General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDahlia Lithwick: Mary Trump's Book Shows How Donald Trump Gets Away With It
https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2020/07/mary-trump-book-psychoanalysis-enablers.htmlMary Trumps Book Shows How Donald Trump Gets Away With It
The problem with a fraud as big as this president is that once you start collaborating with him, its impossible to get out.
By Dahlia Lithwick
July 13, 2020
5:52 PM
snip//
The bulk of the book focuses on the tale of Mary and her brother Fritzs abandonment by the rest of the Trump clan. Her father, Freddy, the scion and namesake, failed to be the storybook heir to her grandfathers real estate empire, instead collapsing into a tragic black hole of alcoholism, illness, and despair. Donald Trump, Freddys younger brother, not only helped push Freddy down but also stepped on his sinking shoulders on his way into the empty, Freddy-shaped space to become his fathers successor. And as Freddys parents and three other siblings altered their lives and priorities in order to orbit around Donald, Mary and her brother were eventually written out of the wills, the empire, and the family story, as payback for their fathers perceived weakness and failures. This is all tragic in its own right, but it also makes Mary, who has been let down by the so-called adults in the room almost since her infancy, perfectly positioned to explain and translate what happens to otherwise high-functioning adultsher aunt Maryanne, a competent federal judge; the lawyers and accountants tasked with fulfilling Donalds whims and hiding his failings; the sycophants and Republicans and evangelical Christians who support his campaign unquestioningly; and the officials who now populate the Senate, the Cabinet, and the Oval Office. All of them appear to be reasonably mentally sound. Yet they all cover for Donald, at the expense of real suffering and genuine human loss, just as the Trump clan ignored Freddys disintegration and death. Mary Trumps childhood trauma has become Americas trauma, and she really wants to know how that came to be. Again.
The section of the book that has garnered the most attention is likely Marys claim that Trump cannot be evaluated for pathologies because he is in the West Wing, essentially institutionalized and that he has in fact been institutionalized for most of his adult life. So there is no way to know how he would thrive, or even survive, on his own in the real world. We are not used to seeing entities like the White House described in this waya very expensive and well-guarded padded cellas a means of protection for the broken man inside rather than as a platform from which a leader can change the world. And her ultimate point is that even a shattered psyche, buffered from the real world, can still do irreparable damage to it. But the most interesting assessments she offers are reserved for those inside the institutions, the people who might have saved us and certainly have not, from the nuclear family, to the Trump businesses, to New Yorks bankers and powerful elites, to Bill Barr, Mike Pompeo, and Jared Kushner. They all knew and know that the emperor has no clothes, even as they devote their last shreds of dignity to effusive praise of his ermine trim and jaunty crown.
Mary Trump seems to answer the question of why they do this in a section late in the book about Donald Trumps father, Fred Trump. In describing Freds growing realizing that his fair-haired boy, Donald, was a fraud, Mary explains that, yes, Fred himself was a master at fattening his wallet with taxpayer funds, committing tax fraud to benefit his children. (Mary admits she was the one who leaked the family tax information to the New York Times in 2018 for its blockbuster story.) But as it became clear that Donald had no real business acumenas his Atlantic City casinos cratered and his father unlawfully poured secret funds into saving themMary realized that Fred also depended on the glittery tabloid success at which Donald excelled. Fred continued to prop up his sons smoke-and-mirrors empire because, as Mary writes, Fred had become so invested in the fantasy of Donalds success that he and Donald were inextricably linked. Facing reality would have required acknowledging his own responsibility, which he would never do. He had gone all in, and although any rational person would have folded, Fred was determined to double down.
Mary Trumps words there could just as easily be true for John Kelly, Kellyanne Conway, John Bolton, Mitch McConnell, Susan Collins, or Melania Trump. And as Mary Trump is quick to observe, the sheer stuck-ness of his enablers means that Trump never, ever learns his lesson. Being cosseted, lied to, defended, and puffed up means that Donald Trump knows that, no matter what happens, no matter how much damage he leaves in his wake, he will be OK. He fails up, in other words, because everyone around him, psychologically normal beings all, ends up so enmeshed with his delusions that they must do anything necessary to protect them. Trumps superpower isnt great vision or great leadership but rather that he is so tiny. Taking him on for transactional purposes may seem like not that big a deal at first, but the moment you put him in your pocket, you become his slave. It is impossible to escape his orbit without having to admit a spectacular failure in moral and strategic judgment, which almost no one can stomach. Donald Trumps emptiness is simply a mirror of the emptiness of everyone who propped him up. Its that reflection that becomes unendurable. This pattern, as Mary writes, guaranteed a cascade of increasingly consequential failures that would ultimately render all of us collateral damage. Nobody, not even Mary, who signed on briefly to ghostwrite one of his books, ends up just a little bit beholden to Donald Trump and that includes his rapturous supporters who still queue up, maskless, to look upon his greatness. As she concludes, his sociopathy reminds me that Donald isnt really the problem at all. That makes hers something other than the 15th book about the fathoms-deep pathologies of Donald Trump: It is the first real reckoning with all those who caused the darkness.
Mary Trump is, among other things, a brisk and gifted writer, and she is a fact witness to, and also a victim of, a family that elevated a mediocre and vicious man, at the expense of justice, fairness, and truth. Her real beef is not with her uncle Donald, who has always been exactly as we have long known him to be; thats why a smattering of new details about his business failures and meanness were never really the point of this book. Weve read that book before. The perspective of this book is made possible exactly because Mary Trump was one of the first children to be written out of the will, cast out of the family, and denied the support and love that should have been hers, as a result of her fathers perceived failures. It is thisbecause she was ousted rather than being forced to remove herselfthat allows her to see clearly why everyone else stuck around. And what she reveals is a devastating indictment of all the alleged adults who stick around Donald Trump, who came together to fail America, to leave vulnerable populations to fend for themselves, and who continue to lie and spin to pacify his ego. They do it because they cant admit the payoff is never coming, and to save themselves from the embarrassment of having to admit they were catastrophically wrong.
soothsayer
(38,601 posts)Squinch
(50,949 posts)Bernardo de La Paz
(48,999 posts)leftieNanner
(15,082 posts)Self delusion is a bad thing. Especially in high level elected officials.
Lookin' at you Lindsey and Mitch and Susan and ..................................
Pepsidog
(6,254 posts)Nasruddin
(752 posts)"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!" Upton Sinclair
They got their judges, they got their regulations removed, they got their immigrant bashing, they got their tax reduction.
There's more , but that's a sample of what they were in for, & the benefit.
They may, or may not, have desired some of the side effects of this and other regime actions.
diva77
(7,640 posts)tblue37
(65,336 posts)GopherGal
(2,008 posts)with a tinge of refusing to admit the completeness of their utter moral bankruptcy. (well, maybe only for that small subset of his supporters who are even capable of feeling shame.)
I may have to read the article (if not the book) because the endless willingness of his enablers to continue to torpedo their own credibility and, one would think, self-respect is morbidly fascinating.
paleotn
(17,911 posts)The only explanation that makes any sense.
lagomorph777
(30,613 posts)Maraya1969
(22,478 posts)uponit7771
(90,335 posts)FM123
(10,053 posts)All of them.
They do it because they cant admit the payoff is never coming, and to save themselves from the embarrassment of having to admit they were catastrophically wrong.
struggle4progress
(118,280 posts)TheBlackAdder
(28,183 posts).
And there were his marks, or more appropriately dupes, who are often too embarrassed to come forward.
.
Mr. Ected
(9,670 posts)And be willing to lose their job and jeopardize their future to Put America First.
Their cowardice is more damning than their ineptitude.
Nasruddin
(752 posts)George Conway III
I'm sure there're plenty more - not enough, but maybe more will come
Beartracks
(12,809 posts)Nasruddin
(752 posts)Check his twitter feed - I think he has early posts supportive of Mr Trump & I believe he has said that he voted for him in 2016
niyad
(113,265 posts)Traitor in chief's enablers, his continually- revolving inner circle, as "psychologically normal". Seems to me that there has to be some flaw in the psyche to even want to be near the orange thing. Sane people have long recognized him for exactly what he is, and do not think of wanting to associate with him.
Phoenix61
(17,003 posts)means no diagnosable pathology. That leaves a lot of space for bat shit crazy.
niyad
(113,265 posts)ResistantAmerican17
(3,801 posts)Phoenix61
(17,003 posts)A person who is batshit crazy is certifiably nuts. The phrase has origins in the old fashioned term "bats in the belfry." Old churches had a structure at the top called a belfry, which housed the bells. Bats are extremely sensitive to sound and would never inhabit a belfry of an active church where the bell was rung frequently. Occasionally, when a church was abandoned and many years passed without the bell being rung, bats would eventually come and inhabit the belfry. So, when somebody said that an individual had "bats in the belfry" it meant that there was "nothing going on upstairs" (as in that person's brain). To be BATSHIT CRAZY is to take this even a step further. A person who is batshit crazy is so nuts that not only is their belfry full of bats, but so many bats have been there for so long that the belfry is coated in batshit. Hence, the craziest of crazy people are BATSHIT CRAZY.
dmr
(28,347 posts)I enjoyed reading your post.
dhol82
(9,352 posts)Especially after having known many psychoanalysts.
Guy Whitey Corngood
(26,500 posts)complicated, psychobabble terms, such as "bat shit crazy".
pandr32
(11,579 posts)smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)I have pre-ordered the book. I can't wait to read it, if for no other reason that to feel justified in my belief that the man is, was and always will be an absolute loser, despite the image he crafts for himself.
lunatica
(53,410 posts)will ostracize them and so will everyone who hates Trump. Their futures will be ruined because theyll be ridiculed and will look extraordinarily stupid and gullible for having been so dumb as to fall for his brand of crazy. We, Trumps enemies, will never let them live it down, nor will we extend a hand of friendship to help them out.
Theyre fucked either way so not knowing what to do, so theyre treading water. This they continue to support him because we never will. Theyve been condoning too many real life and death sins. Were not going to forget or forgive.
BigmanPigman
(51,584 posts)The fucking moron is famous for holding grudges and revenge. I can beat him at that game. I will make it my mission in life to never, ever let anyone forgive and forget, especially those who were stupid enough to vote for him in the first place (they all have hate deep down in their tiny hearts).
lunatica
(53,410 posts)will be all anyone needs to know about them in order to reject them. And there will always be someone who remembers and tells everyone. They really are doomed.
BigmanPigman
(51,584 posts)dixiegrrrrl
(60,010 posts)I
They will be popping up in various levels of elections, as new Independents, as Libertarians, even as Dems.
It will be fairly easy to learn their background history, any attempt to erase it will look suspect.
.
lunatica
(53,410 posts)liberalmuse
(18,672 posts)Why do semi-sane people go all in for this vile failure of a human being and end up willing to lose everything - their self respect, morality, willing to shed everything that makes up a decent human being? Her explanation makes a lot of sense.
dmr
(28,347 posts)true to his own sense of being. He's played the game of politics, yet has kept his dignity and credibility. Now, Donald and his enablers are going after the man, but because Dr. Fauci has remained true, their betrayal will backfire.
That's a lesson right there.
Buns_of_Fire
(17,175 posts)Luckily for the rest of us, they're already wearing The Sign. It's in the form of a bright red baseball cap with the letters "MAGA" on the front.
love_katz
(2,578 posts)I am not usually a fan of country music, but that video was great! Perfect description of Agolf Twitler and his fans.
sunonmars
(8,656 posts)Pepsidog
(6,254 posts)DAngelo136
(265 posts)No one likes to admit being the victim of a con artist.
Nasruddin
(752 posts)If you've "pulled the trigger" too, you're a lot less likely to admit ....
Narc victims are sometimes mini-narcs themselves, with the same probs admitting any faults.
Mr.Bill
(24,282 posts)But I won't judge until I see the rest of the book.
I think there's a lot of blackmail going around in both directions. And whether he killed himself or not, that is why Jeffery Epstein is dead. A lot of these people have some very dark secrets, and other people's knowledge of them is at least partly what is driving their false loyalty and incomprehensible behaviors.
I believe Ghislaine Maxwell will not live to see another New Year's Eve. And I believe at some point some very prominent people will begin to disappear.
BigmanPigman
(51,584 posts)from Barr protecting his father and tRump (he hired Epstein years ago) to Graham protecting whatever Putin has on him and the rest of the GOP "mob family".
McKim
(2,412 posts)Bill, I think you are on to something big. People in high places have done things they dont want the public to know about.
dalton99a
(81,455 posts)DallasNE
(7,402 posts)The sucking sound of money here is a lot like the sucking sound of money coming out of Citizens United and the poster boy for the corruption that is always at the vortex of money. The house of cards is in full display.
Nasruddin
(752 posts)He fails up, in other words, because everyone around him, psychologically normal beings all, ends up so enmeshed with his delusions
This has just got to be wrong. It's at least partly wrong about Ms Trump herself. There have to be thousands of people at this point who got tangled up with Mr Trump's nonsense but then cut the cords and walked away. Some sooner, some later.
People like Mr Trump prey on susceptible persons. We need better education on how psychopaths and extreme narcissists operate so people can train, and overcome this ensnarement easier. I would point out that it is often other narcs that are attracted to and get drawn into the traps laid by these difficult people. Not sure why.
lunatica
(53,410 posts)and the power it gives them. Trump is a very noisy millionaire who has spent a lifetime selling himself as a high powered rich man who pretends hell help his followers be like him. From his Trump University to his Art of The Deal to his Apprentice persona he promises fame, wealth and power to anyone who follows him.
Hes the conman and we, the American people are his mark. Those of us who dont fall for it are ignored and drowned out by the loud fanfare.
Nasruddin
(752 posts)The reverence of psychopathic behavior in CEOs, politicians, generals & the like goes beyond Mr Trump. I see this as something he takes advantage of. Many people want to be the wingman to successful examples and the behavior is repeated with other leaders. There are also people trying to con the con (sometimes the same person). I don't understand this behavior but they are often marks too - it's a thing successful narcs do to people around them, they manipulate this behavior.
Traildogbob
(8,716 posts)The former bama coach running against Sessions, just listen to him rant. God sent trump cause he knew we needed help. Sessions abandoned trump when he needed him. I will never abandon trump. On and on and on. He is auditioning to GRT paid. At this point he can never say he got conned. What an ass hole. Hope trump brings it all down on the Governance Of Putin GOP crime syndicate.
Proud Liberal Dem
(24,406 posts)We are all in immense jeopardy because of sunk cost fallacy on a massive level?!
obamanut2012
(26,068 posts)I know someone who discovered three days before her wedding her fiance had three kids with a woman he had been with for over a decade. He bought her a condo, he gave her money for the kids, he stayed over one or two nights a week when he said he was at the office very late working on a case and would just sleep on his couch.
What did she do?
She married him.
Why?
Because her parents AND HIS said they had spent too much money on the wedding and reception, and guests were flying from all over, and it would be too embarrassing to cancel, so just get married.
So she did.
He had a great time, she was miserable and obviously distressed.
She visited a divorce attorney two days later. He went on the honeymoon.
Her parents were supportive and loving her entire life until this happened. She has barely talked to them in the years since it happened, because their embarrassment and money was worth more to them than her psyche.
I always think of this when sunk cost fallacy is mentioned.
Proud Liberal Dem
(24,406 posts)What a crazy/sad story.
My heart goes out to your friend. I hope the next chapter that followed brought her the happiness she was robbed of.
seta1950
(932 posts)She could of told us this before the 2016 elections
StarfishSaver
(18,486 posts)First, she never thought he would win. But more important, she knew no one would believe her or care what she had to say. She'd have been seen simply as a disgruntled relative seeking to settle scores decades after she and her brother were disinherited. And she's right.
Her perspective resonates now because we've all see him in action. But four years ago, she would have been dismissed out if hand, just like everyone else who tried to warn the country about him.
Nevilledog
(51,080 posts)StarfishSaver
(18,486 posts)The stories she tells about Trump bring no surprises to anyone who has been paying attention to him. What I think makes the book unique and very meaningful is how she so skillfully contextualizes everything. She gathers all we know about him, things we may or may not have known about his family, and puts it all into perspective - not just anecdotally, but clinically. It's very powerful.
Nevilledog
(51,080 posts)Warpy
(111,245 posts)It's about the power of propaganda, bullying, fear of being different, and groupthink. I think he's always known this and has worked it to his greatest advantage.
They do it because they cant admit the payoff is never coming, and to save themselves from the embarrassment of having to admit they were catastrophically wrong.
Yeah, I'd say Mary has all their numbers.
sprinkleeninow
(20,237 posts)Takket
(21,562 posts)^THIS
brilliantly said.........
i have been baffled these last four years as to WHY people support him. The answer has always been, they don't care that he is godless, or stupid....... he's racist, and that feeds their ultimate desire.
but beyond that i wondered....... well... there are lots of racists....... at least 1/3 of the country apparently..... why him? He seems to lack all of the base qualities that makes for a good leader/politician that will make people support you. He has no record of heroism from military service to tout, he has no history of being a leader of persons on any level (elected office or otherwise), he isn't eloquent (the the point of being virtually incoherent when he speaks), he is bereft of charm and charisma, and he isn't attractive at all.
but now it all makes sense.......... he is a mirror for the legions that form his cult........... and those people, who love only themselves, adore the reflection they see.
pansypoo53219
(20,972 posts)the moron is fake.