General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Washington Post's Picks for Biden's Cabinet:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/08/21/biden-picked-his-vp-now-we-pick-his-dream-cabinet/?utm_campaign=wp_week_in_ideas&utm_medium=email&utm_source=newsletter&wpisrc=nl_ideasIt's a great list!
(Tom Toles/The Washington Post)
Opinion by The Ranking Committee
August 21, 2020 at 6:04 a.m. PDT
Add to list
With presumptive Democratic nominee Joe Bidens veep picked, convention concluded and campaign cruising ahead of his opponents, he might be tempted to start measuring the White House drapes. So to curb that temptation, the Ranking Committee members are doing it for him for Round 69 starting with whom he should pick for his Cabinet.
Drew Goins
Chief of Staff Susan Rice
Rice would obviously be a great secretary of state as well, but the Biden-Harris administration will immediately confront so many problems on so many fronts that it will be vital to have a take-charge chief of staff who can set priorities and make things happen. Rice has the needed close relationship with Biden, and she takes no mess from anyone. Imagine the woe to befall any poor staffer who came to a meeting unprepared.
Eugene Robinson
Secretary of State Chris Coons
This Republican would rest easier if Sen. Coons was at the helm of the State Department in his friend Joe Bidens administration. The Delaware Democrat is clear-eyed about China and has a record of advocacy for straight talk about Chinas Communist Party that few Democrats can match.
Hugh Hewitt
Special Envoy Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Pete Buttigieg
Buttigieg should be tapped for a top State role managing the rebuilding of U.S. international leadership and alliances with a focus on the coronavirus. Buttigieg speaks a gazillion languages. Hed be apt at communicating to his fellow millennials the virtues of restoring U.S. global leadership on 21st-century challenges such as the need for better global health infrastructure. They might justifiably be suspicious that such leadership can accomplish much good in the world, but Buttigieg likes nothing more than persuading people into optimism with that technocratic flair of his.
Greg Sargent
Treasury Secretary Gina Raimondo
The governor of Rhode Island is arguably the most effective executive in politics today and certainly the one with the most guts. She has taken on hard problems, such as underfunded pensions and rampant coronavirus. Shes a veteran of Wall Street who can talk the language of the financial industry, but shes not its slave or its tool. Shell be ready to mop up the damage done during the Shutdown Crash. Then again, she might be the only person ready to master the mess known as the Department of Homeland Security.
David Von Drehle
or DHS Secretary Gina Raimondo and Treasury Secretary Andrew Cuomo
Biden needs someone at Treasury who can mediate between the different wings of the Democratic Party while maintaining the confidence of the markets. Who better to do that than the governor from Wall Street himself?
Henry Olsen
Defense Secretary Michèle Flournoy
One of the leading defense intellectuals of her generation, Flournoy is also a seasoned veteran at the Pentagon, having served under President Barack Obama as undersecretary for policy. She can take the worlds toughest bureaucracy and point it toward a dangerous but different future. And 100 years after suffrage, its time to have a female defense secretary; Id love to see a majority-female Cabinet.
David Von Drehle
Attorney General Sally Yates
A courageous civil servant who has demonstrated her commitment to upholding the law even under personally and politically difficult conditions.
Catherine Rampell
Commerce Secretary Erica Groshen or another protector of stats
Dont let the name of the department fool you; arguably Commerces most important function is overseeing most of the federal governments major independent statistical agencies. This job may be especially hard next year, given attempted sabotage of the census. Id appoint Groshen (former Bureau of Labor Statistics commissioner and fierce defender of statistical agency independence) or if not her, perhaps Julia Lane (NYU economist who just wrote a book about democratizing public data), Katherine Wallman (former chief statistician of the United States) or someone else with a demonstrated commitment to safeguarding and upgrading government statistics, which have been under assault for the past three-plus years.
Catherine Rampell
Labor Secretary Sara Nelson
Nelson, president of the Association of Flight Attendants union, would be an olive branch to organized labor and the progressive wing of the party. The labor movements rising star doesnt hold public office which was a disadvantage as a long-shot name in the veepstakes, but an advantage in a year when Biden wants avoid taking too many members of Congress away from their seats.
David Byler
Sign up for The Odds newsletter for election updates from data columnist David Byler
Health and Human Services Secretary Mitt Romney
After all, as Democrats keep telling us, Obamacare was really his idea and it would be a meaningful gesture across the aisle in an era when such things are badly needed.
Megan McArdle
Housing and Urban Development Secretary Cory Booker
His campaign stump speech would always begin with the story of how his life was changed by strangers who fought against housing discrimination so that his parents could buy their dream house and give him a future. And who has better experience than the former mayor of Newark?
Karen Tumulty
Energy Secretary Mitch Landrieu
A Louisiana politician who understands both the offshore oil and gas industry and the environmental risks it poses, Landrieu would be a Democratic voice from the Gulf Coast in an administration that probably wont have many others. His stand on Confederate monuments in New Orleans was bold and deserves recognition, too.
Charles Lane
Veterans Affairs Secretary Michelle Howard
The highest-ranking woman and African American in U.S. Navy history, Adm. Howard retired in 2017 with four stars and experience both in Washington, as the Navys second-in-command at the Pentagon, and abroad, as commander of U.S. naval forces in Europe and Africa. She might not want this notoriously thankless job, but Americas veterans would be lucky to have her.
David Von Drehle
Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Jay Inslee
He ran his campaign on a single issue. That issue is now the single most important, and conveniently for the country, theres an expert on what to do about it ready to serve. Inslee put climate change front and center in the primary. He could make sure it stays there in the presidency.
Molly Roberts
Director of National Intelligence Adam Schiff
The California congressman, who chairs the House Intelligence Committee and served as a House impeachment manager, would be a fine pick for DNI. Among the many tasks the next chief will face is repairing trust between Congress and the intelligence community. And of course, no one is more familiar with the Trump eras partisan perversion of intelligence than Schiff is.
Jennifer Rubin
CIA Director Drew Gilpin Faust
The first female president of Harvard University is the 21st-century equivalent of the so-called Wise Men of the mid-20th century, the sage leaders whose independent stature gave them the freedom to be honest and whose stock in trade was good judgment. She would bring a much-needed gravitas to the battered intelligence community.
David Von Drehle
Bonus Yang!
I want Andrew Yang to have some job that puts him at the forefront of the administrations thinking on technology, the economy and the future. He has a creative, counterintuitive mind and a voice that should continue to be heard.
Karen Tumulty
Fiendish Thingy
(23,200 posts)CaliforniaPeggy
(156,619 posts)Sneederbunk
(17,483 posts)Kamala4TheWin
(55 posts)and they can spare the seat, Warren should be Secretary of Education and Yang the Commerce Secretary.
I also want a position for Beto...maybe Press Secretary
Chainfire
(17,757 posts)the denazification bureau.
Fiendish Thingy
(23,200 posts)Although Adam Schiff would be fantastic as Director of National Intelligence, Id prefer to see him take over as speaker of the house when Pelosi steps down in 2022 (which she announced when she was re-elected as speaker after the 2018 blue wave).
That, and Warren as Senate Majority Leader. (Seniority be damned) Warren would be far more effective than anyone else I can think of in shepherding legislation through the senate to Bidens desk without it being watered down to the point of meaninglessness.
BComplex
(9,912 posts)She should have been president. She needs an office where she can make big changes before another nazi steps in an ruins the country for once and for all.
Fiendish Thingy
(23,200 posts)A cabinet member can help shape policy, which can change with the next administration.
The Majority Leader guides and crafts Laws, which endure. Warren would ensure that no Third Way, Neoliberal BS would make it to Bidens desk.
Right now, as we speak, Trumps Labor Secretary, Scalias son, is deregulating the financial advisor industry, loosening rules that advisors must act in clients best interests, as well as loosening rules about the riskiness of funds allowed in 401ks.
Warren could guide legislation to protect against this type of corruption.
BComplex
(9,912 posts)Fiendish Thingy
(23,200 posts)tritsofme
(19,898 posts)Its pretty silly to think he would face a coup, let alone a successful one, after restoring a Democratic majority for the first time in six years.
hedda_foil
(16,985 posts)I adore Elizabeth Warren, and think she should be Treasury Secretary, but it's unlikely that centrist members of the Senate Democratic caucus would go for her as Leader.
Fiendish Thingy
(23,200 posts)MyOwnPeace
(17,549 posts)It will be important to have strong leadership in both House and Senate if we are to get things back on line. I could think of a couple of Cabinet positions in which both Warren and Schiff would benefit our country and Joe's team, but the BEST must be where they are!
JHB
(38,207 posts)HHS, like the entire rest of the federal government during this Republican administration, needs a thorough assessment of how its functions have been damaged through Republican neglect and outright sabotage. Would Romney be diligent in carrying out that job?
lamp_shade
(15,479 posts)Not on the list.
nolabear
(43,850 posts)Totally Tunsie
(11,850 posts)I'd hate to see our Governor moving on to Washington. Our little state needs her still.
DFW
(60,170 posts)(To the Washington Post: )
From your "suggestions," either you posted such awful ones for about half of the postings that one can only surmise you wanted to provoke counter-suggestions, or you asked the RNC to do all the work. You actually asked Hugh Hewitt and Henry Olsen? Who do they suggest for Intelligence czar? Alexander Lukashenko?
Pete Buttigieg for some nothing non-existent post because he speaks "a gazillion languages?" He speak seven, including the dubiously useful Maltese and Darí. So what? I speak nine, and they are all of languages of either allies (German, French, Spanish, Dutch and Italian, e.g.) or important adversaries (Russian). Plus I speak oddball languages like Swedish and Catalan, which have their uses on occasion. I could help mediate the separatist movement in northeastern Spain! Whoopeee! Seriously, Mayor Pete deserves better, and less focus on his peripheral talents. State, Defense, HUD.
And will someone FINALLY please get us Howard Dean for HHS Secretary while his batteries are still fully charged? This is already 12 years overdue. Rahm Emmanuel's grudge has deprived us of Howard's talents long enough.
Oh, and by the way please Cory Booker for Senator from New Jersey, period. The guy jumped in vocally with the "get Al Franken" crowd when the Republicans invented their scam. Not even a hint of a public apology. Instead: Al Franken for anything that Cory Booker might be suggested for, because he not only deserves it more, but would probably be far better at it.
And finally: Susan Rice for White House COS and Jay Inslee for EPA? Well, bravo, the stopped clock is indeed spot on correct twice a day.
OnDoutside
(20,868 posts)DFW
(60,170 posts)But at least I still get to speak out. There's that.
OnDoutside
(20,868 posts)DFW
(60,170 posts)PatSeg
(53,211 posts)especially the part about Howard Dean who served the Democratic party so well as DNC chair and was treated so poorly afterward.
I liked Sally Yates for Attorney General. I don't like the idea of taking Adam Schiff out of congress, he is a powerful voice and I see him as eventually becoming Speaker.
And why would Chris Coons want to be Secretary of State? We don't need to take a Democrat out of the senate, unless we can be absolutely sure a Democrat will replace him. And why do we care what Hugh Hewitt thinks about a Biden cabinet? Actually why did The Washington Post even think to include him?
Overall, I wasn't terribly impressed with the list, but it will be interesting to see how close it is to reality.
DFW
(60,170 posts)I speculated flat out in my comment that I thought they just posted all that for no other reason than to provoke responses to the contrary. Even some Republicans realize what worthless right wing extremists Hewitt and Olsen are. No purpose whatsoever is served by asking them their opinion on anything more controversial than the weather.
PatSeg
(53,211 posts)which is evident by the comments here, so if that was their intent, it worked. I'm surprised they didn't ask Donald Trump's opinion.
DFW
(60,170 posts)At least those whose names he recognizes--should be at least a third of them.
GoCubsGo
(34,899 posts)The bench is plenty deep without taking away good people from Congress.
Stinky The Clown
(68,952 posts) Drew Goins
Chief of Staff Susan Rice
Not a current office holder, so no sweat.
Eugene Robinson
Secretary of State Chris Coons
I suspect DE would replace him with another Democrat.
Hugh Hewitt
Special Envoy Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Pete Buttigieg
Not a current office holder, so once again, no sweat
Greg Sargent
Treasury Secretary Gina Raimondo
Her Lt Governor is also a Democrat
David Von Drehle
or DHS Secretary Gina Raimondo and Treasury Secretary Andrew Cuomo
Cuomo's Lt Governor is Democrat Kathy Hochul, who has also served in Congress.
Henry Olsen
Defense Secretary Michèle Flournoy
Another great suggestion and yet again, not a current office holder
David Von Drehle
Attorney General Sally Yates
Not an incumbent office holder and a GREAT choice!
Catherine Rampell
Commerce Secretary Erica Groshen
or another protector of stats
And an another non-incumbent
Catherine Rampell
Labor Secretary Sara Nelson
Ooo Ooo Ooo another non incumbent. And wicked good choice!
David Byler
Health and Human Services Secretary Mitt Romney
Now that's a seat we can take from an incumbent. Ha!
Megan McArdle
Housing and Urban Development Secretary Cory Booker
Its New Jersey! I should think it isn't a worry.
Karen Tumulty
Energy Secretary Mitch Landrieu
Once again, no loss of an incumbent
Charles Lane
Veterans Affairs Secretary Michelle Howard
Well well, a retired 4 star black woman. If she's smart, she won't take it. If she's about service, she will. I suspect she would.
David Von Drehle
Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Jay Inslee
Democrat Lt Governor Cyrus Habib would replace him.
Molly Roberts
Director of National Intelligence Adam Schiff
Its California. No worries.
Jennifer Rubin
CIA Director Drew Gilpin Faust
And ANOTHER non officeholder.
GoCubsGo
(34,899 posts)Still don't like it.
Stinky The Clown
(68,952 posts)If you dont like the person for other reasons I dont care. Just your posts stated concern.
Stinky The Clown
(68,952 posts)lpbk2713
(43,273 posts)There will be a hell of a lot of fence mending to be done
and she would be ideal for the job if she wants it.
OnDoutside
(20,868 posts)I think it would be Rice though.
mvd
(65,911 posts)Thanks for posting the picks. It is a fair list. We dont need a Republican, especially in charge of health! And the list is a bit centrist wing heavy. I do like Inslee and there has been no one more vocal about climate change.
CaliforniaPeggy
(156,619 posts)I think that some of the posters responding are forgetting that I didn't make this list--I just posted it!
I just wanted people to see what ideas are out there circulating.
mvd
(65,911 posts)Always good to see the ideas out there.
CaliforniaPeggy
(156,619 posts)PatSeg
(53,211 posts)I knew it came from The Washington Post and appreciate you posting the list.
DeminPennswoods
(17,504 posts)He filled a similar role when Biden was VP and has known him for 30+ years.
Susan Rice is a lightning rod. I don't think she gets a cabinet post at all. Maybe she ends up as Amb to the UN.
Love Sally Yates for Atty Gen.
Can't see a woman as SecDef yet but could as 1 or more of the CINCs.
Would like to see Robert Reich back at OMB, head of economic advisers or another similar job.
Hekate
(100,133 posts)Fingers crossed we get the chance!