Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Atticus

(15,124 posts)
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 05:36 PM Nov 2019

"Poor People Just Die"---from 7/12/09 (thanks to

BluesRunTheGame for locating it)





Originally appeared 7-12-09

I was five when "Pap" died. Pap was my grandmother's next door neighbor and, like most who lived in our neighborhood, he was a working man, a laborer. One of my grandfathers died the year after I was born and the other I saw maybe twice a year. Pap filled in for them on an almost daily basis. He let me "help" in his garden and let me pet his beagles whenever I wanted.

I came home from school one afternoon that fall of my first grade year and my grandmother told me to sit down at the kitchen table. Both my parents worked and we stayed with "Nanny" after school. She said she had some real sad news and that I needed to be a "big boy". "Pap died today. His heart was sick and it quit working. The ambulance came, but it was too late", she explained, speaking softly and earnestly.

I cried. Eventually, I asked what is always asked: "Why? Why did he have to die? Why couldn't the doctors make him well? Why couldn't they save him?"

Nanny explained that doctors and hospitals and medicine cost a lot of money and Pap didn't have a lot of money. Rich people bought medicine and had surgery and went to hospitals. "Poor people just die", she said, as gently as possible and held me while I sobbed into her apron.

In the fifties, I overheard several hushed conversations between my parents and other adults that featured the word "cancer". I didn't understand what it was, but I knew it was bad, very bad. Only later did I understand that even "routine" cancers were usually a death sentence for those without insurance or wealth or both. Family members maintained gruesome vigils while the tumors spread throughout their loved ones body and sometimes the stench of necrotic tissue required those attending to the dying to smear Vicks under their nose to keep from retching.

Are we to return to those days? Are we to once again allow money to be the real medicine in our nation? Will we be too busy to march on Washington? Too busy to hound our senators and congressmen to vote for AT LEAST a public option for health care insurance?

I can accept wealth allowing some to drive a Mercedes or a Porsche while others drive Chevys or ride the bus.
I cannot accept wealth allowing some to live while others "just die".



Obviously, some of this is outdated, but the tragedies it discusses are still with us today.

19 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
"Poor People Just Die"---from 7/12/09 (thanks to (Original Post) Atticus Nov 2019 OP
Ron Paul and a right wing audience: Garrett78 Nov 2019 #1
My response to him and his crowd ends with "---and the mule you rode in on!" nt Atticus Nov 2019 #2
"We should actually legalize alternative health care!" Grokenstein Nov 2019 #10
Three Hundred Dollars a month for insurance...I forgot that. irisblue Nov 2019 #12
Churches are broke. democratisphere Nov 2019 #3
Isn't Ron Paul dead or something? CTyankee Nov 2019 #4
Only on the inside. Salviati Nov 2019 #5
Brain dead but still living. democratisphere Nov 2019 #8
Yeah, I was shocked to learn he's still wasting oxygen. Grokenstein Nov 2019 #11
Was he ever actually alive? paleotn Nov 2019 #14
I've seen a lot of this "just die" business during my lifetime. democrank Nov 2019 #6
Massively Agree! democratisphere Nov 2019 #7
Hard to believe that some people would rather die than live under "socialism." CTyankee Nov 2019 #9
Then they should visit Sweden, or any other of a host of countries that have socialized medicine. Haggis for Breakfast Nov 2019 #13
Not giving a crap about anyone but themselves is strong in this country. paleotn Nov 2019 #15
So true this post. mountain grammy Nov 2019 #17
We are all poor people CloudWatcher Nov 2019 #16
This is a great post, Atticus mountain grammy Nov 2019 #18
K&R for visibility crickets Nov 2019 #19

Grokenstein

(5,721 posts)
10. "We should actually legalize alternative health care!"
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 07:13 PM
Nov 2019

"Let people practice what they want!"

It's easy for sociopath trash like the Pauls to dismissively tell the poor to fend for themselves, but that's just evil. That's ringing the dinner bell for the snake oil (or these days "essential oils&quot salesmen.

democratisphere

(17,235 posts)
3. Churches are broke.
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 06:04 PM
Nov 2019

Most people are actually broke.
The COST OF AMERICAN HEALTHCARE is TRULY, ACTUALLY CRIMINAL. (This crime must be stopped and reveresed)
If people without insurance become gravely ill, death is likely, if not inevitable.

MAGA.
MAKE AMERICA GRACIOUS AGAIN.

Great post Atticus!

Grokenstein

(5,721 posts)
11. Yeah, I was shocked to learn he's still wasting oxygen.
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 07:15 PM
Nov 2019

But hey, his spawn is making up for his absence in front of cameras.

paleotn

(17,901 posts)
14. Was he ever actually alive?
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 08:09 PM
Nov 2019

Seems to me he and his son are loathsome creatures, neither alive or dead, that suck the life out of the living. Human parasites....and I struggle applying the word human to them.

democrank

(11,092 posts)
6. I've seen a lot of this "just die" business during my lifetime.
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 06:20 PM
Nov 2019

I can not, for the life of me, understand why so many Americans support the health care system we have. Many folks are one unexpected catastrophic medical issue away from losing their homes. Some have lost jobs and can’t afford insurance. Some don’t regularly take life-saving medications because they cost too much.

The system needs an overhaul. Not a little tweaking, but an overhaul.

Haggis for Breakfast

(6,831 posts)
13. Then they should visit Sweden, or any other of a host of countries that have socialized medicine.
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 07:48 PM
Nov 2019

People that talk this way have no idea what they're talking about. They have allowed others to formulate their opinions instead of thinking, or educating themselves about what socialism truly looks like. It is pathetic that they are so willfully ignorant.

paleotn

(17,901 posts)
15. Not giving a crap about anyone but themselves is strong in this country.
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 08:28 PM
Nov 2019

and ironically it drives people to hurt themselves just so some mythical "undeserving" person doesn't take advantage of the system. They'd rather we all lived in the squalor of Sinclair's Jungle just so someone, somewhere doesn't get something they don't think they deserve. It's a terrible, soul crushing way to live, but I think it's America's true epidemic, driving most of our national ills. I could care less if someone gets something we may not think they deserve as long as everyone's basic needs are provided for. It's a hell of a lot better than the vast majority of us living in some laissez faire hell. I guess that's the root of what makes us different from Rethuglicans and wing nuts.

CloudWatcher

(1,846 posts)
16. We are all poor people
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 08:30 PM
Nov 2019

In just the last week, giant progress in the treatment of cystic fibrosis. Totally amazing results for 90% of the people that suffer from this terrible disease.

Oh, except the cost. Estimated to be $311,000. Per patient. Per year.

Long-awaited cystic fibrosis drug could turn deadly disease into a manageable condition

The system is broken. We should never have for-profit and health-care in the same sentence.

mountain grammy

(26,605 posts)
18. This is a great post, Atticus
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 08:47 PM
Nov 2019

Well worth resurrecting because it’s true.. the Koch brother who just died had prostrate cancer. When he was diagnosed he was given a short time to live but lived another 20 or so.. His money kept him alive. I’ll bet he never touched a child’s heart..

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»"Poor People Just Die"---...