Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:25 AM Oct 2020

I do not see how, even with Biden as POTUS, the US will stop COVID-19

Last edited Wed Oct 21, 2020, 11:39 AM - Edit history (1)

100 million (or so) MAGAts and their families, plus their non-voting brethren, plus the Red/Purple states (especially with Rethug Governors) power structures (and local Red areas as well) in full coronaviral rebellion equals:

1. They will not socially distance, and I suspect they will only increase their violent attacks on mask wearers and social distancers, or people to try to force the insurrectionists to comply
2. They will not close their businesses, even temporarily in numbers large enough to have universal systemic impact
3. They will not wear masks, they will not stop meeting in large groups
4. A huge number (some non Rethugs too) will not take a vaccine (which will be only partially effective IF one is even found)
5. Local law enforcement in many cases will not enforce shit (even in Blue states)
6. They will not close schools in many cases, they will not close their churches, nor their sporting events, in so many cases
7. The will travel to states and areas in their own states that ARE following safety regulations and practices, and spread it there
8. They will violently resist orders, and it will get FAR worse when it is a Democratic POTUS who is trying to crack down
9. A defeated Trump and other RW sources (Fux Newz, OANN, hate radio, hate internet, YT, Twitter, FB, etc etc) will stir up insurrection, resistance, non-compliance non-stop resistance and sabotage of Biden and all Democratic attempts at mitigation.
10. Even herd immunity may not work (even after 2 to 3 million plus die) due to mutations, or a going away of T-Cell and antibody immunity, or simply the percentages needed to for herd immunity to work never being reached.

I am sure I have left a lot out, too.

How does Biden change this? Nationwide martial law? That will cause insane violence and resistance, and there just isn't enough enforcement personnel in terms of raw numbers.

Colour me very pessimistic the US can come to grips with the pandemic, even with a massive Blue Wave in the elections. I can see it TRULY becoming a global pariah state, with Americans banned from entering many nations (barring a 2 or 3 week managed quarantine once they fly or drive in) years, and basically being known chiefly as a death projector.

I so, so, so welcome/am-open-to any suggestions/programmes/hopes/alternative scenarios, etc etc that show me as being dead wrong.

81 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I do not see how, even with Biden as POTUS, the US will stop COVID-19 (Original Post) Celerity Oct 2020 OP
$10,000 fines. My Pet Orangutan Oct 2020 #1
+1 mdelaguna Oct 2020 #12
I agree, but that's not a realistic amount FoxNewsSucks Oct 2020 #20
good idea but then it makes more police/citizen direct contact treestar Oct 2020 #27
The fine in my city is $9 BannonsLiver Oct 2020 #55
Biden can withhold certain federal funds from states that are not making an effort. Blue_true Oct 2020 #74
Jeez-zuz! Calm down. Surely you did not mention martial law!? No, I must have read that wrong. Solomon Oct 2020 #2
No dweller Oct 2020 #7
well if not martial law (obviously the final last resort if states simply flat out refuse to obey) Celerity Oct 2020 #14
How well do you know the US system? GulfCoast66 Oct 2020 #23
massive powers are unleashed is a POTUS declares a state of national emergency Celerity Oct 2020 #62
Are you sure about a National mask mandate? MichMan Oct 2020 #60
China was able to stop the virus with measures treestar Oct 2020 #30
It will take time and the vaccine will hopefully come online Sherman A1 Oct 2020 #3
K&R, on number 9 ... Red Don wont go away and will have a floor of 5% kGOP followers per county uponit7771 Oct 2020 #4
I get what you're saying Proud Liberal Dem Oct 2020 #5
so, basically you are saying CatWoman Oct 2020 #6
no, I want to know what can be done Celerity Oct 2020 #11
So you are basically saying that in regards to SARS-COV-2, it doesn't matter Blue_true Oct 2020 #67
stop putting words in my mouth Celerity Oct 2020 #69
Your lead paragraph said exactly that in so many words. Blue_true Oct 2020 #71
no it did not, I simply listed out what he will be up against, & it's disingenuous to accuse me Celerity Oct 2020 #75
He will have tools for dealing with the people that you mentioned. Blue_true Oct 2020 #77
Is he wrong? durablend Oct 2020 #33
Agreed. The minute biden is sworn in, Volaris Oct 2020 #79
He can do a few things right away. Mike 03 Oct 2020 #8
thank you for the reply Celerity Oct 2020 #19
Also...the lying to the American people will stop. we can make better, more informed decisions wiggs Oct 2020 #56
With just three weeks of all Americans wearing masks, even without distancing, the number of Doodley Oct 2020 #9
Dad and I went to Walmart a few days ago phylny Oct 2020 #24
This. durablend Oct 2020 #37
Wow, could I ask what state your dad lives in njhoneybadger Oct 2020 #40
His permanent address is in New York (Westchester County) phylny Oct 2020 #45
A smart marketing/public info blitz would make more people embarrassed not to wear masks. Just Biden Doodley Oct 2020 #51
I can help somewhat (I mean it can't hurt) but sadly Trump has weaponized masks. Statistical Oct 2020 #58
I don't agree with that 30% figure. I live in Georgia, and even in Republican strongholds, few Doodley Oct 2020 #64
At 93 you're playing with house money anyway BannonsLiver Oct 2020 #57
Herd immunity a mix of natural (stupid) and vaccine. Statistical Oct 2020 #10
I agree with you 1000% genxlib Oct 2020 #13
thanks for that, but what if tens of millions still refuse, and they have enough local and state Celerity Oct 2020 #16
That will only be true until things start to get ugly genxlib Oct 2020 #29
I so hope you are right, and I suspect you might be Celerity Oct 2020 #39
I agree that Covid-19 will continue to be endemic in the US Klaralven Oct 2020 #15
I think we're going to see huge disparities among different areas of the country. enough Oct 2020 #17
honest question.. Can a state ban entrance from a hotspot state? Or impose a mandatory quarantine Celerity Oct 2020 #25
NY has tried to do that. babylonsister Oct 2020 #48
Biden can make it a national policy and FORCE states to comply or face loss of federal monies, not beachbumbob Oct 2020 #18
What if the vermin Rethug state leaders challenge it, ram it up the food chain to a now 6-3 Celerity Oct 2020 #42
Trump basically ignored Supreme Court ruling that he didn't like, or Blue_true Oct 2020 #72
Lots of things can change when the Rule of Law comes back to a Wild West town. PubliusEnigma Oct 2020 #21
I so hope so! Celerity Oct 2020 #26
For one thing...no one will be holding super spreader rallies Rice4VP Oct 2020 #22
Do we know that for sure? What if Trump immediately starts up a Rebellion 2021/Retake America 2024 Celerity Oct 2020 #31
Hopefully he'll be too busy babylonsister Oct 2020 #49
The problem is that MF45 FoxNewsSucks Oct 2020 #28
With all the misconceptions about it flying around, herd immunity is achievable through vaccination. beastie boy Oct 2020 #32
You're right! Biden can't STOP Covid... NewDayOranges Oct 2020 #34
Bingo. nt Blue_true Oct 2020 #73
One honest question genxlib Oct 2020 #35
I hesitate to answer for someone BannonsLiver Oct 2020 #50
I am American-born, London raised woman who now lives in Sweden for several years Celerity Oct 2020 #63
The USA has to build a system that meets our constraint. Blue_true Oct 2020 #76
Yes, and I have never once said or inferred that the US should copy Sweden, or Norway or Denmark Celerity Oct 2020 #78
One thing is certain Chainfire Oct 2020 #36
Maybe so maybe not TexasProgresive Oct 2020 #38
As has been said on DU previously, Bayard Oct 2020 #41
+1 Celerity Oct 2020 #43
Well, we get tagged with it anyway, sooo MyNameGoesHere Oct 2020 #44
I prefer the term "empathy gulag" BannonsLiver Oct 2020 #52
Here's what you're missing: MineralMan Oct 2020 #46
Sorry for the misspell on martial, and I just got back online, we had a Celerity Oct 2020 #59
Not sure about the best way to get people on board to help get slow down Covid. But bluestarone Oct 2020 #47
There are some things he can do which have been mentioned BannonsLiver Oct 2020 #53
There are several ways Hestia Oct 2020 #54
The most important thing that President Biden can do is be a strong leader. marie999 Oct 2020 #61
There is plenty he can do Meowmee Oct 2020 #65
The big issue now is a total lack of federal coordination. Just by Blue_true Oct 2020 #66
Martial law? Do you not want Biden to make it past his first year? Initech Oct 2020 #68
what you just said is what I said, so many skipped the part following it Celerity Oct 2020 #70
Only a vaccine will end COVID Calculating Oct 2020 #80
Even my fellow Ohio dummies usually wear masks... Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2020 #81

FoxNewsSucks

(10,429 posts)
20. I agree, but that's not a realistic amount
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:44 AM
Oct 2020

I posted before, treat mask-wearing like a speed trap. $75-100 ticket for failing to wear a mask in public buildings, or in certain outdoor occasions. Lots of money for the city/county/state and incentive for governments to send their cops out to fill the ticket books.

Then, put it on their record. Let health insurance companies access those convictions and jack up their rates just like car insurance companies do.

Speeding tickets are a huge profitable racket for the government and a cash cow for insurance companies.

Use the same model for compliance with disease guidelines. The only difference is that this would actually be to the public benefit, not just the coffers of government and insurance.

treestar

(82,383 posts)
27. good idea but then it makes more police/citizen direct contact
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:49 AM
Oct 2020

not like stopping a car. Some of those idiots will make a show out of the encounter and of course the cops vs. right wingers can be disastrous too, as the white right wingers are more likely to be sovereign citizens or libertarians who think their rights are being violated.

BannonsLiver

(16,387 posts)
55. The fine in my city is $9
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 11:04 AM
Oct 2020

Which is of course ludicrous. The amount is low because some feared it would disproportionately impact low income communities if it were higher. That’s of course dumb given that literally every other citation-fine is not based on who can afford it and who can’t. A parking ticket is $25 whether you’re in a ‘99 Cavalier or a Mercedes.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
74. Biden can withhold certain federal funds from states that are not making an effort.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:04 PM
Oct 2020

That likely stands up in Court, if well targeted. He can even use examples of what Courts allowed Trump to do, and ignore any politicized ruling after that. All those things would be easier than fining an individual.

Solomon

(12,310 posts)
2. Jeez-zuz! Calm down. Surely you did not mention martial law!? No, I must have read that wrong.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:29 AM
Oct 2020

Really. Get a grip. Please.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
14. well if not martial law (obviously the final last resort if states simply flat out refuse to obey)
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:39 AM
Oct 2020

then nationwide orders or whatever it would be called. Just using all that as examples of possible things in the toolkit.

GulfCoast66

(11,949 posts)
23. How well do you know the US system?
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:46 AM
Oct 2020

There is no mechanism for a US president to declare Martial law nor to issue a mask mandate.

The states have more power in this area.

No one can ‘stop’ the virus. But we could do much more to mitigate its economic damage to average Americans.

And have a president who does not give advice counter to science would go a long way toward getting more people to take better precautions.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
62. massive powers are unleashed is a POTUS declares a state of national emergency
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 12:04 PM
Oct 2020

That said, martial law was probably not the best subject to toss out in the OP, as it is such a loaded term.

This article was directed at things to worry about with Trump, but is applicable to any POTUS.

The Alarming Scope of the President's Emergency Powers



https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/01/presidential-emergency-powers/576418/

snip

But will they? Unknown to most Americans, a parallel legal regime allows the president to sidestep many of the constraints that normally apply. The moment the president declares a “national emergency”—a decision that is entirely within his discretion—more than 100 special provisions become available to him. While many of these tee up reasonable responses to genuine emergencies, some appear dangerously suited to a leader bent on amassing or retaining power. For instance, the president can, with the flick of his pen, activate laws allowing him to shut down many kinds of electronic communications inside the United States or freeze Americans’ bank accounts.

Other powers are available even without a declaration of emergency, including laws that allow the president to deploy troops inside the country to subdue domestic unrest. This edifice of extraordinary powers has historically rested on the assumption that the president will act in the country’s best interest when using them. With a handful of noteworthy exceptions, this assumption has held up. But what if a president, backed into a corner and facing electoral defeat or impeachment, were to declare an emergency for the sake of holding on to power? In that scenario, our laws and institutions might not save us from a presidential power grab. They might be what takes us down.

1. “A LOADED WEAPON”

The premise underlying emergency powers is simple: The government’s ordinary powers might be insufficient in a crisis, and amending the law to provide greater ones might be too slow and cumbersome. Emergency powers are meant to give the government a temporary boost until the emergency passes or there is time to change the law through normal legislative processes. Unlike the modern constitutions of many other countries, which specify when and how a state of emergency may be declared and which rights may be suspended, the U.S. Constitution itself includes no comprehensive separate regime for emergencies. Those few powers it does contain for dealing with certain urgent threats, it assigns to Congress, not the president. For instance, it lets Congress suspend the writ of habeas corpus—that is, allow government officials to imprison people without judicial review—“when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it” and “provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions.”

Nonetheless, some legal scholars believe that the Constitution gives the president inherent emergency powers by making him commander in chief of the armed forces, or by vesting in him a broad, undefined “executive Power.” At key points in American history, presidents have cited inherent constitutional powers when taking drastic actions that were not authorized—or, in some cases, were explicitly prohibited—by Congress. Notorious examples include Franklin D. Roosevelt’s internment of U.S. citizens and residents of Japanese descent during World War II and George W. Bush’s programs of warrantless wiretapping and torture after the 9/11 terrorist attacks. Abraham Lincoln conceded that his unilateral suspension of habeas corpus during the Civil War was constitutionally questionable, but defended it as necessary to preserve the Union. The Supreme Court has often upheld such actions or found ways to avoid reviewing them, at least while the crisis was in progress. Rulings such as Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company v. Sawyer, in which the Court invalidated President Harry Truman’s bid to take over steel mills during the Korean War, have been the exception. And while those exceptions have outlined important limiting principles, the outer boundary of the president’s constitutional authority during emergencies remains poorly defined.

snip

MichMan

(11,924 posts)
60. Are you sure about a National mask mandate?
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 11:47 AM
Oct 2020

There are commercials running for weeks of Joe saying he will issue a mandatory mask mandate on day 1 of his presidency.

treestar

(82,383 posts)
30. China was able to stop the virus with measures
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:50 AM
Oct 2020

that would never fly in the US. So I kind of get it. We have to put up with it. People won't put up with government coming to their houses to take their temperature. It's unconstitutional most likely.

Sherman A1

(38,958 posts)
3. It will take time and the vaccine will hopefully come online
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:29 AM
Oct 2020

sooner rather than later, but we still have at least another year or so before this part of the overall mess will abate. Things will get better but it will be a bumpy ride for particularly the immediate term and then hopefully we start to see some light on the horizon.

uponit7771

(90,336 posts)
4. K&R, on number 9 ... Red Don wont go away and will have a floor of 5% kGOP followers per county
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:29 AM
Oct 2020

... and he will rule the kGOP while out of office

Proud Liberal Dem

(24,412 posts)
5. I get what you're saying
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:31 AM
Oct 2020

I think (or hope) that having better and more responsible leadership at the top whom won't play favoritism with helping states and communicating a clear and consistent message on a daily basis with full transparency will eventually persuade most people to do what they need to do to start taking COVID more seriously. People will (hopefully) eventually just get sick of "living with COVID" and once a vaccine is released and people start getting innoculated that should help start to stem and slow the rate of infection. I would assume that Biden would re-establish some of the pandemic response teams and programs that Trump eliminated in 2018 to assist as well. It's going to be a hard long slog towards an end because of the recklessness and irresponsibility of Trump but I don't think it's a hopeless effort.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
67. So you are basically saying that in regards to SARS-COV-2, it doesn't matter
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 08:44 PM
Oct 2020

who is in office. That is a massive fallacy.

Biden would protect healthcare and frontline workers by getting them adequate PPE, that alone will prevent primary and secondary (people taking it to their families) infections. Biden can withhold federal funds from states that are not making a baseline attempt to control the virus. He could do like Australia and Germany, do focused lockdowns - so the governor of South Dakota doesn’t see a need to fight the virus, then hot spots in South Dakota get locked down and US Marshals get sent in to monitor adherence. In the better performing areas of Europe vis a vis SARS-COV-2, a mere statement from the federal level that an area will be locked down until x-date if it doesn’t get it’s shit together is enough for officials in those places to get their asses on the stick and make an effort to slow infections.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
69. stop putting words in my mouth
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 08:46 PM
Oct 2020
So you are basically saying that in regards to SARS-COV-2, it doesn't matter who is in office.


I NEVER said that

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
71. Your lead paragraph said exactly that in so many words.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 08:53 PM
Oct 2020

The fact is, there is a massive amount of impact that a real President can have, from Day 1.

This is the largest crisis of the last 50 years, nothing else comes close. We need a leader to tackle this crisis, not a divisive fool that is only interested in sowing more division.

From Day 1, like I said, Biden can meet with all the governors, lay out a plan with metrics that need to be met and explain that any location not meeting those metrics will be locked down.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
75. no it did not, I simply listed out what he will be up against, & it's disingenuous to accuse me
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:07 PM
Oct 2020

of saying or inferring there would be no difference between Biden and Trump when it comes to dealing with COVID. Biden obviously will try his absolute level best to stop it. I just think there is going to be crazy resistance from the RW QAnon and MAGAt types, as well as many Rethug elected POS.



Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
77. He will have tools for dealing with the people that you mentioned.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:22 PM
Oct 2020

Doing actions like getting adequate PPE to healthcare workers will prove to be a critical gain, IMO. Providing funds to schools so that they can immediately reduce class size and spread students out also should be highly beneficial.

Volaris

(10,271 posts)
79. Agreed. The minute biden is sworn in,
Thu Oct 22, 2020, 01:13 AM
Oct 2020

these twats will turn themselves into the Zombie Tea Party, and screech like cut harpies about the national debt, unfunded mandates (remember that one?), and the general state of utter oppression they must suffer because the president of the united states happens to be Not A Complete Fucking Idiot.

It will take 3 months to metastasize in the dark corners of the web, and as soon as its warm out again, they'll be out on the streets making a nuisance of themselves, and comparing their plight BLM.

they're nothing if not predictable.

Mike 03

(16,616 posts)
8. He can do a few things right away.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:33 AM
Oct 2020

Authorize companies to mass produce N95 masks and PPE, which are still shamefully difficult to get.
He can roll out much more widespread and accurate testing.
He can institute serious contact tracing.

Prices will drop on all of the above because FEMA will no longer be hoarding this stuff and giving it back to corporations to resell at ridiculous prices. There won't be bidding wars between states for precious medical supplies.

If he would just do those things at least those of us who want to do the right thing can improve our chances.

If we can regain the Senate, Biden can implement immediate and targeted COVID relief packages and better stimulus program.

He could go further with mask mandates and lockdowns.

Also we'll have the CDC back in the driver's seat and Joe will allow scientists to directly speak to the public, not through the filter of quacks like Scott Atlas and the My Pillow Guy.

Trust will be regained in the vaccine process, because under Biden/Harris the FDA will not be under political pressure to rush out a junk vaccine.

A lot is possible!

wiggs

(7,813 posts)
56. Also...the lying to the American people will stop. we can make better, more informed decisions
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 11:04 AM
Oct 2020

individually and well as with respect to public policy.

Don't know why Biden doesn't start every answer to every question with that...' well, for one thing, I won't be lying to the American people multiple times per day.'

Doodley

(9,089 posts)
9. With just three weeks of all Americans wearing masks, even without distancing, the number of
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:36 AM
Oct 2020

new cases would be in the thousands, rather than the tens of thousands, but it takes all Americans to work together, to save lives and to save the American economy. This is a mission more important than landing man on the moon, but we can do it, if we all have each other's backs. Other nations have achieved it, and so can we.

This should be the message, with a marketing/public education campaign in the hundreds of millions of dollars, with very simple to understand graphics and videos and the scientists at the center, led by Joe Biden.

Also, if Biden wins and gets. say 52% of the vote, you can expect him to have a honeymoon with voters, maybe giving him approval in the 60s. He needs to hit the ground running, and use that goodwill by being a strong leader.

phylny

(8,380 posts)
24. Dad and I went to Walmart a few days ago
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:46 AM
Oct 2020

He's 93 - I know, I know, he's old and frail, but he just wants to live his life.

We wear masks, wash our hands, and socially distance. We saw about 10 people (in a not-too-crowded Walmart) who weren't wearing masks. One smart-ass guy was HOLDING his "TRUMP 2020" mask.

People are not willing to work together. It's disheartening.

durablend

(7,460 posts)
37. This.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:56 AM
Oct 2020

"People are not willing to work together. It's disheartening."


Those of you saying "Oh we'll just (figuratively) hold hands, and everyone will wear a mask and so and so" aren't based in reality. And those fighting the mask/social distancing requirements damn well aren't going to listen to what they consider to be an "illegitimate president" no matter how you wish it so.

njhoneybadger

(3,910 posts)
40. Wow, could I ask what state your dad lives in
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:01 AM
Oct 2020

I live in northern New Jersey which is tRump country. I have never seen anyone not wearing a mask in a store or heard anyone complaining about it.

phylny

(8,380 posts)
45. His permanent address is in New York (Westchester County)
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:12 AM
Oct 2020

He's with us in Virginia Trump country. Locally, most people are wearing a mask, but 30 minutes away, not everyone is. It's disheartening.

Doodley

(9,089 posts)
51. A smart marketing/public info blitz would make more people embarrassed not to wear masks. Just Biden
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:56 AM
Oct 2020

being elected would make mask-wearing more prevalent. Having a president that actually leads and says we all need to wear masks would make a difference.

Statistical

(19,264 posts)
58. I can help somewhat (I mean it can't hurt) but sadly Trump has weaponized masks.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 11:08 AM
Oct 2020

He turned it into a political wedge issue and then doubled down with "alternative facts". At this point I would say a good 30%+ of the population won't wear a mask under any circumstances unless forced by law and even then would try to undermine the effort (down under nose, masks with valves, etc).

All this is simple and easy. Every other first world nation has made progress. It isn't rocket science or requiring some herculean sacrifice.

Doodley

(9,089 posts)
64. I don't agree with that 30% figure. I live in Georgia, and even in Republican strongholds, few
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 07:42 PM
Oct 2020

don't wear masks in supermarkets. We need a leader who will make the best case for masks in very simple language and create an environment where it is considered socially unacceptable, unpatriotic, or embarrassing not to wear masks. Hardline attitudes about smoking have changed. The same can be done about masks, but we need smart leadership.

Statistical

(19,264 posts)
10. Herd immunity a mix of natural (stupid) and vaccine.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:36 AM
Oct 2020

Your right. Trump has poisoned the well. He could have come out strongly for social distancing and masks (be a patriot wear a mask) but he didn't and nothing will change the mind of Trumpers now. Red States are unlikely to put in any serious enforcement.

So we are left with the gruesome reality that it will be herd immunity by a combination of vaccine and natural exposure. All we can do is try to reduce the case counts in states with sane governance so it ends up more by vaccine and less by natural exposure but nationally a significant portion of it will be bought with death and suffering.

genxlib

(5,526 posts)
13. I agree with you 1000%
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:37 AM
Oct 2020

But I see one advancement that will turn the corner.

Widespread, accurate, cheap and quick testing. Not waiting in line for a brain enema that takes a week for results. But quick nasal swabs or spit tests that give you an answer in minutes. It is a game changer for anyone who wants to open work places, hold events, play sports, crowded dining, full theaters, etc.

Just as an example, my daughter is a Freshman at Ohio State. They do weekly spit tests of every single staff and student. A lot of ink was spilled in outrage when they had an outbreak affecting several thousands of kids when they first got to campus. But what we have not heard reported is that they have it fairly well under control. Their positivity rate has fallen to under 1% after initially being in the teens. They publish all of their stats here https://safeandhealthy.osu.edu/dashboard

If a bunch of kids in tight quarters can do it, we can to. The testing can make all the difference.

I thought this was a fascinating and helpful article.

https://www.vox.com/2020/8/27/21374002/rapid-covid-19-test-3m-abbott

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
16. thanks for that, but what if tens of millions still refuse, and they have enough local and state
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:42 AM
Oct 2020

legal backing to keep them from complying?

The whole thing, due to Trump and others, is insanely politicised now.

genxlib

(5,526 posts)
29. That will only be true until things start to get ugly
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:49 AM
Oct 2020

My suspicion is that the current increase we see will be an inferno by the end of the year. I think the doubters will get a reality check when they start to see overflowing morgues and stacked body bags again.

By the time of the inauguration, I suspect that the Country will be more inclined to play ball. Especially if it can be done as part of a cautiously open economy. One of the reasons that Ohio State has been successful is that they are still doing a lot of protective measures on top of the testing. And they are doing it with the threat of closing the campus and sending everyone home. There is an underlying incentive that in order to participate in even this partial opening, then you have to play by the rules.

 

Klaralven

(7,510 posts)
15. I agree that Covid-19 will continue to be endemic in the US
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:40 AM
Oct 2020

However, vaccines will limit cases among those who want to be protected. Antibody therapeutics will limit the severity of disease among those who aren't protected by vaccines.

International travel by Americans will continue to be limited and subject to quarantines. But the permanent suppression of international travel is a good thing because that makes us less vulnerable to the next pandemic.

enough

(13,259 posts)
17. I think we're going to see huge disparities among different areas of the country.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:42 AM
Oct 2020

Certain areas will coordinate and cooperate with an improved national system for dealing with the disease. Other areas will not.

It’s going to take a long time.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
25. honest question.. Can a state ban entrance from a hotspot state? Or impose a mandatory quarantine
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:47 AM
Oct 2020

on people coming from a hotspot, and/or COVID-19 mitigation rebellion state?

babylonsister

(171,065 posts)
48. NY has tried to do that.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:38 AM
Oct 2020

The problem is trusting people will self-quarantine imo. I'm sure many don't.

 

beachbumbob

(9,263 posts)
18. Biden can make it a national policy and FORCE states to comply or face loss of federal monies, not
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:43 AM
Oct 2020

that difficult to do.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
42. What if the vermin Rethug state leaders challenge it, ram it up the food chain to a now 6-3
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:03 AM
Oct 2020

hardcore RW stacked SCOTUS and they tell Biden to GTFO?

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
72. Trump basically ignored Supreme Court ruling that he didn't like, or
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 08:58 PM
Oct 2020

worked around them. One president ignored the Supreme Court and carried out forced removals on American Indians from their ancestral lands. The only question is will Biden use workarounds like with-holding certain funds to recalcitrant states.

Rice4VP

(1,235 posts)
22. For one thing...no one will be holding super spreader rallies
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:45 AM
Oct 2020

The Trumpanzees might protest in the streets and since it will be winter, the rest of us will be at home or work staying safe

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
31. Do we know that for sure? What if Trump immediately starts up a Rebellion 2021/Retake America 2024
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:51 AM
Oct 2020

Tour? Tens of millions of shell-shocked, enraged white nationalist MAGAts will be out there post election, floating about in the aether, looking for a piece of hateful driftwood to latch on to.

FoxNewsSucks

(10,429 posts)
28. The problem is that MF45
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:49 AM
Oct 2020

and the republicons seem to be determined to get as many people infected as possible, and as many stupid morons to refuse to cooperate as possible. They know they're losing, and just want to do as much damage as possible.

That's true, but as pointed out above there are a few things that Biden can and will do which will help. There will still be the problem of morons who run out to spread it because they are incited by talking heads on OAN and Fox (who are ALL broadcasting from the safety of their basements).

I made a suggestion in post #20. Give government entities and insurance companies an excuse to profit from the ignorance and non-compliance.

beastie boy

(9,342 posts)
32. With all the misconceptions about it flying around, herd immunity is achievable through vaccination.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:53 AM
Oct 2020

Even if only half of US population is participating. The short term goal is not to eliminate the virus, but stop its spread. This is very achievable. After that, as sporadic outbreaks here and there are controlled, it is possible to contain the impact of the virus to a minimum, effectively reducing the effects of the virus to below the level of an epidemic. It is very unlikely that the virus will completely go away, not even under the best of circumstances.

NewDayOranges

(692 posts)
34. You're right! Biden can't STOP Covid...
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:53 AM
Oct 2020

But he won't mock people who take common sense steps to avoid spreading or getting the virus.

Biden can increase the production of PPE so that frontline caregivers can provide healthcare with less risk.

Biden can stop undermining and tweet-attacking Governors that decide to enact social distancing safety measures.

Biden may be able to persuade anti-science Republican Governors like De Santis, Abbot, Roem and Parsons to encourage mask-wearing and other healthy policies...

genxlib

(5,526 posts)
35. One honest question
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:53 AM
Oct 2020

If i remember correctly, you are Swedish correct?

It seems like I recall you writing an OP about how Sweden did pretty well with leaving the economy open.

How do you square that position with the above noted concerns?

I have to tell you that Sweden has been a thorn in my side whenever I try and talk common sense to my stubborn friends. They are constantly throwing it out as an example that we are doing it wrong.

BannonsLiver

(16,387 posts)
50. I hesitate to answer for someone
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:46 AM
Oct 2020

But having read a number of the OPs posts on the virus in the last 7 months I think they’ve been pretty critical of the Swedish response strategy. And yes, totally agree on that pain in the ass part. Have experienced the same with other people.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
63. I am American-born, London raised woman who now lives in Sweden for several years
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 12:46 PM
Oct 2020

I am half Swedish and half Bajan (Barbados)

I have written extensively, in great detail, for well over half a year on Sweden.

Sweden and the RW US framings of COVID are massively different, and there has been an insane amount of disinfo about Sweden pushed out there by so many sides (still is, especially on MSNBC, CNN, and even Fux news, albeit Fux spins it 180-degree opposite) , trying to us us as an example of why they are right and their opponents are wrong.

I will try to summarise quickly and not write pages. I can, if pressed, provide mountains of documentation to back up what I shall say.

1. Sweden NEVER had herd immunity as it goal to deal with COVID-19. This is the biggest disinfo angle shot out there in the US press, and I have debunked it so many times.

2. Sweden has a different level of government power versus the other Nordics in (and most all other Western nations) terms of what can be ordered by our government, The health authorities have far more legal control, barring new sets of laws passed (some have been, but were not in place when the peak was hitting).

3. Sweden's main tragedy with COVID-19 came from our elderly care system, which is run differently than the other Nordics. t is far more open, and far less professionally-staffed (a recent development due to brain drain from us to Denmark, Norway, Finland, Germany, etc). The workers we now have are far less competent and les trained when taken as a whole. The % of staffing by immigrants and refugees is vastly higher, as is our overall % of population, compared to the other Nordics. The immigrant/refugee populations here were the other main group devastated by COVID-19 (due to sociological and economic issues, especially crowed living arrangement and almost no history of innate social distancing, something Swedes natural do anyway, plus natives and multi generation immigrant Swedes live alone at vastly higher rates). Our numbers were inflated by the sheer higher %'s of impacted groups as well.

4. ALL the other Nordics, not just Sweden, for close to 5, 6 months, said do not wear masks. Norway and Denmark especially (they have changed a bit now, for trains, etc). This is almost never brought up, only Sweden is taken to the woodshed, as we had so many more deaths, again due to elderly and the immigrant sectors that I have documented so many times They did lockdown for a bit near the beginning, and we did not fully (there were and are many restrictions here, another myth is that we were wild west wide open, which is just patently untrue) lockdown. I do wish we had done the lockdown like Norway did.

5.Sweden is vastly more socially-distanced than the RW is in the US. That is a natural social thing here. The main groups who are not are the two that were ravaged (the elderly and the immigrant refugees groups). The RW in the US are disingenuous rotters when they try and say we are like them. we are NOTHING like them. We also are FAR more healthy in terms of most all age groups, especially the 50, 60 year olds and under cohorts. That is why our death count is so so low in the the younger (under 60 years of age) groups.

6. Our level of infection per million is actually fairly low, 48th (and dropping) in the world. Our death rate per million is now 16th, and dropping. Notice the huge difference. We have a huge percentage of deaths becuase it was so so high a percentage of infections in the oldest sectors, the ones most likely to die. It was mostly all front loaded, and has been vastly lowered. I saw an ex CDC head all other lying and saying we were still the worst in the EU and exploding. this was just a couple days ago, and it is a flat out lie.

7. The bottom half (over 5 million people) of our population has had to date, only 31 deaths total. That is for the entire under 40yo population. Zero schoolchildren's have died, only 2 under 20yo have died, a 4 yo and a 1 year old, both with massive comorbidity. This is despite the schools under high school (and some high schools) remaining open the whole time. 99% of all deaths have come from people 50 and older, 96% were 60yo and over over 60yo, 89% of all deaths were 70 years of age and older.

8. As for our economy, we did better than almost all of the EU in Q1, better than many in Q2 (again there was a tonne of disinfo initially sloshed around out there based off a faulty flash estimate from earlier), but still took a large hit, and will continue to take hits, although in 2021 we should recover a lot. We are extremely export-driven, with manufacturing making up a high percentage of that, so the global supply change seizing up hurt us, as did decreased demands for out exports. Our internal consumption was more robust.

https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/









front loaded deaths, vastly reduced rate of death now (due to our incredibly poor handing of the lederly care homes and scattered site housing)

https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/09f821667ce64bf7be6f9f87457ed9aa



last double digit death day was over 3 months ago (11 deaths on July 18th)




deaths were are are massively skewed to the oldest sectors



Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
76. The USA has to build a system that meets our constraint.
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:17 PM
Oct 2020

We have one of the least healthy populations in the world. What Sweden does won’t work for us. Mask wearing must be central to our effort, along with accurate, rapid testing and quarantining. We need to test people that enter the country from outside the country and quarantine anyone that is sick and sequentially test anyone that has been exposed to a person that tests as sick at an entry airport, that is about what New Zealand does.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
78. Yes, and I have never once said or inferred that the US should copy Sweden, or Norway or Denmark
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:27 PM
Oct 2020

when it comes to COVID-19. In fact I said in that reply we are not at all like the US, on a number of levels.

The Trumpian RW and their penumbras of malice are wilfully trying to spread it, which is all in line with their death cult mentality.

Chainfire

(17,538 posts)
36. One thing is certain
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:53 AM
Oct 2020

By the evening of the inauguration, Republicans will want to know why Covid has not been defeated yet.

The time to deal with the disease was before it spread to every community in the country.

TexasProgresive

(12,157 posts)
38. Maybe so maybe not
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 09:57 AM
Oct 2020

I live in a very red Texas county. I was in town yesterday to the feed store and shudder Walmart. Everyone was in masks and maintaining distance even a couple, he in a mask emblazoned with TRUMP and her in a TRUMP PENCE tee shirt. They didn’t look happy about it, but there you go.

Bayard

(22,069 posts)
41. As has been said on DU previously,
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:02 AM
Oct 2020

"A mask is not a political statement. Its an IQ test".

Make wearing a mask the smart thing to do. Make it the PATRIOTIC thing to do.

I think escalating fines are a good idea for non-compliance. Big fine if you insist on having a party, jail time if you have a second one. Same penalty for companies that don't comply--at the top, not the workers on the job being forced to follow orders or lose their jobs.

Insist/encourage states to have testing checkpoints at their borders. Law officers who refuse to enforce laws are fired. No second chances.

There are pretty strict laws about insurrection. Enforce them at ALL levels.

MineralMan

(146,308 posts)
46. Here's what you're missing:
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:12 AM
Oct 2020

1. This is a new virus that has had no vaccines created for it in the past. Unlike the flu, we started from scratch with the COVID-19 virus. There will be vaccines. Multiple vaccines. Some will be more effective than others, but a good working vaccine will become available next year. That has nothing to do with Trump or Biden. The work continues, either way.

2. People, in general, are getting better about wearing masks and social distancing. I have observed that in my own area, where the numbers of unmasked people in public places have gone way, way down in the past three months.

3. Nobody is going to declare martial, or "marital" law, as you put it. That's not going to happen. However, Joe Biden will encourage the creation of solid mask laws in our states. The citizens of each state will also have to encourage their own states to pass such laws.

4. With Biden as President, science will take the lead on the pandemic, instead of one person's whims. That is going to make a big difference. The "bully pulpit" actually does matter. It matters a good deal.

5. COVID-19 is still a very serious threat. Treatments are improving, though, as we better understand the details of how it affects the human body. Also research that has been going on is showing results, finally, with regard to treatment.

6. In 2021, we will begin to see the pandemic numbers go down. By the end of the year, they will be way down, in fact.

You're frustrated. So am I. But, electing Joe Biden will get things moving in the right direction with regard to the pandemic, as well as in many other areas. So, be worried about the pandemic, but not pessimistic in the long term. Over time, we will conquer this thing. Biden will help make that happen sooner.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
59. Sorry for the misspell on martial, and I just got back online, we had a
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 11:43 AM
Oct 2020

huge power cut that affected 50K or so people here in Södermalm (Stockholm), so I couldn't correct it until now.

Your other points are valid and thank you for them.

bluestarone

(16,940 posts)
47. Not sure about the best way to get people on board to help get slow down Covid. But
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 10:13 AM
Oct 2020

I feel insurance coverage or NO insurance coverage could have something to do about it. I don't know how but i would like to see medical insurance CO. speak of NO MASK?, then NO COVERAGE. Something like this. (probably impossible, i know)

BannonsLiver

(16,387 posts)
53. There are some things he can do which have been mentioned
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 11:01 AM
Oct 2020

There’s also the possibility of playing hardball with governors.

“Oh you want/need that federal money for (fill in the blank)? How about a mask mandate with teeth?”

Imo anything should be on the table.

 

Hestia

(3,818 posts)
54. There are several ways
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 11:03 AM
Oct 2020

1 - Wave a flag to get their attention - "Squirrel!"

Deep data dives and tuff love will become our friends here:

2 - Fully Fund and Staff the Public Health Corp (or the corp where a fully competent Surgeon General comes from) and give them back the Quarantine powers they used for tuberculosis and other health outbreaks. These are Federal Employees that take an Oath to the US.

Have them go door to door, neighborhood by neighborhood. Yes, it will take awhile, but these will be workers who are from your area or town - they will know the who, what, wherefores. Do deep dive background checks of all workers. Take mental health workers, social workers and other team members at the same time:

a) Along with testing, have a questionnaire for other healthcare needs - senior care, difficulty in paying for medications they need
today, child abuse, childcare assistance, hoarding, rental assistance, Medicaid sign up assistance, Section 8 or HUD sign up
assistance (whatever it is called), addiction rehab, sanitation, etc.

b) Dwelling assistance - fully insured and bonded public employee building inspectors to inspect dwellings for either weather
rehab, foundation rehab, roof rehab, plumbing inspectors, tree surgeons, etc. Condemn if necessary.

A. Shore up and fully fund Building Trade Apprentice Programs and as part of their education and licensing hours, team
members will be educated and recruited from these programs.

B. Recruit from Master Gardener, Local Farms, etc. and have them scope out the best spots for neighborhood garden/farm (whatever) and train/assist with neighborhoods to grow their own food. Build Community Open Air spots where playgrounds and homework/tutoring spots can be set up so neighborhood adults can keep an eye on their children while working in garden/farm spots.

C. Keep and shore up water/sewer lines so they can be used for gardens & Open Air Areas, along with sanitation needs.

D. Hire fully insured and bonded security guards from an Law Enforcement type Apprentice Program for those who are interested in this type of work/future employment, leading to Neighborhood Enforcement and the children will know who they can actually trust when something happens instead of complete strangers. Have them keep watch over tools and equipment and safety.

E. Quarantine Powers - details for each area tba

3 - Andrew Cuomo laid it out this past weekend. NYC will be tracing on the micro level to track & trace. It is how Taiwan, Vietnam, et al are keeping/have kept their rates to practically nil.
===

Everything is Connected. People will know that someone cares about their needs and won't feel so isolated, what their needs are for their neighborhoods, and job and training opportunities for those who want or need them and actual knowledge of what is needed in one fell swoop instead of a study here, a study there, etc. Get it all at one time so we can all see what is needed now. Details can be worked out in working groups.

Keep the freakin' corporations and lobbyists out of it. If a company wants to sell, say building supplies, they are going to have to have an actual bid like everyone else and be fully insured and bonded and have paid their taxes and have their bank accounts investigated. What good will it do to have a someone win a bid but not have the funding source to fulfill the contracts.

Fund and Staff Procurement Programs. Personally, I loved working in Procurement. Not everyone is cut out for it, so put those who are in those positions. We need to quit trying to force square pegs into round holes.

===

Paid Training Programs will have an immediate impact on the local economy, give people opportunities they would not otherwise have and being a State and/or Federal Employee the benefits they wouldn't otherwise have, along with the expectations of being said employee. Sorry, but being expected to show up and show up on time is not an "entitlement" thing, it's respect for your fellow team members so you/y'all can get your work done. This is not fast food, it is helping your local economy and give people a sense of accomplishment that they are actually doing some great work helping in their local areas.

===

I could go on and on and on...but really, all the above are connected and have these disparate programs not working together and training the next generation have gotten us to the bureaucracy we have today.

I haven't proofread so take it as you will. I think you will get the jist

Meowmee

(5,164 posts)
65. There is plenty he can do
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 08:26 PM
Oct 2020

All of the things dump has not done. A federal plan which unifies and helps states instead of pitting them against each other, free testing everywhere, high quality masks available to everyone, some sort of mask mandate in every state and every establishment, no in person schooling, work from home whenever possible. Economic aid for everyone who needs it.

I am sure there is a lot more... once a vaccine is available, a requirement at schools and places of employment that people have to be vaccinated to attend etc. It is not going to be easy because of the initial lack of response and the lies etc. which allowed it to spread to the level it has and because there are a lot of idiots here who refuse to follow simple and easy guidelines. But eventually it will get better and hopefully without many more people dying.

Herd immunity is basically mass murder and is not a solution of any sort. Even viruses and many diseases perhaps that did not mutate were mainly controlled with a vaccine. Since this seems to be more like an influenza virus in terms of the fact that it mutates and will most likely come back every season, a vaccine is the main thing that will stop it so to speak, or at least get it to a very low occurrence even with less than 100% compliance.

I don't think all red or red purple areas are in full rebellion, some people have the good sense to realize their lives are on the line. My county is quite conservative but each time I have ventured out, everyone is masked and is complying with whatever stores require to be there. 99% of people who have come to our home to do work have been masked. Having a decent person in charge, who actually gives a damn and who leads by example is going to make a big difference as well.

In any case the thing to concentrate on now is winning the election.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
66. The big issue now is a total lack of federal coordination. Just by
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 08:34 PM
Oct 2020

bringing that into play, Biden will have an enormous positive impact.

Initech

(100,075 posts)
68. Martial law? Do you not want Biden to make it past his first year?
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 08:46 PM
Oct 2020

Because that's how Biden doesn't make it past his first year. The mere mention of it would cause conservatives to go apeshit. Like seriously rabid levels of apeshit crazy.

Celerity

(43,357 posts)
70. what you just said is what I said, so many skipped the part following it
Wed Oct 21, 2020, 08:50 PM
Oct 2020
Nationwide martial law? That will cause insane violence and resistance, and there just isn't enough enforcement personnel in terms of raw numbers.

Calculating

(2,955 posts)
80. Only a vaccine will end COVID
Thu Oct 22, 2020, 01:50 AM
Oct 2020

Or at least mitigate it enough that we can return to some semblance of normal life.

Buckeye_Democrat

(14,853 posts)
81. Even my fellow Ohio dummies usually wear masks...
Thu Oct 22, 2020, 02:53 AM
Oct 2020

... after Gov. DeWine finally announced a statewide mask mandate.

I never imagined the mandate would make much of a difference, considering the hostility that I saw when I was in the extreme minority of mask-wearers here, but it did.


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I do not see how, even wi...