How Can A Senator Vote With Trump Most Of The Time And Still Be A Moderate?
A number of GOP senators especially those from states that backed Hillary Clinton in 2016 are in competitive reelection fights in 2020, including Sens. Cory Gardner of Colorado and Susan Collins of Maine. In their campaign pitches, these senators have been presenting themselves as moderates worthy of representing moderate states, using words and phrases like bipartisan, building consensus and both sides of the aisle.
But just how moderate are Gardner and Collins anyway?
That question is surprisingly difficult to answer, as it really depends on what senatorial behavior is being examined. That is, someone like Gardner can both vote with President Trump on nearly all major issues and still be one of the three most bipartisan members of the Senate. The same is true of Collins. At the risk of getting a little bit wonky, I want to dig into three of the most commonly used metrics for measuring a senators ideology to show you how each of them can be spun.
Lets first start with a metric that FiveThirtyEight has developed, the Trump score, or how often a senator or representative votes in line with what Trump wants. According to this metric, Collins has voted with Trump 67 percent of the time in the past three and a half years, while Gardner has done so 89 percent of the time. This is one of the easier metrics to grasp, and if you dont like Trump, someone who does what he wants two times out of three or nine times out of ten doesnt sound so great.
But what do these scores actually tell us?
https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-can-a-senator-vote-with-trump-most-of-the-time-and-still-be-a-moderate/