General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSlate "It Took Savannah Guthrie 19 Minutes to Give Trump His Toughest Grilling in Years"
https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2020/10/savannah-guthrie-trump-town-hall-grilling.html(This is a great read, esp for those - like me - that refuse to watch the orange asshole)
Rather than face former Vice President Joe Biden in a town hall debate on Thursday, President Donald Trump took questions from voters in a one-hour special on NBC. Before the Miami crowd got its turn, however, host Savannah Guthrie interviewed Trump directly, appearing to respond to criticism of the networks decision to hand Trump air time by giving the president one of the most intense grillings of his four years in office.
Guthrie pressed the president on details related to his own experience with COVID-19, his baffling evasiveness when asked to condemn white supremacy, and the QAnon conspiracy theory, which Trump declined to condemn but did say, I do know they are very much against pedophilia, they fight it very hard. While Trump tried to fall back on his usual bluster, Guthrie was a cheerful but firm interviewer, returning again and again to the facts and details of Trumps answers. As usual, Trump attempted to lie through the barrage of tough questionsand almost every time got pinned down by an interviewer who didnt back off. At one point, after Guthrie parried one of Trumps attempts to undermine a questions premise, the president replied, So cute.
Quite a lot happened in 19 or so minutes! Lets take it topic by topic.
COVID-19
Guthrie wasted no time in launching into Trumps inconsistencies. After introducing herself, explaining the situation behind the competing presidential town halls, and wishing the first lady and their son good health, she asked Trump to explain his unusually intense medical treatment.
Trump responded that he didnt feel good and that he had a temperature, and that all I know is I felt good the following day. Guthrie wasnt satisfied with the answer. Did the doctors ever tell you that they saw pneumonia on your lung scan?
Trump: No, but they said the lungs are a little bit different, a little perhaps infected, and
Guthrie: Infected with?
Trump: I dont know. I didnt do too much asking. I really felt good. I didnt have much of a problem with the lungs. I did have a little bit of a temperature. Obviously I felt there was something missing. And then I tested, you know, I tested positive.
Guthrie then tried to pin Trump on the dates of his infection, a topic for which the White Houses explanations have shifted. Your first positive test was Thursday, Oct. 1, OK? When was your last negative test? When did you last remember having a negative test? Trump didnt give a definitive answer, but thanks to Guthries persistence he offered a bit more detailand made a revealing obfuscation:
snip - LOTS more at the link
Salviati
(6,008 posts)Slather him in ketchup, he's done.
flibbitygiblets
(7,220 posts)Honestly I didn't have a hope in hell that Guthrie would do anything other than let trump get away with lying his assoff.
I think her ability to be pleasant but direct and firm really worked where others have not been as successful in holding his feet to the fire.
CountMyVote4Reality
(209 posts)A more thorough grilling became a trump steak?
Perhaps it was a MORE thorough grilling THAN whatever.
Apologies from a grammar cop, but I hope you'll phrase better in the future.
nutshell2002
(178 posts)We all knew exactly what you meant. I find myself making simple typos when I text/type. Thank you for sharing your thought and have a great day!
BigmanPigman
(51,584 posts)I refuse to watch him too. I watched a bit of Cuomo on CNN and he said that Guthrie did a great job of not letting him off the hook, which too many reporters do. The transcript reinforced why I can't watch him. Just reading what he said has me super pissed off. This part was the winner (she asked him about saying he would have a peaceful transition of power if he loses)
Trump: "Savannah, I want it to be clean. I really feel were going to win. But I want this to be clean
. Peaceful transfer, I absolutely want that. But ideally I dont want a transfer because I want to win."
That seems to say that if he loses than there will be no peaceful transition. We knew this is what he will do and finally got him to say it.
CountMyVote4Reality
(209 posts)THAN is a comparison like more or less.
Sorry to go grammar cop, but nerve was already struck.
Maru Kitteh
(28,339 posts)friendly helpful reminders in our writing. It helps us improve, imo.
underpants
(182,773 posts)sitting on his porch with no one ever calling him on his wild ass stories and twisted reality of stories hes heard and told a thousand times.
Trump: Why arent you asking me about antifa? Why arent you asking me about the radical left? Why arent you asking Joe Biden questions aboutwhy doesnt he condemn antifa? Why does he say it doesnt exist?
MFM008
(19,805 posts)slept through it all.
sheshe2
(83,746 posts)Oh boy.
No words and I just need some sleep now.
Shrike47
(6,913 posts)TheBlackAdder
(28,183 posts).
What bullshit.
.
COL Mustard
(5,897 posts)I didn't watch the town hall. I was too busy drinking...making good use of the time!
PSPS
(13,591 posts)COL Mustard
(5,897 posts)Since all the righties are whining about it. Check out FR if you want some real cheesy whine!
Lucinda
(31,170 posts)chriscan64
(1,789 posts)Another self inflicted wound for Trump who could have done another worthless rally and changed no minds at all. Lost a few votes if anything changed.
Thekaspervote
(32,755 posts)UCmeNdc
(9,600 posts)Trump answers sounds like a crazy old man.
Trump sounds like he supports QAnon.
Grokenstein
(5,722 posts)just from the tweets from weeping arseholes shrieking about how she was "unfair" and it was an "ambush" and how he "dominated" her. You can bet he'll be hurling his bowl of num-nums from his Big Boy Chair all night long if he isn't drugged out of his gourd. ...I mean, more so than what was the pre-COVID norm.
Cha
(297,154 posts)cwydro
(51,308 posts)wnylib
(21,432 posts)But in the end, Trump got what he wanted - attention diverted to him and away from Biden's own town hall.
In the morning and all day long, the media will focus on the things that Trump said and largely ignore the views that Biden expressed and the answers that he gave.
burrowowl
(17,639 posts)DeminPennswoods
(15,278 posts)Trump: That was a retweet. That was an opinion of somebody. And that was a retweet. Ill put it out there.
Guthrie: I dont get that. Youre the president. Youre not someones crazy uncle who can retweet whatever.
Except he is that crazy uncle.
Sunsky
(1,737 posts)I'm done with NBC except for a few hosts. She could have done her stellar job on another day or time.
Biden had one of his best performances. He elaborated on many key issues, yet some voters were not watching due to conflicting schedules. This election is crucial for minorities and I'm not here for NBC's political gamesmanship. Now, Savannah or Trump becomes the headline instead of Biden's great performance. We will soon hear comparisons of how many people watched Trump vs Biden. It should not have been this way.
BobTheSubgenius
(11,563 posts)I bet the WH did due diligence on SG and determined that she was reasonably benign, and the dolt thought his vastly superior intellect could manage both her and the situation.
Good thinking, you fucking imbecile. If you had even an inkling of how inadequate you are in just about every area, you'd be in a darkened room, weeping.
UserNotFound
(108 posts)She was pretty tough on him, for a corporate media type...but I think I would have called him a fuckin' liar right off the bat.... Thanks for the link!!
JohnnyRingo
(18,625 posts)I missed both events, figuring I could read about it later (now). I expected one of the programs to be a bit boring and the other to be off the rails crazy. Guess which one attracts more eyeballs.
Sounds like Guthrie just gave Trump a shovel and let him start digging.
bucolic_frolic
(43,132 posts)Wow is she going to get promotions!
BlueLucy
(1,609 posts)I knew it would be a woman to finally get it done.
Blue Owl
(50,349 posts)n/t
Justice
(7,185 posts)Guthrie stood up to Trump and acted like a reporter.
I thought and said hed talk all over her.
I was wrong.
cp
(6,623 posts)Shows how Dumpy talks exactly like a mob boss, that is, in code with loads of deniability. Only now he's so addled that there is no plausibility about his denials.
Thank you, Savannah Guthrie, even though NBC stinks for giving him free air time.