General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsI find it hilarious to hear any American speak about Cuba and human rights
when several of their presidents tried to kill Fidel Castro.
Whether American like it or not what Fidel did for healthcare and education in Cuba is light years ahead of anything done by neo-liberals. And Fidel didn't lock any body's children in cages.
Enough with this bullshit - grow the fuck up. Wake up Everybody!
Callado119
(171 posts)...I hope we dont have to find out the hard way how few Americans agree with you...we still time to get an electable nominee that doesnt have to force every downbalot dem to have to disavow Castro and the Soviet Union when the election should be a referendum on trump..
gab13by13
(21,337 posts)I would be happy to be shown polls that show differently.
Bernie gave a truthful answer about Castro, I guess Dems are looking for a candidate who only gives politically correct answers?
Dopers_Greed
(2,640 posts)We are truly doomed
NYC Liberal
(20,136 posts)Polls are utterly meaningless, especially this early.
ehrnst
(32,640 posts)Since you seem to be reluctant to show your source, here's mine:
https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/president-general/
ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)nicely done
2naSalit
(86,612 posts)Last edited Tue Feb 25, 2020, 03:05 PM - Edit history (1)
Almost like it was a mechanical device.
shanti
(21,675 posts)so little time.
m-lekktor
(3,675 posts)tirebiter
(2,536 posts)Sort of outweighs everything else.
Act_of_Reparation
(9,116 posts)Deterrence was the smart move. We would have done the same.
ms liberty
(8,574 posts)blue cat
(2,415 posts)And no amount of pouting is going to change the fact that many Americans are turned off by it.
BlueTsunami2018
(3,492 posts)Castro is better than every President from Ike to Clinton?
Have we finally lost our goddamn minds here?
Pacifist Patriot
(24,653 posts)ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)beat up that straw man!
Act_of_Reparation
(9,116 posts)Tommy_Carcetti
(43,182 posts)And no one is going to be elected on complimenting him.
Theres no need to whatabout things.
gab13by13
(21,337 posts)kissing up to Putin a murderer, for kissing up to MBS a murderer, and for Trump writing love letters to Kim Jong Un a murderer.
Tommy_Carcetti
(43,182 posts)Unless youve just woken up from a 4 year plus coma, weve been pretty consistent here about Trumps assault on democracy.
Act_of_Reparation
(9,116 posts)The American people have never been particular adverse to dictators as a concept. Just those who piss off the board at United Fruit.
N_E_1 for Tennis
(9,722 posts)in this country after the fire on their head is extinguished.
delisen
(6,043 posts)Do you seriously believe that Fidel Castro did not separate families or engage in dictatorial human rights abuses?
In 1980 Castro initiated he Mariel Boat Lift-mentally ill persons and developmentally disabled person were summarily taken from institutions in Cuba and sent to an uncertain future in the US without any planning or even any care for their well-being. Even if those institutions were as bad as many of ours, using dictatorial powers to expell persons in distress and create havoc in the lives of people unable to fend for themselves was a truly disgusting act-
https://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/op-ed/article209282994.html
The Mariel Boatlift started with a surprise announcement by Cuban President Fidel Castro on April 20, 1980. He said that he was opening the port for Cubans to leave the Communist island. The Carter administration had secretly worked to improve relations with Castro, but was caught unaware and unprepared for Castros decision.
After the start of the exodus, Castro shocked the world by opening Cuban prisons and mental health facilities, transporting the prisoners and patients to the port for the 90-mile trip to Miami. Floridians from Key West to West Palm Beach sent private boats to Mariel to be paid by families and friends to transport the fleeing Cubans across the dangerous Florida Straits. The flotilla that this spurred was described by the press as Rag Tag Chaos.
Read more here: https://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/op-ed/article209282994.html#storylink=cpy
Human Rights Watch report of 2005 details abuses and looks at the actions of both the US and Cuba
https://www.refworld.org/docid/45cb38452.html
Over the past four decades, hundreds of thousands of people have left Cuba, many of them seeking basic rights denied them by the government of Fidel Castro, such as the rights to freedom of expression, association, and assembly. Their ability to pursue these freedoms abroad has been curtailed, however, by Cuba's denial of another fundamental right the right to freedom of movement.
Cuba routinely refuses to grant its citizens permission to leave their country and often denies those who have left permission to return. These restrictions have resulted in the involuntary separation of many Cuban families, violating the rights of children to be with their parents.
The emotional toll on family members is immeasurable. A Cuban physicist who now lives in Brazil, for example, has never been able to meet his six-year-old son. His ex-wife and son are in Cuba, but because he violated Cuban travel restrictions by refusing to return from an authorized trip abroad in 2000, the Cuban government has barred him from visiting the island to see his child. A Cuban mother in Mexico, who was separated from her sons for three years in similar circumstances, told Human Rights Watch that she felt like the Cuban government "tore out a piece of my life."
The dictatorial leaders, the human rights abusers, the anti-democracy strongmen can be found on both the left and the right.
ehrnst
(32,640 posts)One would never DARE say about Hitler that he did well with infrastructure, and got the trains running on time, promoted healthy families, was a devout Catholic, ate a healthy vegetarian diet... even if all those things are good things.
You don't minimize the horrors that he eventually visited on people by focusing on the minor positive things that improved from the Batista/US reign.
There are people out there that would say stuff like this, and I am not referring to neo-nazis.
Back during the 2016 primaries, I came across this comment in a The Atlantic article on how some Bernie Sanders supporters were thinking about voting for Trump (this was back when their web site still had Comment sections for most of their articles - the only reason I still have access to it is that I quoted it on another forum: )
"The Italian Peninsula was a loose collection of monarchies and papal states before Mussolini came to power and was a Democracy after he left so good does come out of an authoritarian leader.
"Even Germany was better off after World War 2 than they were after World War 1. Unfortunately, it took Hitler to get Europe and the United States to stop extorting their people into starvation.
ehrnst
(32,640 posts)They tend to lose the least when societal norms break down.
Everyone else fares far, far worse.
indeed.
HopeAgain
(4,407 posts)so was Batista, who many of the original refugees had supported or worked for. Castro didn't overthrow a Democratic regime. And Bernie said he didn't like the authoritarian nature of the Cuban government, but he's not allowed nuance.
Also the American embargoes were cruel to the average Cuban.
lostnfound
(16,179 posts)Not sure the public has been more than half awake in 50 years.
Thought control measures have been quite effective.
malaise
(268,998 posts)safeinOhio
(32,677 posts)a brutal dictator installed by the US and big Sugar. Everyone always skips the reasons for a dislike of America. Just like Iran was overthrow by British and US oil to install the Shah.
Please take a look at history. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fulgencio_Batista
For all of those here that are attacking Castro, please compare and contrast him to who he replaced.
ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)it's time we moved from children's stories to real history in our narratives.
Tommy_Carcetti
(43,182 posts)All were/are undemocratic regimes. Just in different forms.
safeinOhio
(32,677 posts)Democratically elected leader. Like us now thinking anyone other than trump, they went with the only one with power to over through the brutal, repressive Shah.
Castro got into power because of the leader he replaced. That may have turned out bad, but it was because of Batista. This ain't checkers, you have to look beyond those in power and look at how they got there.
Ghost Dog
(16,881 posts)It was known that Barriguilla had plundered and murdered, that he was a millionaire, that he owned in Havana a good many apartment houses, countless stock in foreign companies, fabulous accounts in American banks, that he agreed to divorce settlements to the tune of eighteen million pesos, that he was a frequent guest in the most lavishly expensive hotels for Yankee tycoons. But no one would ever think of Barriguilla as a revolutionary. Barriguilla is that sergeant of Weyler's who assassinated twelve Cubans in Guatao. Batista's men murdered seventy in Santiago de Cuba. De te fabula narratur.
Four political parties governed the country before the 10th of March: the Auténtico, Liberal, Democratic and Republican parties. Two days after the coup, the Republican party gave its support to the new rulers. A year had not yet passed before the Liberal and Democratic parties were again in power: Batista did not restore the Constitution, did not restore civil liberties, did not restore Congress, did not restore universal suffrage, did not restore in the last analysis any of the uprooted democratic institutions. But he did restore Verdeja, Guas Inclán, Salvito García Ramos, Anaya Murillo and the top hierarchy of the traditional government parties, the most corrupt, rapacious, reactionary and antediluvian elements in Cuban politics. So went the 'revolution' of Barriguilla!.
Lacking even the most elementary revolutionary content, Batista's regime represents in every respect a 20 year regression for Cuba. Batista's regime has exacted a high price from all of us, but primarily from the humble classes which are suffering hunger and misery. Meanwhile the dictatorship has laid waste the nation with commotion, ineptitude and anguish, and now engages in the most loathsome forms of ruthless politics, concocting formula after formula to perpetuate itself in power, even if over a stack of corpses and a sea of blood.
Batista's regime has not set in motion a single nationwide program of betterment for the people. Batista delivered himself into the hands of the great financial interests. Little else could be expected from a man of his mentality - utterly devoid as he is of ideals and of principles, and utterly lacking the faith, confidence and support of the masses. His regime merely brought with it a change of hands and a redistribution of the loot among a new group of friends, relatives, accomplices and parasitic hangers-on that constitute the political retinue of the Dictator. What great shame the people have been forced to endure so that a small group of egoists, altogether indifferent to the needs of their homeland, may find in public life an easy and comfortable modus vivendi...
https://www.marxists.org/history/cuba/archive/castro/1953/10/16.htm
Thanks for the thread Malaise.
Kaiserguy
(740 posts)don't know ,don't remember or just don't care about history when it comes to what we did wrong.
ehrnst
(32,640 posts)The history of Cuba and Castro didn't stop at the the overthrow of Batista...
safeinOhio
(32,677 posts)better for the people, if they weren't connected or rich. Both were a reaction to the first. Just a fact to consider.
ehrnst
(32,640 posts)safeinOhio
(32,677 posts)victims of Batista and the Shah.
ehrnst
(32,640 posts)safeinOhio
(32,677 posts)to counter the 30 year block aid by the US. No Castro turned to communism with the help of Russia. Tramps bestie. If the US government wasnt a tool of big business and had pushed Cuba toward Democracy, history would not be the same. Same story for most of Central and South America.
Always look at the big picture and skip the bs
malaise
(268,998 posts)He said that Batista was responsible for the improved literacy rates in Cuba. Every reliable data source I checked for the nth time says literacy rates under Batista were in the 60% range given the poor education available in rural Cuba. That changed under Fidel.
But facts are no longer popular.
safeinOhio
(32,677 posts)from Puerto Rico turn it Blue. Like to see the bully get screwed by those he screwed.
malaise
(268,998 posts)and don't forget the Haitian-Americans as well.
safeinOhio
(32,677 posts)second, third and fourth generation Cubans. My cup is always half full.
MerryBlooms
(11,769 posts)HAB911
(8,891 posts)Tarc
(10,476 posts)the Batistas and the Pahlavis propped up by the West. The only reason conservatives hated Castro and the like is because they lost control; there is no valid humanitarian concern or opposition.
Dopers_Greed
(2,640 posts)Tarc
(10,476 posts)is approximately zero.
You and Tulsi can work on courting the Deplorable voters if you wish, I'll pass.
Response to Tarc (Reply #62)
Dopers_Greed This message was self-deleted by its author.
treestar
(82,383 posts)Cant afford that attitude
Tarc
(10,476 posts)Good luck with that.
treestar
(82,383 posts)By slim margins?
delisen
(6,043 posts)regardless of the West.
Did the women of Iran have human rights prior to colonialism and western influence? No. Neither did children.
Other countries, including theocracies are quite capable of Human Rights abuses without any influence from the west.
Human rights abuses flourished long before colonialism.
Do you think Saudi Arabia was a bastion of freedom for all its citizens prior to the discovery of oil and its alliance with western powers?
No. It was a kingdom of tribal all-male rulers with the power of life and death over their family members-where the law allowed for maiming and murder of "transgressors.
Tarc
(10,476 posts)There was a democratically-elected government in Iran.
The US and the UK aided the coup which installed Pahlavi.
Resentment and anger over a colonial puppet state created the situation in which Khomeini rose to power.
In Cuba, in Vietnam, and others, this pattern has repeated itself. Actual progressive, liberal individuals oppose such foreign meddling.
Mosby
(16,311 posts)Iran has been led by military dynasties since the 1700s.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qajar_dynasty
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pahlavi_dynasty
Tarc
(10,476 posts)The PM was overthrown by the CIA, to give Pahlavi, their asset, more control of the nation.
Mosby
(16,311 posts)It's not that simple, Mossadegh was appointed to the position of PM by the Shah.
malaise
(268,998 posts)vlyons
(10,252 posts)or kissed Putin's ass and laundered money for Russian mobsters
Vinca
(50,271 posts)admitted pussy grabber over someone they are told is a "Commie lover." Details don't matter anymore, it's the headlines. I'm getting a sick, sick feeling about where this is all headed.
NYC Liberal
(20,136 posts)brutus smith
(685 posts)evertonfc
(1,713 posts)twice in last 18 months. It absolutely pitiful the conditions they have to live in. They may have high literacy rates but who cares when you can't make a nickel. I love the people and they love America.
ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)to do with their pitiful conditions? Asking for a friend
evertonfc
(1,713 posts)It's thier form of govt mostly. Even they will tell you that. Doctors, computer programmers make nothing. The system of free enterprise only exist for a small few. I live Cuba. I'll probably go back in July. I enjoy taking basic toiletries like soap, lotion, toothpaste, shampoo. They love it. Go Check it out. Cheap flights. Air Bnb. I stay with Cuban families.
ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)tenderfoot
(8,432 posts)LOL
ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)ancianita
(36,055 posts)Castro, a lawyer, set up Cuba as a self sustaining, people-driven society. Russia's still got its spy tentacles there, though.
Cuba's medical system, founded by Che Guevara and the best in the Americas, has sent doctors across continents to keep brothers and sisters alive and healthy through their struggles to keep insurgents from stealing their lives and landbase resources.
I love Harold & the Blue Notes.
malaise
(268,998 posts)Judi Lynn
(160,530 posts)The only ones who know otherwise have been led by their own character to put in the time and concern needed to start looking for the truth themselves.
The tidal wave of absolute propaganda only takes down those who settle for whoppers easily sold to idiots.
Awaken, grow up and don't die stupid. Use that brain as more than a storehouse for unquestioned alarmingly stupid lies created to mislead idiots.
Use some time to look up the father of spin who organized the first US political propaganda and learn how he launched that massive ship so long ago with the violent overthrows of Guatemala and Iran.
ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)malaise
(268,998 posts)as usual
KG
(28,751 posts)groundloop
(11,519 posts)Miguel Díaz-Canel, who was trained as an electrical engineer, is currently the President of Cuba.
I too have visited Cuba, I was there approximately a year ago, shortly before Bolton and Trump reversed all the advances made by President Obama in Cuban relations. I'd like to go again if I ever get the chance.
It's a shame that so many people in this country have such strong opinions about Cuba without actually knowing anything about it.
Happy Hoosier
(7,308 posts)Last edited Wed Feb 26, 2020, 11:26 AM - Edit history (1)
Very compassionate!
Criticizing Castro is NOT an endorsement of American human rights atrocities, FFS. That's fucking insulting.
It's possible to oppose human rights abuses no matter who does them, ya'know...
leftstreet
(36,108 posts)Happy Hoosier
(7,308 posts)But he did harbor a deep hatred for the Castros and the Cuban government.
he did think that engaging with Cuba was the best way to end human rights abuses.
Nature Man
(869 posts)does he know my best friend's sister's cousin?
Bettie
(16,109 posts)and it isn't as if it was a paradise under Batista either.
Apparently, nuance isn't a thing anymore and you'd think, here in the US, that we could see that few things are 100% good or 100% bad, since our own government has done some awful things over the years.
avebury
(10,952 posts)Castro couldn't hold a candle to all the crap Trump and his cronies have done and will continue to do is Trump steals the 2020 election.
Mao led the Communist revolution in China but Nixon found a way for the US to make peace with each other.
Japan bombed Pearl Harbor but they are one of our allies now.
The US was in an extended war with North Viet Nam but we have worked things out with them. John McCain even visited the country years later.
But the US insists on holding a grudge against Cuba for the rest of eternity. Yes there are Cuban-Americans who have family members who suffered under Castro.
Castro might have not been the most benevolent ruler of a country but for crying out loud - he is DEAD! At some point the US needs to move on and reestablish a relationship with Cuba. Based upon our attitude about Cuba it is a miracle that we have relationships with the England (remember Revolutionary War and War of 1812), Saudi Arabia (they provided the majority of the 911 hijackers), and so on.
If the current state of the Cuban people is that poor, the US has probably contributed to it by doing everything they can to isolate them. It is not surprise that the Soviet Union (now Russia) has close ties to Cuba. When the US refuses to do business with a country it leaves a vacuum for other countries to fill.
kentuck
(111,094 posts)Wouldn't it have been easier to propagandize the people by keeping them illiterate? Why gamble that they might read something else, living so close to the US?
H2O Man
(73,537 posts)there aren't any silly distraction taking place. That might make it hard to keep our eyes on the prize if there were such distractions intended to divide our party. Plus we are all too smart to get sidetracked on nonsense.
Recommended.
malaise
(268,998 posts)Last edited Tue Feb 25, 2020, 03:37 PM - Edit history (1)
Wait - they're creating them
H2O Man
(73,537 posts)Mc Mike
(9,114 posts)they'd be in a better position to bitch about how 'bad' his replacement was.
Second, any pol who cozies up to Castro's Cuba could never be elected in America. Here's the proof:
https://www.democraticunderground.com/10141583668
malaise
(268,998 posts)You see you can cozy up for profits but don't you dare praise the literacy advances or health care
Mc Mike
(9,114 posts)Got caught at it, and it came out after his anti-castro speech to the American Cubans who hate Castro.
He pissed off the one group of Latin/Hispanic Americans that reliably voted R in bloc. And it was no big deal for him or the repugs, or corporate media.
malaise
(268,998 posts)As we say 'jackass say di world nuh level'. Iran-Contra is another glaring example of law-breaking by RWs.
Sadly until Dems address the madness that is US foreign policy, this crap will continue. You cannot overthrow democracies overseas and expect it to thrive at home. You cannot argue that you overthrow governments because they object to dissent from their citizens when you try to kill leaders in said countries because they show dissent to your way of doing things. That is not simply being inconsistent, it is absolute madness.
Mc Mike
(9,114 posts)and the corporate media retails the bs to us as reasonable.
We hate castro cuba, but love North Korea and Saudi Arabia.
malaise
(268,998 posts)the simple question is if both the Executive Branch and Congress can get rid of previous presidents' policies, why have either of these spread rather than removed. There is only one conclusion - the US wants the same imperial power as the Europeans once enjoyed.
Don't forget how they turned on Obama for the Arab Spring which removed Mubarak - dictators are loved and encouraged as long as they are pushing the agenda of the most powerful folks on our planet - and of course buying weapons to kill their own people or any neighbors who want to run their own lives their way.
Mc Mike
(9,114 posts)Most of the citizens here are just bled for the bigshots' empire, bled with taxes to finance their military adventures and bled by being cannon fodder for them.
Most of us are living like plebes, not roman citizens. Fair trade would not hurt our standard of living.
malaise
(268,998 posts)Notice the global silence re the current situation in Haiti - police and the army are fighting it out out against each other in the streets. You have to see it to believe it.
Mc Mike
(9,114 posts)The WASPs never forgave Haiti for that successful rebellion. They've squatted on Haiti ever since.
We need a UN with teeth, no security council veto power.
malaise
(268,998 posts)Mc Mike
(9,114 posts)Good day to you, mal.
malaise
(268,998 posts)Sadly Jamaica and Haiti have a thriving drugs for guns trade. Turns out some of the assault rifles that show up here with Haitian police IDs. Most are of course US made.
Mc Mike
(9,114 posts)removed his buddy Noriega.
Imagine if US manufacturing could make renewable energy equipment, water purification kits, ag and manufacturing tools, medicines, instead of guns and bullets.
malaise
(268,998 posts)Iran Contra has several off-shoots - many of the biggest drug dons were given visas and allowed to thrive as long as the guns flowed to kill off opposing interests. And of course the evangelicals poured in to destroy the liberation theologists and social justice groups.
Mc Mike
(9,114 posts)leaders, in order to restore the more 'stable' Medellin cartel to power.
Penny Lernoux had some excellent reporting and books about the death squads vs Lib Theo adherents.
Noriega's big sin was not implicating the Sandinistas, and thinking he deserved to be in charge of his own country, because of his decades of loyal service to the North, and West.
HAB911
(8,891 posts)Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz, and all the other insane RW Cubans in S. Florida, indirectly.
I've told Marco, my Senator, on three occasions via email that he should go back to Cuba and take Ted with him and that pisses me off because it's antithetical to my core beliefs as a raging liberal. crickets