I stand at attention saluting or something !-) Stay tuned! nt JoeOtterbein May 2019 #14
and yet they wont remove the biggest bully of them all. AllaN01Bear May 2019 #13
Yeah, imagine that! smirkymonkey May 2019 #24
IKR !?!?! uponit7771 May 2019 #25
Ah, but there's a mistake: sandensea May 2019 #20
But the art reflects what's going on with the illegal occupant of the white house. nt iluvtennis May 2019 #21
Check out this artist's "gunlicker" series. MontanaMama May 2019 #22
Petition for Kate hermetic May 2019 #26
Thank you for this link. mia May 2019 #27
It should be on the cover of Time and Newsweek. CaptYossarian May 2019 #28
Yes, definitely. JudyM May 2019 #34
Reminds me of this one. Not banned (yet?) garybeck May 2019 #30
This message was self-deleted by its author brandnewday2009 May 2019 #31
Excellent, she solved her exposure problem Kind of Blue May 2019 #32
Unfettered Admiration Offered corbettkroehler May 2019 #33
Getting banned from fb is a good thing. Chin music May 2019 #38
Jon McNaughton is the only artist that should be allowed on Facebook Blue Owl May 2019 #39
My FB post of this is still up! JoeOtterbein May 2019 #40
Good news! mia May 2019 #41
Maybe cause my RWNJ Trumper FB "friends" are so used to me... JoeOtterbein May 2019 #44

gratuitous

(82,849 posts)
18. Isn't "censorship" on Facebook a thing with conservatives right now?
Tue May 21, 2019, 10:47 PM
May 2019

I'll bet Fox and the rest of the Nitwit Brigade will be all over this in defense of Kretz and her artistic vision, right?

Whoa, crickets are out early this year.

Judi Lynn

(160,449 posts)
36. She has a series of people named "Gunlickers" in Google images:
Wed May 22, 2019, 03:47 PM
May 2019







York College art exhibit features men licking their guns
Mike Argento, margento@ydr.com Published 1:08 p.m. ET Feb. 27, 2018 | Updated 1:09 p.m. ET Feb. 27, 2018

Kate Kretz started thinking about it years ago, long before Harvey Weinstein and his peculiar ways sparked a national movement.

She was thinking about how all of this stuff was connected, how all of it crawled from the same fetid primordial pool.

She and her husband had a young daughter, and like many others, she would lay awake at night wondering about the state of the world and what kind of place her daughter would inherit. And she started thinking that the things that worried her all had a common denominator, a wellspring of terrible ideas and horrible behavior that permeated and poisoned our culture.

Mostly, she said, she "thought about how all of those things are connected in terms of how we treat anyone who's different than us," from gun culture to rape culture to misogyny to racism to, well, everything.

More:
https://www.ydr.com/story/opinion/columnists/mike-argento/2018/02/27/york-college-art-exhibit-features-men-licking-their-guns/376207002/

maxsolomon

(33,244 posts)
3. Where does her "Cautionary Tale" say she was banned from FB?
Tue May 21, 2019, 08:36 PM
May 2019

Maybe I don't read so good no more, but I don't see it.

Is it further into the unlinked piece?

mia

(8,360 posts)
6. Preface to the artist's statement.
Tue May 21, 2019, 08:43 PM
May 2019

This was the beginning of the facebook post....

Artist Kate Kretz was BANNED from Facebook for this piece.
It obviously touched the same nerve in a lot of people:
MAGA hat wearers who don't think that they are racist bullies just because they support a racist bully.

In FB's rush to pretend it is cracking down on racism and hate speech, they are suppressing the artists who use their art to point out hate speech.

If you feel this is a misdirection, please share or make your own statement. We will see how long this post is allowed to stay up, and if I end up in Facebook jail.

I have been following Kate's work for several years now. It is powerful and provocative. I don't always like it, but I always respect it... and her freedom to express herself.

maxsolomon

(33,244 posts)
29. Ok, but you didn't link to it.
Wed May 22, 2019, 11:30 AM
May 2019

Still, that's a FB post ABOUT her being "banned". I'd wager the Klan-hood post was taken down and she got a time-out.

This part: "We will see how long this post is allowed to stay up, and if I end up in Facebook jail" is typical FB share-bait bullshit.

I see jingoistic Trump-humper stuff from my elderly Aunt that uses the same victimhood rhetoric: "Share if you agree! We'll see who really loves 'Merica!"

Haggis for Breakfast

(6,831 posts)
43. I must have spent an hour looking at her work.
Wed May 22, 2019, 08:24 PM
May 2019

Some of it was so powerful; I had a visceral reaction to certain pieces.



JudyM

(29,187 posts)
45. Right, me too. Visceral. Such talent and dedication!
Wed May 22, 2019, 11:22 PM
May 2019

Would be great if Tom Steyer types would engage her in national exposure.

davekriss

(4,616 posts)
23. Thank you, yes, I meant the artists webpage
Wed May 22, 2019, 12:32 AM
May 2019

Apologies, I easily could have googled that up. Thanks!

sandensea

(21,596 posts)
20. Ah, but there's a mistake:
Tue May 21, 2019, 11:10 PM
May 2019

That hood should have a Chinese or Taiwanese flag, as that's where MAGA hats are mostly made.

Response to mia (Original post)

Kind of Blue

(8,709 posts)
32. Excellent, she solved her exposure problem
Wed May 22, 2019, 02:38 PM
May 2019

and will get more eyes and a lot more recognition for her works now.

JoeOtterbein

(7,699 posts)
44. Maybe cause my RWNJ Trumper FB "friends" are so used to me...
Wed May 22, 2019, 08:29 PM
May 2019

...posting anti-Trump/GOP stuff all the time, they didn't notice enough to report me!

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Artist Kate Kretz was BAN...