Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:03 PM May 2020

People in Montana aren't masking or distancing... My Mom's former caregiver called me this

evening (she lives in Montana) to ask me for some information concerning the request to Social
Security concerning my Mom's death benefit. (Mom died last November)

So when that business was done I asked her how the virus was doing up there and she said nobody's
worried about it at all. I told her, "Well, we don't have to argue about it. Just remember that everyone
who has died because of it so far IS DEAD."

She was also misinformed about the population here, suggesting Q city had millions of people. So I
corrected her by saying more like 700,000 for the greater area. She's definitely one factually challenged person... I shoulda told her the joke about what you call a person who doesn't mask or distance (A: a corpse) but I'm always too slow.

That's what we're up against...

35 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
People in Montana aren't masking or distancing... My Mom's former caregiver called me this (Original Post) abqtommy May 2020 OP
Depends on where she is... 2naSalit May 2020 #1
After illegally entering the park, no less. MontanaFarmer May 2020 #4
Both my parents were Montana natives and I've lived here and there in the state as boy and man. abqtommy May 2020 #5
I have people buried in Ronan, and I live in Flathead County. Maru Kitteh May 2020 #11
Sounds like good virus response there. My Mom was born in Kalispel. She was living in abqtommy May 2020 #13
We have a newer one now... 2naSalit May 2020 #14
Thanks, I'll remember that too! abqtommy May 2020 #18
It's a popular bumper sticker around here. 2naSalit May 2020 #23
Hungry Horse and Martin City were pretty wild as I remember. No ID required to buy beer if you jalan48 May 2020 #32
Visting my relatives in Flagstaff ChazII May 2020 #24
People took it very seriously here for awhile. MontanaFarmer May 2020 #2
I had also heard that Bullock did a solid job right from the get-go. MFGsunny May 2020 #7
It really does depend where this person is referring to up here. MontanaMama May 2020 #3
See my Reply #5... abqtommy May 2020 #6
I'm very familiar with Ronan. MontanaMama May 2020 #8
I'm really into understanding this virus and protecting myself, my son that lives with me and abqtommy May 2020 #9
You know where I live and where I work GusBob May 2020 #10
I was hoping to see you in this thread GB. MontanaMama May 2020 #12
Nice day for hiking today! GusBob May 2020 #26
The wildflowers right now!!! MontanaMama May 2020 #28
I worry about that too. 2naSalit May 2020 #15
I think it's over 900,000 now Warpy May 2020 #16
I'd have to actually look up the population stats here and I haven't done that since I moved here in abqtommy May 2020 #19
I just got too old for those Boston winters Warpy May 2020 #30
Hmmm...every town and city has a legal boundary that's called The City Limit and there are stats abqtommy May 2020 #31
They are part of the "greater" because so many are commuter towns. Warpy May 2020 #33
It took me MFM008 May 2020 #17
Thanks, I'm not involved in those details since the caretaker is handling it. Hell, I knew Mom abqtommy May 2020 #20
People in Montana probably don't need to FBaggins May 2020 #21
Suture yourself, as the do-it-yourself doctor kit says. As for me I believe that it's better to be abqtommy May 2020 #22
The U.P.? Were you mistaking the outline of NC for part of MI? FBaggins May 2020 #25
I do see a similarity between the outlines or North Carolina and Upper Michigan. It wasn't abqtommy May 2020 #27
That's the point you're missing. Of COURSE you'll gamble with your own life FBaggins May 2020 #29
4 new cases today in Bighorn county GusBob May 2020 #34
Oh no! Thanks for the update, Bob. It might be a good idea for you to start a new thread to maintain abqtommy May 2020 #35

2naSalit

(86,318 posts)
1. Depends on where she is...
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:11 PM
May 2020

In the part of Montana where I live, it's about 50% maybe more. I see more masks every time I go out so there's hope. It's really going to get bad here when the National Parks open up and the tourists start to show up. Yellowstone is closed but some stupid woman fell in a hot pool near Old Faithful night before last so there's that.

MontanaFarmer

(630 posts)
4. After illegally entering the park, no less.
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:29 PM
May 2020

Quite a feat, actually, to drive basically to mammoth from old faithful with what would have had to be some awfully significant burns. Crazy.

abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
5. Both my parents were Montana natives and I've lived here and there in the state as boy and man.
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:34 PM
May 2020

The person I wrote about in my original op lives in Ronan, a small town just south of Polson so I
wouldn't expect it to be representative. I was living in Hungry Horse in 1980 and right after I left for
California all the right-wingers started moving in and of course they're not gonna give up their free-dumbs. How's that going? What you've said is encouraging... We're only running about 50% here
in Albuquerque.

I always hated to hear about deaths by hot springs, especially a youngster. The stupid runs deep...

Montana State Motto: At least we're not North Dakota... see? I do remember!

Maru Kitteh

(28,313 posts)
11. I have people buried in Ronan, and I live in Flathead County.
Thu May 14, 2020, 12:05 AM
May 2020

Whitefish is a serious boutique town now, more Dems so very high percentage of mask wearers. Kalispell and C-Falls it depends where you go, but even with the easing of restrictions somewhat, there are more masks than you might expect. I bought a set of tires last Friday at Discount Tire, had to be there to drop it off before they opened and ended up waiting in line with 6 other people. All kept their distance and all but one were wearing masks. I was rather proud of us, actually.



abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
13. Sounds like good virus response there. My Mom was born in Kalispel. She was living in
Thu May 14, 2020, 12:19 AM
May 2020

Arizona in 2005 when I moved here to Albuquerque so I could visit and have a job too. In 2017 she
and her caregiver (also a Montanan) moved back north and here I am, lost my traveling bone, all dressed up and nowhere to go!

I actually like it here, been here 15 years already, longer than anywhere. Why? Because maybe twice
a year I have to clean snow off my car!

Let's all survive together!

jalan48

(13,839 posts)
32. Hungry Horse and Martin City were pretty wild as I remember. No ID required to buy beer if you
Thu May 14, 2020, 07:00 PM
May 2020

looked old enough.

ChazII

(6,200 posts)
24. Visting my relatives in Flagstaff
Thu May 14, 2020, 08:46 AM
May 2020

to get my grandmother's ashes to take down to Phoenix. Most everyone is wearing masks. Grand Canyon is still closed.

MontanaFarmer

(630 posts)
2. People took it very seriously here for awhile.
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:27 PM
May 2020

Lately, folks' willingness to wear a mask has seemed to become directly proportional to how much they love trump. Also, Bullock did a very solid job very early, locking down the state before we had a confirmed case. It's inevitable, though, given some of the behaviors described in the OP, coupled with the struggles of some of the surrounding states, that we see at least some hotspots develop. I don't so much fear it sweeping the state as i do small communities getting community transmission going in a care center or similar. People that aren't taking it seriously here haven't had to because we've had relatively few cases and deaths; i sincerely hope they don't have to learn it the hard way.

MFGsunny

(2,356 posts)
7. I had also heard that Bullock did a solid job right from the get-go.
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:35 PM
May 2020

And it was a definite plus, given how all this really works under best scientific knowledge.

Stay well.

MontanaMama

(23,294 posts)
3. It really does depend where this person is referring to up here.
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:28 PM
May 2020

I live in Western Montana and we still have good restrictions in place even as the state opens up via phase 1. Costco and our local organic grocery store require masks on everybody that enters the store. I was at Target the other day for the first time since early February and maybe half the customers were wearing masks. That was not good. Most of the places that I go, which isn’t very many, people are wearing masks. I own a small business, and we are still seeing customers by appointment only, and those folks by and large show up wearing masks. Granted, I live in a fairly blue area of Montana.

All in all, we have had fewer than 500 documented cases in the state in the state. I agree with the post above that when our national parks open up, it will be a whole different story up here. I am dreading it.

ETA: We have just over 1 million people in the entire state.

MontanaMama

(23,294 posts)
8. I'm very familiar with Ronan.
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:52 PM
May 2020

My kiddo’s favorite fishing tackle shop is there!

I can understand why some folks don’t feel the threat of the virus up here. We have only 16 active cases in the state as of tonight. That’s going to change, however. Yellowstone is opening it’s southern border in a few days. It’s only just beginning.

abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
9. I'm really into understanding this virus and protecting myself, my son that lives with me and
Wed May 13, 2020, 11:55 PM
May 2020

other people too. Death is such a final thing and I'm not in a hurry to go through it! Stay safe!

GusBob

(7,286 posts)
10. You know where I live and where I work
Thu May 14, 2020, 12:03 AM
May 2020

All I can say is. Phase one has been a failure in my estimation. People have become complacent
One case in Hill county. Zero on RB
I only go into Havre once a week. Very few masks
On the Agency and in the clinic all I can say is: we fear trouble

MontanaMama

(23,294 posts)
12. I was hoping to see you in this thread GB.
Thu May 14, 2020, 12:08 AM
May 2020

I’ve been curious what’s happening in your part of the state. I wear a mask everywhere. Most people do at the few places I go which is comforting. I’m grateful for spring weather...it’s been so good to get out and hike where I don’t see anyone for miles and miles. That said...I agree with you. Trouble is coming.

GusBob

(7,286 posts)
26. Nice day for hiking today!
Thu May 14, 2020, 03:04 PM
May 2020

I know you miss baseball. The hiking has been good=first flowers blooming and trout biting like crazy. This weekend I went to the Bearpaw Battlefield, its open an not a soul in sight.

MontanaMama

(23,294 posts)
28. The wildflowers right now!!!
Thu May 14, 2020, 04:12 PM
May 2020

Yep. On Monday's hike, I saw larkspur, paintbrush, blue bells, lupine, buttercups, pasque flower and so much more. Still, I don't think our mountain wildflowers compare to what you have on the plains. I used to take a trip to Miles City every spring to turkey hunt before my kiddo was born...the spring flowers rivaled anything I'd ever seen.

2naSalit

(86,318 posts)
15. I worry about that too.
Thu May 14, 2020, 01:00 AM
May 2020

I hope it doesn't escalate but I fear things will get worse before better. One prediction I saw a while ago said that the expected peak for Montana would be around 6/20. We may have changed taht but when the tourists show up, everything changes.

Warpy

(111,124 posts)
16. I think it's over 900,000 now
Thu May 14, 2020, 02:11 AM
May 2020

when you factor in all the exurbs in Sandoval and Valencia Counties.

At least the Gov. is on the ball. I shudder to think what Susana la Tejana would have been doing all this time.

I'm also a little surprised Gallup is still closed. I expected the gin mill owners to be johnny on the spot filing lawsuits against the improper use of the Riot Control Act, which was clearly passed to kill unions.

In any case, I expect the bigger towns and the cities to be pretty compliant, out in the boonies, not so much.

(I moved here from Boston, which has the same population as this city. Factor in the burbs and exurbs, it goes up to 5 million)

abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
19. I'd have to actually look up the population stats here and I haven't done that since I moved here in
Thu May 14, 2020, 05:50 AM
May 2020

2005. I know I'm still here. Traffic is sure light whenever I go out, that's for sure. Yeah, we've always
voted straight Dem since we moved here and it's good to see it pay off now. I'm still disappointed with
the rate of mask/distance compliance here, especially at the apartments I live at. I'm a bitter old man who was previously a bitter child so I rag on people all the time.

I just did a search and here's one thing I found: "Albuquerque, New Mexico Population 2020
561,188". That'd be just inside the city limits, add on a bit more for the burbs.
https://worldpopulationreview.com/us-cities/albuquerque-population/

Here's the State Of New Mexico population: "New Mexico Population 2020 (Demographics, Maps, Graphs) 2,096,640" https://worldpopulationreview.com/states/new-mexico-population/

I like it here. There's lots more public politeness than I've seen elsewhere in bigger towns.

Warpy

(111,124 posts)
30. I just got too old for those Boston winters
Thu May 14, 2020, 04:43 PM
May 2020

The climate here is paradise. The summers are a lot longer, but triple digit heat with humidity under 20% is easier to take than 90+ heat with 90+ humidity.

I've already had a case of "presumptive," so I will probably be a little less fussy if somebody gets too close.

I've forgotten where I found those stats, it was about 2 months ago and it added in towns like Los Lunas and Belen, which are fair sized commuter towns, along with a few dinky towns to the north and that increased the total. Greater Boston extends into NH and northern RI, real estate prices being as insane as those around San Francisco and 90 minute commutes looking like a good idea so the rug rats will have a back yard.

I like the culture here.

abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
31. Hmmm...every town and city has a legal boundary that's called The City Limit and there are stats
Thu May 14, 2020, 05:46 PM
May 2020

for that. Then there are Metro Areas that count in the suburbs. I wouldn't include Belen and Los Lunas or Rio Rancho in that but then I think it's possible to claim artistic license in some courts. I'd say that given the population of the State Of New Mexico that nearly half of the state's population can be found
in the Greater Albuquerque area. I get a small town feel here that has kept me here so long.

I've been in New York City as a child and as an adult changing planes. Never been to Boston, I think that large groups of people are best avoided.

But I think we agree on most critical points. I like the culture here, too.

Warpy

(111,124 posts)
33. They are part of the "greater" because so many are commuter towns.
Thu May 14, 2020, 09:44 PM
May 2020

It was the same in Boston. The land area of Boston is small, but there are adjacent towns that weren't incorporated along with suburbs and exurbs, and they all drove to work in the city every day and you could chew the air, another reason I finally left.

abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
20. Thanks, I'm not involved in those details since the caretaker is handling it. Hell, I knew Mom
Thu May 14, 2020, 05:54 AM
May 2020

was gonna die but I wasn't even prepared for it once it happened. Sorry for your loss...

FBaggins

(26,714 posts)
21. People in Montana probably don't need to
Thu May 14, 2020, 07:57 AM
May 2020

Out of ~9,000 tests in the last couple weeks... they've only had about ten positive cases and only a couple people hospitalized. It's been two weeks since they last reported a death in the state and the total is only 16. Half of their counties haven't reported a single positive test. They started easing restrictions a couple of weeks ago and yet had only one positive test out of over 800 yesterday.

Making some assumptions from your post (mother is old enough to have a caregiver)... that caregiver may be one of the few that needs to take masks seriously (but even then, just in her patient's home)




abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
22. Suture yourself, as the do-it-yourself doctor kit says. As for me I believe that it's better to be
Thu May 14, 2020, 08:03 AM
May 2020

safe than sorry. You're in the U.P.? Been there, done that. Stay safe.

FBaggins

(26,714 posts)
25. The U.P.? Were you mistaking the outline of NC for part of MI?
Thu May 14, 2020, 02:43 PM
May 2020

"Better safe than sorry" is fine for your own life (though I doubt you were wearing the mask six months ago)... but insufficient to justify demeaning people in an entirely different situation than your own.

In NM, you could have 5,000 tests in a day and find that almost 150-200 of them were positive. Montana could go multiple days between anyone showing up positive. The risks (and therefore the appropriate societal responses) are entirely different.

abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
27. I do see a similarity between the outlines or North Carolina and Upper Michigan. It wasn't
Thu May 14, 2020, 03:10 PM
May 2020

my intention to cause any insult to anyone... You just go ahead and do whatever your own bad self* decides. So will I. I know I won't gamble with my life or anyone elses.

* to Bill Cosby

FBaggins

(26,714 posts)
29. That's the point you're missing. Of COURSE you'll gamble with your own life
Thu May 14, 2020, 04:33 PM
May 2020

You do it every time you get in a car or walk down a staircase or fly on a plane (or when you went out without a mask before Covid 19).

What you won't do is gamble with your life (or that of others) beyond a given set of odds that you consider too dangerous (when compared to the benefits you see of taking the risk).

Where you live (and in much of the country), the risks you would take in not wearing a mask in public... is beyond that threshold.

In Montana - the risk of going maskless today is below that of risks that you take all the time.

There's simply a difference between 16 cases statewide... and 231

abqtommy

(14,118 posts)
35. Oh no! Thanks for the update, Bob. It might be a good idea for you to start a new thread to maintain
Fri May 15, 2020, 08:38 AM
May 2020

visibility...I know here in New Mexico Our Navajo brothers and sisters are having a hard time now...

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»People in Montana aren't ...