Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Cyrano

(15,035 posts)
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 01:06 AM Jul 2019

No American should ever again ask, "How/Why did it happen in Germany"

We're seeing it up close and personal. It's been building for decades. And it has now come to the point where between 30% to 40% of Americans are eating shit and believing it's sirloin.

Germany, in the early 1930s, was an "advanced" country by most metrics. But during a period of a few short years, they plunged into barbarism. They turned from the future to the past. They embraced a self-destructive nationalism. They were manipulated by a small group of clever/malignant people who were seeking absolute power. And hatred of "The Other" was one of their major tools. -- Not every German bought into it. But enough did.

The majority of Americans denounce/reject Trumpism. But you don't require a majority to succeed. All you need is just enough people to buy the snake oil/drink the Kool-Aid/believe the well-packaged hate/spread the poison/become infected with the disease/despise their fellow human beings.

Not only can "it happen here." It's been happening here, in slow motion, for about 50 or more years. In short, John, Martin and Bobby are dead and Nixon's "Southern Strategy" has spread throughout the land to the ignorant everywhere. (Hatred, bigotry and ignorance don't recognize state lines.)

Perhaps the biggest lesson humanity can learn from this era is that bigotry/hatred outweigh self-interest. Those being hurt most by Trumpism are the MAGAs. Yet, they seem to have no problem fucking up their own well being, as long as they can "get the THEMS."

Does this tell us that hatred of "The Other" is stronger than self interest? I can't say for sure, but it certainly seems so. And if that's true, it makes humanity a suicidal species.

Disagree with this? Well, take a look at some old photos of what Germany looked like in 1945 after the civilized world bombed them into total rubble.

No one is going to bomb us back into the stone ages. But when/if another world war occurs, it will last for perhaps a few hours and then, humanity will be over. We will have turned out to be an evolutionary mistake.

Republicans refuse to learn from history. What about the rest of us? Have we learned? Do we finally "get it?" And the biggest question of all: What are we going to do about it?

43 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
No American should ever again ask, "How/Why did it happen in Germany" (Original Post) Cyrano Jul 2019 OP
Trump would have his critics executed if he could Skittles Jul 2019 #1
+1. Or force them to fight to the death for his enjoyment dalton99a Jul 2019 #7
Once again, my friend you have hit the nail on the head FirstLight Jul 2019 #2
A tad premature,..This isn't Nazi Germany whathehell Jul 2019 #3
Nazi Germany wasn't Nazi Germany before it became Nazi Germany Cyrano Jul 2019 #4
+1 durablend Jul 2019 #13
And that is foolish Bettie Jul 2019 #16
Too many Americans, including some even here, are still burying their head in the sand. triron Jul 2019 #23
You clearly don't know the difference between OliverQ Jul 2019 #6
+1, this is so true it was like a boiling frog to them uponit7771 Jul 2019 #12
Nether did the OP., It seems.. whathehell Jul 2019 #31
How do you know this isn't the lead-up to something like Nazi Germany? pnwmom Jul 2019 #8
What steps are we missing before kristallnacht? Thanks in advance uponit7771 Jul 2019 #11
Nice try, but it's you who are obligated to first make the case whathehell Jul 2019 #25
Few to none, I'll answer my own question ... do you agree? tia uponit7771 Jul 2019 #36
Lol.. Yeah, I guess that's easier than making the original case. whathehell Jul 2019 #39
This isn't Nazi Germany, but it's attitudes like yours that made Nazi Germany possible. WhiskeyGrinder Jul 2019 #14
No, it's attitudes like yours.that give alarmists a bad name.. whathehell Jul 2019 #21
No, continue to rationalize. triron Jul 2019 #24
No, you continue to irrationalize.. whathehell Jul 2019 #26
We should be far removed, we're not ... that's scary enough no? tia uponit7771 Jul 2019 #37
OK, perhaps you could suggest reasons to feel Bettie Jul 2019 #15
I already have, in other posts in other threads whathehell Jul 2019 #19
Railing against "doom and gloom" is tantamount to the ostrich with its head in the sand Stinky The Clown Jul 2019 #17
Nah.. "Whoever invokes Hitler ( Nazi Germany) first, loses" whathehell Jul 2019 #18
you are entirely missing the point of the OP Takket Jul 2019 #22
I guess we're just supposed to say Bettie Jul 2019 #29
Post removed Post removed Jul 2019 #35
If I did, it's because the OP's point was poorly made.. whathehell Jul 2019 #38
If the USA starts nuking "shithole" countries with brown people PufPuf23 Jul 2019 #28
Your post is full of "What ifs"? whathehell Jul 2019 #34
The fact is that except for the actual act of "nuking", PufPuf23 Jul 2019 #42
Just looking at how urgent solving climate change is, and... Lock him up. Jul 2019 #5
#NeverAgainIsNow Hermit-The-Prog Jul 2019 #9
THIS !!!! uponit7771 Jul 2019 #10
on the up-side, evolution might proceed faster with more mutagens in the environment 0rganism Jul 2019 #20
We had a good run. nt OhZone Jul 2019 #27
"It Can't Happen Here" Retrograde Jul 2019 #30
Forget nazi Germany. What's happening now is infecting every democracy world Kurt V. Jul 2019 #32
I know -- the planet is going through convulsions. It's not just us. nt Hekate Jul 2019 #41
Evangelical Christians, too jberryhill Jul 2019 #33
I reached that point myself in stages: GOP nomination, election, increasing horror, numbness... Hekate Jul 2019 #40
The silver lining is that Germany came back- dawg day Jul 2019 #43

FirstLight

(13,360 posts)
2. Once again, my friend you have hit the nail on the head
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 01:21 AM
Jul 2019

I feel as if I am watching a dystopian reality unfold before my eyes...on SO MANY LEVELS

And also feeling the helplessness of my own circumstances to do anything...
Damn, o can barely keep my own head above water....how do I fix the broken govt?

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
3. A tad premature,..This isn't Nazi Germany
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 02:10 AM
Jul 2019

and it's not going to become it. I get that things are bad, but I see no value in hyperbolic doom and gloom

Cyrano

(15,035 posts)
4. Nazi Germany wasn't Nazi Germany before it became Nazi Germany
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 02:47 AM
Jul 2019

So exactly when is that line crossed?

Ignoring the rule of law?

Concentration camps on our southern border?

Taking a crap on the Constitution?

You call a comparison to Nazi Germany "A tad premature,..." So exactly when do Americans decide that it is no longer "premature?"

Let me say this, whatthehell. Most human beings don't wait until they've fallen off a cliff before reaching for a lifeline.

If you can look at the world of Trump, and think that anything short of a vision of doom and gloom is justified, I believe you are somehow missing what most people would call reality.

However, please let the rest of us know when our fears/beliefs are no longer "a tad premature."

I'm not mocking your belief. I just think that you are badly mistaken.

durablend

(7,460 posts)
13. +1
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 08:58 AM
Jul 2019

People just want to stick their heads in the sand and believe "laws" will prevent it from happening here.

triron

(21,995 posts)
23. Too many Americans, including some even here, are still burying their head in the sand.
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:37 PM
Jul 2019

Agree 110% with your post. Our local paper is in the same boat.

 

OliverQ

(3,363 posts)
6. You clearly don't know the difference between
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 02:52 AM
Jul 2019

1930s Germany and 1940s Germany. We're definitely in 1930s Germany territory, and yes it can happen here. Why would you think it can't?

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
31. Nether did the OP., It seems..
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 08:04 PM
Jul 2019

"Yes it can happen here"? .

Anything is possble, but it's very unlikely, due, for one of thing, to the historic differences between 1930's Germany and 2019 America.

Unlike 1930's Germany, we are not less than twenty years out of an imperial monsarchy. We are a two century plus democracy with long established democratic institutions.

pnwmom

(108,974 posts)
8. How do you know this isn't the lead-up to something like Nazi Germany?
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 04:41 AM
Jul 2019

They didn't start out by murdering millions. They started out with hate and deportations.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
25. Nice try, but it's you who are obligated to first make the case
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:42 PM
Jul 2019

that we are, in fact, pre- kristallnacht -- Thanks in advance.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
39. Lol.. Yeah, I guess that's easier than making the original case.
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 08:26 PM
Jul 2019

Unfortunately I can't be drawn into a discussion on it until you do.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
21. No, it's attitudes like yours.that give alarmists a bad name..
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:32 PM
Jul 2019

Enjoy the paranoia. The rest of us will continue to think rationally.

Bettie

(16,089 posts)
15. OK, perhaps you could suggest reasons to feel
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 09:07 AM
Jul 2019

positive and hopeful? Because I'm not seeing any.

We have a guy at the head of government who is untouchable in terms of law. He and his minions have declared they are absolutely untouchable and it seems to be the case, given that they have a complicit Senate and a timid House.

Same guy has already announced that he will accept any and all aid from foreign governments for his next campaign of destruction, there has been nothing to secure our elections, we have concentration camps operating in our borders (and they are celebrated by the orange thing's fans), and currently one in five of our federal judges were appointed by the orange pustule. And that is just a small portion of the fuckery going on.

So, tell me where the hope is there? Where? Because I'm having a hard time seeing it.

At one point, I thought maybe an impeachment inquiry would bring it all into the open, but I've given up hope for that ever happening at all.

SO, all of our eggs are in the basket of an election that is not going to be free or fair.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
19. I already have, in other posts in other threads
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:24 PM
Jul 2019

but those who seem to want to invoke Chicken Little with his falling sky seem to prefer the "Be afraid..Be very afraid"! mantra, so you'll have to forgive me if I choose not to waste my time again..

Stinky The Clown

(67,786 posts)
17. Railing against "doom and gloom" is tantamount to the ostrich with its head in the sand
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 10:31 AM
Jul 2019

The OP is right. It IS happening, right now, today.

The parallels to Nazi Germany are, of course imprecise. That was then and this is now. But comparisons to the overall trajectory is spot on.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
18. Nah.. "Whoever invokes Hitler ( Nazi Germany) first, loses"
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:17 PM
Jul 2019

That used to be a DU Truism, and AFAIC, still is.

This IS a bad time, but equating it to a regime that systematically murdered 6 million, is way over the top.

Takket

(21,555 posts)
22. you are entirely missing the point of the OP
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:36 PM
Jul 2019

The OP isn't saying "drumpf is rounding up and killing 6 million", the OP is saying parallels can be drawn between the rise of the Nazis in Germany and the rise of the modern Nazi (the MAGAt).

The dehumization of non-whites, concentration camps on the border, weaponization of "patriotism", ICE.... etc.

Bettie

(16,089 posts)
29. I guess we're just supposed to say
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:58 PM
Jul 2019

"Oh well, it all seems awful and no one is really doing anything to stop it, but gosh darn it, no one has come knocking on my door yet, so it's all good!"

I'm not able to do that.

Response to Takket (Reply #22)

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
38. If I did, it's because the OP's point was poorly made..
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 08:21 PM
Jul 2019

Of course I see paralles between the rise of European fascism 80 yesrs ago, but the OP pushed it further, making it a fait accompli, basically saying "We are now Naxi Germany", which we clearly are not.

PufPuf23

(8,764 posts)
28. If the USA starts nuking "shithole" countries with brown people
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:54 PM
Jul 2019

(and natural resources), are we as bad as Nazi Germany? Our feckless leader thinks this talk is OK and the act(s) to be considered.

What if we start putting people based upon race in internment camps? Oh yeah we are already.

What if the domestic opposition to this evil is not effective?

What if the evil crazy is normalized?

How far can the USA go down the rabbit hole?

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
34. Your post is full of "What ifs"?
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 08:11 PM
Jul 2019

"If" is the critical word here. The point is, the OP wasn't talking about a "what if" future, he was talking about the Present Reality.

PufPuf23

(8,764 posts)
42. The fact is that except for the actual act of "nuking",
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 08:39 PM
Jul 2019

the "What ifs" I mentioned have already happened or are happening and Trump has raised the specter of using nuclear weapons.

Shit could get very ugly very fast say if we go into a competitive war.

Lock him up.

(6,925 posts)
5. Just looking at how urgent solving climate change is, and...
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 02:49 AM
Jul 2019

... looking at how little emergency there is in actually solving it...
humanity really is a suicidal species...we're like past to point of no return.
21 degrees Celcius at just 600 kilometers from the North Pole happened this week!

Never seen before.

Hermit-The-Prog

(33,321 posts)
9. #NeverAgainIsNow
Fri Jul 19, 2019, 04:48 AM
Jul 2019

I don't have twitter, but saw #NeverAgainIsNow in some OP here on DU. It is chilling to be unable to refute that.

0rganism

(23,938 posts)
20. on the up-side, evolution might proceed faster with more mutagens in the environment
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:29 PM
Jul 2019

the massive increase in background radiation should provide plenty of opportunities to push through some incredible adaptive pressure

here's hoping the cockroaches do better long-term than us.

Retrograde

(10,132 posts)
30. "It Can't Happen Here"
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 07:58 PM
Jul 2019

I'm currently reading this 1935 novel by Sinclair Lewis, and it's frightfully prescient. I'm up to the part where the newly-elected Hero of the People "cleans up the swamp" by jailing his enemies in Congress and forcing through a measure to void Supreme Court rulings he doesn't like.

Kurt V.

(5,624 posts)
32. Forget nazi Germany. What's happening now is infecting every democracy world
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 08:08 PM
Jul 2019

wide. Thousands upon thousands of rich and/or powerful ppl see democracy as having ran its course.

Hekate

(90,641 posts)
40. I reached that point myself in stages: GOP nomination, election, increasing horror, numbness...
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 08:30 PM
Jul 2019

...and finally, this year, a recognition of how otherwise decent Germans/Austrians were bulldozed, numbed, and silenced by the viciousness that overtook and ruled their nation.

My MIL was raised in Vienna, Austria, a city of culture -- music, the arts, science, philosophy, so advanced in every way. Her parents had immigrated from Russia, but even they could not see what was coming. She could: it was a feature of her psyche that she knew when to jump. So finally she got two of her sisters and their families on the train to Belgium just ahead of the Anschluss, and still not all of that group survived.

I think of them often these days, and wonder what I can do. I pray I can be of use. I think America, this country where I was born, so long a beacon of democracy, arts, science, and mostly goodhearted and well meaning people -- being swept under by this tide of viciousness led by the minority -- and I think we are in for a long period of darkness that I can only pray I live to see the end of.




dawg day

(7,947 posts)
43. The silver lining is that Germany came back-
Tue Jul 23, 2019, 08:43 PM
Jul 2019

The country was taken over by total evil.

And then, after the defeat, Germany (with enormous help from the Allies, and being broken up by the USSR) crawled out of the pit and became a relatively good global citizen.

Decent leadership can make a big difference in a nation's path. Trump will take us to hell, if you don't mind my using that term. But we don't have to stay there.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»No American should ever a...