General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMcConnell cautions Democrats on nixing the filibuster
I think the important thing for our Democratic friends to remember is that you might not be in total control in the future, the Kentucky Republican said. Any time you start fiddling around with the rules of the Senate, I think you always need to put yourself in the other fellows shoes and just imagine what might happen when the winds shift.
McConnell added that he has resisted pressure from President Donald Trump to nix the legislative filibuster.
https://www.politico.com/amp/news/2020/06/30/mcconnell-filibuster-democrats-345816
It's sinking in... they know a(nother) blue wave is coming. Good. I hope they choke on it.
We will never forget. We will never forgive.
Wounded Bear
(58,634 posts)The Senate right now is the last bastion defending racism and white privilege in our country.
They've stacked the courts, but I think we can alleviate that a bit with some decent legislation.
still_one
(92,116 posts)Demsrule86
(68,539 posts)It is risky but I think Senators should have to stand up and vote ...not hide behind the 60 vote rule.
Wounded Bear
(58,634 posts)Now, someone can declare a fillibuster, they'll call an immediate cloture vote and if it doesn't pass, they just move on. Bullshit, if someone wants to actually fillibuster, make them stand there in their comfy shoes and Depends and talk for hours and hours.
Now, everything gets fillibustered; they vote and can't get cloture and they just move on.
Me? I'd just nuke it. Fuck it, McConnell escalated for judges, time to escalate back and declare the minority part meaningless. Maybe that way they'll have to listen to the voters, most of whom blame "Congress" for nothing getting done when it has been Repubs riding the brakes for years upon years.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)steamrolling the minority. Some who find themselves always among smaller factions should appreciate the power it gives them to require some accommodation of their needs and beliefs from the mainstream.
Wounded Bear
(58,634 posts)Hortensis
(58,785 posts)been grossly misusing the filibuster keep Democrats from accomplishing anything. But that's not minority rule; and using it as intended, very rarely in special situations, does not create minority rule either. It tends to lead to negotiation and agreement both sides can live with when something is especially important to a minority group, but not always.
Btw, there's nothing simple and easy to understand about most legislative procedures and principles; as someone who wrote a book on this explained, by the time we hear about these issues they're usually twisted out of recognition and we don't understand what's at stake. Their critical principles and functions are never mentioned, just the current squabble.
The filibuster is intrinsically liberal as intended and is an essential check on abuses, both within the senate especially and through the federal government against the nation. McConnell's threatening Democrats, and that makes us want to spit in his crooked face because he abuses it to defeat democracy. Hopefully, at best he'll be gone next January, but at least that they'll be such a weak minority that they'll be forced to deal in something approaching good faith to get anything they want.
Mariana
(14,854 posts)to grossly misuse the filibuster, and to do it for decades on end, then it's much too flawed to leave in place as it is. It's not like the Republican Senators are going to suddenly become honest and principled, and stop misusing the filibuster on their own.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)should to okay throwing over what is very necessary for our own wellbeing and served us well for over 200 years. I suspect throwing over the McConnell Republicans and restoring ethical procedures would serve us far, far better.
For that, we need control. We'd all do far better to find some flawed friends who failed everyone in 2016 and refuse to leave them in place instead.
Mariana
(14,854 posts)That is 45 years ago, not 200. Maybe a repeal of that change is all that's necessary.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)as a way to fulfill the spirit of the constitution. One of those important tweaks to make it work as it was supposed to.
Everyone needs to understand that, although liberals might be forced to change the rules to eliminate the filibuster, actually imagining that'd be a good thing is to inadvertently support conservative attitudes of authoritarian hierarchy. Majority makes right and fuck all those who imagine they should have say.
Doremus
(7,261 posts)It's being abused to the detriment of Democracy, the antithesis of its purpose. Time for reform.
Maven
(10,533 posts)The ONLY way for the majority to have any of its legislative priorities move forward is to abolish the filibuster.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)That's what they want. Tough situation.
It's not that the nuclear option may not be taken, only that there are huge reasons why it's called that. It is itself a failure of the principles and structure of our democracy with potentially severe costs for everyone. And that's not considering McConnell eventually carrying out his threats; he'd do his worst regardless.
If the people give enough Republicans the boot from office in November, not just from the senate but from many offices nationally, it just may be the Republican Party that finally breaks and is forced to reform itself instead.
cstanleytech
(26,280 posts)maybe it's time to let it go.
Then if legislation is bad the voters will make the choice to change it by changing the makeup of the Senate.
Maven
(10,533 posts)It is an anti-majoritarian body. The filibuster makes it almost impossible for the majority to shape policy with their votes. That has to end.
Bev54
(10,045 posts)not republicans. The way the senate is set, with all these small states getting the same amount of senators as populated states, the dems will never get a veto proof majority for more than a very small period of time, if ever. They have only had it for a for a few months at a time over the last 40 years. It is the repubs that the senate favours. So get rid of it, get the work done that needs to be done. It is the only way any real work will be done at all. Screw Moscow Mitch, he is hardly one to listen to.
dalton99a
(81,432 posts)PJMcK
(22,025 posts)Two words:
Merrick Garland.
Just shut the fuck up, you un-American asshole.
GusFring
(756 posts)SoonerPride
(12,286 posts)We will pass Medicare for all, add two new states, and expand the SCOTUS to 13 jurists.
If anyone in your party filibusters those then we will end the filibuster.
Change is coming.
Wanderlust988
(509 posts)If we get a bare majority, I'm not confident we could muster the votes to get rid of it. Sen. Feinstein is dead set against removing it.
Wounded Bear
(58,634 posts)We look good at flipping the Senate right now. Stars are aligning. McConnell went all in on judges, Dems need to go all in on social justice programs. Even DiFi should be able to see that. California is marginalized more than most states by the fillibuster.
Demsrule86
(68,539 posts)Sherman A1
(38,958 posts)as long as the member doing the filibuster physically stands on and holds the floor until a cloture vote is passed or the member can no longer continue to talk.
Caliman73
(11,728 posts)If you are against allowing a bill to go up for debate, then put your face and voice out there so that people can see who is holding up legislation and why.
I would not even be opposed to more than one person doing the filibuster but they have to state their reasons for opposition and can't just read "Green Eggs and Ham". Put them on the record for their opposition.
House of Roberts
(5,168 posts)he better have another think, unless Schumer is as gutless as Harry Reid was.
It always seems like irresponsible tax cuts for the filthy idle oppressor class can get through on 51 votes, but getting rid of them always have to have 60. Better not this time!
liberal N proud
(60,334 posts)cstanleytech
(26,280 posts)did with Obama when he used it like a cudgel to stop his nominations which is what started this thing so I say fuck it and lets do away with it entirely.
Plus consider all for years the Republicans would weaponize a bill by passing it in the House to send to the Senate when they knew the Democrats would oppose and use the filibuster.
Then the Republicans would turn around and use that to rally their base and raise money and rinse and repeat.
This simply stops the cycle and it fucks them royally in the ass because it stop them from using the filibuster to raise money and rally their base.
CentralMass
(15,265 posts)John Fante
(3,479 posts)Laelth
(32,017 posts)It has outlived its usefulness.
-Laelth
The Magistrate
(95,244 posts)Everyone knows if he leads the minority he will filibuster every damned thing that comes down the pike, and prevent a Democratic administration and majority from governing as they were elected to do.
Better to bite the bullet and count on sound policy proving to be popular over the long haul, so that reptiles like McConnell never are again in power to do their damage to our people and our country.
uponit7771
(90,335 posts)The Magistrate
(95,244 posts)Everything he allowed a Republican minority to do, McConnell has disregarded as majority leader.
former9thward
(31,970 posts)former9thward
(31,970 posts)Mike Niendorff
(3,459 posts)And tell Mitch : this is what happens when you don't heed your own advice.
Long past time to go scorched earth on this guy.
MDN
Wounded Bear
(58,634 posts)Mike Niendorff
(3,459 posts)No reconciliation, no let's-make-nice, no let's-put-it-past-us.
It's time to put the hurt on Mitch and his fellow enablers.
It's time for them to pay the price.
MDN
niyad
(113,229 posts)Reallllllly, you worthless aste of oxygen? I remember when the Dems had control, and you traitorous bastards acted like YOU were still in charge.
I hope you and the other mask less traitors all contract fatal cases of the virus.
kairos12
(12,851 posts)chriscan64
(1,789 posts)One justice gets no hearing, two get installed with just over 50 votes. Maybe there is some remnant of a filibuster, but not at your trial, putz.
GulfCoast66
(11,949 posts)Wounded Bear
(58,634 posts)therefore the fillibuster could not be applied, like they did to Obama.
Xolodno
(6,390 posts)He wants to play by the rules again once he's out of power.
He's the one who started torching the rules of decorum, we may as well add gasoline. He made his bed, now he can sleep in it.
And sure, we may lose a cycle in the future and even try to repeal some things, but most will be institutionalized by then and they won't be able to touch it once it becomes popular. Then we will see GOP protest signs that say "keep the government out of my free healthcare". He got his judges, we'll see if it was worth it.
Doreen
(11,686 posts)Maybe not outright but it had a touch of something like it.
jojog
(372 posts)If we don't get climate change legislation through we are finished.
Maven
(10,533 posts)Your days of forcing regressive policies on the majority and packing the courts with unqualified extremists are coming to an end. Get ready for a progressive tsunami that will remake this nation into something civilized again, or for the first time, you snake.
gratuitous
(82,849 posts)We'll see how your shoes fit then. If you're still in the Senate, that is.
Ferrets are Cool
(21,105 posts)dem4decades
(11,282 posts)sobenji
(316 posts)bdamomma
(63,836 posts)nt.
Major Nikon
(36,827 posts)That prophecy is now being fulfilled.
The part of it Mitch just doesnt get is those winds are just never going to shift the other way again. The only thing keeping them afloat at the moment is a successful GOTV effort which has allowed them to get a bigger share of a shrinking demographic. The worst of it is that shrinking demographic is shrinking the fastest in the South.
So once the GOP is gone, they are gone forever. They might be able to somehow reinvent themselves and come back, but it sure wont be as the white peoples party.
Hassler
(3,370 posts)tinrobot
(10,893 posts)Sure sounds like it.
GeorgiaPeanut
(360 posts)I think senate rules should be changed to get rid of the damage created by Trump.
It is unlikely that repukes will ever have the presidency again anyway considering the demographic shift.
JDC
(10,125 posts)LudwigPastorius
(9,130 posts)Oh, eat me, you traitorous, turtle-looking motherfucker!
The Republican party is DONE come November.
dalton99a
(81,432 posts)roamer65
(36,745 posts)world wide wally
(21,740 posts)Flaleftist
(3,473 posts)BigmanPigman
(51,583 posts)and I sincerely doubt you have any real friends (they only want $$$ and power like you and your fucking wife). Even Mitch's adult kids hate him.
MontanaMama
(23,302 posts)Bless your heart. Say hello to your reckoning you self serving traitorous asshole.
cstanleytech
(26,280 posts)Instead what he should be doing is packing his bags and arranging a flight somewhere without an extradition treaty...............I heard Russia so maybe he will soon have a condo in Moscow?
bucolic_frolic
(43,123 posts)Because all I see is Merrick Garland, 200 Swift Boat judges, budgets that get diverted to a Mexican Wall, and no Democrat has the power to do anything about it.
Mitch should listen to himself.
AlexSFCA
(6,137 posts)no debate. We have legislative agenda to plow through at light speed. Biden will sign more bills than any president in history. Dems focus on people not politics, so to avoid gop poison pills, eliminating filibuster if VITAL. GOP is now a domestic terrorist organization responsible for more american deaths than any other terrorist organization. There must be ZERO tolerance for that.
dalton99a
(81,432 posts)Republicans are not our "esteemed colleagues and friends"
AlexSFCA
(6,137 posts)cstanleytech
(26,280 posts)investigate all the Russian as well as Chinese government ties inside the US to varies politicians I suspect we will see a number of Republicans booking flights out of the US and fleeing to countries without extradition treaties with the US.
Crowman2009
(2,494 posts)Kill the filibuster!
peggysue2
(10,828 posts)Is advice from McConnell the Obstructionist. The man deserves a swift kick to the curb because alongside Donald Trump he has proven himself an enemy of our Republic, enemy of all things democratic in nature.
And yes, it is dawning on these greed/power addicts that the tide is turning, that they will soon face minority status, a position they've earned by the numbers, underhanded methods, massive failures and American grief.
May they dwell in the ash bin of history, right behind America's primo Traitor, aka Donald Trump.
Never forget, never forgive.
marble falls
(57,063 posts)I think that the filibuster needs to be stripped down to what is was in the Franl Capra 30's.
None of these weenie semi head nods to filibuster.
No more "secret holds" holds. If you're holding up a nomination, put your name on it. How about" if a nomination is not rejected in XX ampint of days, the nomination is considered an appointment, why not?
cstanleytech
(26,280 posts)rule a default appointment like that as unconstitutional.
marble falls
(57,063 posts)who became Republican and reapportioned gerrymands that devalued our votes and gave us Republican Congresses. Sometimes we spend all our energy on Presidential election years and ignore the off years. DeLay, Gringrich, Lott, Graham, McConnell and their cronies took advantage of that and took over state legislatures.
pecosbob
(7,534 posts)mysteryowl
(7,373 posts)YOU broke the senate!
ibegurpard
(16,685 posts)Republicans have proved beyond a shadow of a doubt that they will not govern in good faith. They would get rid of it in a heartbeat on an issue critical to them. They proved that with their supreme court nominations. I believe it is now an anachronism.
cstanleytech
(26,280 posts)C Moon
(12,212 posts)rpannier
(24,329 posts)I think you always need to put yourself in the other fellows shoes and just imagine what might happen when the winds shift.
When? When did you do that?
yellowcanine
(35,699 posts)Just sayin'.
Volaris
(10,269 posts)Omg that's funny.
Mitch can go choke on a dick, theres no way no to stop the vengeance thats coming for the Party of Trump, and I suspect Yertle knows it now.
GulfCoast66
(11,949 posts)Keep talk till they run out of steam.
I just cant help thinking how much worse the last 3 years would have been had the senate been majority rules.
Remember, we have not controlled it since 2012. And while I think we take it this year it will be in play every election unless there is unless we see a huge political realignment this year.
OnDoutside
(19,952 posts)against Obama, then the filibuster will go, and it's on them. It's a two way street, no more dickhead Pauls.
jalan48
(13,855 posts)pwb
(11,258 posts)Like Supreme Court nominees?
D23MIURG23
(2,848 posts)maxsolomon
(33,284 posts)That ain't Democracy.
RGTIndy
(203 posts)He can't say a goddamn thing about the "rules of the Senate" ever again. Go fuck yourself, Mitch.