Did The 'Send Her Back' Chant Break Out From The Crowd Spontaneously Or....

[global1]

was it pre-planned, deliberate and an intentional chant prompted by Trump's campaign people?

It's almost like Trump told his campaign people that they need to come up with a new chant for the rallies to replace 'Lock Her Up'.

I just can't believe that this crowd came up with that chant all by themselves. I would like to hear from the media people in the room as to how this chant broke out. Did they think it was prompted by Trump's campaign people?

[no_hypocrisy]

1. I have similar thoughts.

[Watchfoxheadexplodes]

2. Seemed spontaneous but

Very loud from just a few at beginning I think you are onto something.

[global1]

3. I Want This Question Examined By The MSM....

I would like to hear a discussion about this on CNN or MSNBC.

[Watchfoxheadexplodes]

4. Little girl on trumps left behind him seemed shocked

At first but then chimed in.

Several behind trump never uttered it at all.

[True Blue American]

13. Planned, they all are

The people behind him were slow getting there. Paid plants in the crowd.

[TheCowsCameHome]

5. Everything Trump does is orchestated/planned.

It's called being a total fake.

[GoCubsGo]

9. Yep, including this stunt.

I have no doubt they planted people in the crowd to start that chant, or otherwise instigated it. It's not that difficult to lead those dupes along like that. Sheep are gonna sheep.

[Arazi]

6. Iirc, Steve Bannon had "plants" in campaign rally audiences to start chants

I'm sure this was not an organic chant but an orchestrated new addition to the ritual frenzy these events have become

[Anon-C]

7. Seems very deliberate, especially the chant that followed Trump's claiming Rep. Omar is anti-semetic

...worked at least on one news channel that was reporting on the chant. What was broadcast clearly and repeatedly was Trump's claim...that's the message that was clearly conveyed.

Both sides, you know.

[cwydro]

8. He seems to have got what he wanted when they responded to him.

Dems need to be very cautious at taking his bait.

[Hermit-The-Prog]

10. "lock her up" came from the Ukraine

TrumPutin continues to use Putin's methods.

https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2017/10/30/1711184/-The-Ukrainian-Origins-of-LOCK-HER-UP

[marble falls]

11. Nothing's by chance at a Nazi rally,

[tanyev]

12. I think it was just as spontaneous as the never named reporter who asked DT if he felt vindicated

after Nunes announced that he had seen reports that the intelligence community had incidentally collected information about Trump's transition team in March 2017.

[global1]

14. It Looks Like The MSM Is Taking The Bait And Saying That This New Chant.....

erupted spontaneously.

When they do this without fully examining whether this was spontaneous or pre-planned they wind up providing Trump with the desired outcome he was looking for - to bolster his re-election strategy.

[NewJeffCT]

15. I was reading that it was pre-planned and fed to the crowd

by Trump campaign staffers

I'll see if I can find the link, but I'm on a call at work until around 10

[colsohlibgal]

16. His Puppets Love Him

This is so like some of the early rallies of Hitler and Mussolini. His fans either never had the capacity for critical thinking or years of Fox News have tamped that down deep. They are like puppets, most of them in a financial situation that is being hurt by their hero.

This is the full bloom of long time resentment by the unwashed masses of all the moves and laws of the Civil Rights Movement. Many still see the Civil War as the war of Northern Aggression.

I have to think Orange Creep’s recent overt up front racism, sexism, and homophobia is turning off some of his more moderate, more educated, supporters, particularly College educated women.

I see no way that Idiot can win the popular vote but because of the stupid and antiquated Electoral College.....well that makes it worrisome. Get out and vote like your life depends on it in those swing states!

[Wounded Bear]

17. If you go to enough WWE events, you learn when to respond...

same thing with church, although most churches aren't quite as violent.

[Grammy23]

18. Just go to any high school football game where there are cheerleaders.

They instruct and demonstrate for the crowd what to say, what to chant. Eventually the crowd knows when to say, Push ‘em back or hold that line, etc. tRump and his rally planners know this is how you get a crowd to say or chant what you want them to. Plant a few leaders in the crowd who blend in to look like everyone else. At preplanned times, they erupt into the desired chant. After a few rallies, the crowd had been taught their part. All it takes is one or two leaders to start the chant. Easy peasy.

Anyone who has ever been to a ball game knows there is an emotional element to it, too. Get the crowd revved up enough and they will tear a stadium apart “celebrating”. They will trample each other, tear down goal posts, set cars on fire and create havoc. And this is often done by the winning side. All brought on by an emotional frenzy. tRump is playing with fire. It can easily spin out of his control so he better be careful what he tries to create.

[Wounded Bear]

22. Yep. Everything you said is true...nt

[Joe941]

19. He is the reality tv pResident...

Nothing on tv is spontaneous... it's all a script.

[GusBob]

20. Easy answer. How long was the pause after it started?

There was a long pause in his speech while they chanted

[malaise]

21. Duh!

pre-planned, deliberate and an intentional chant prompted by Trump's campaign people.