General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNYT Krugman "The Republican Economic Plan is an Insult"
(SING IT OUT LOUD, Paul!)
Its bad faith in the name of bipartisanship.
By Paul Krugman
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/01/opinion/coronavirus-relief-biden-republicans.html
(I am going to pick out four key paragraphs)
snip
Republicans, however, want to rip the guts out of this plan. They are seeking to reduce extra aid to the unemployed and, more important, cut that aid off in June long before we can possibly get back to full employment. They want to eliminate hundreds of billions in aid to state and local governments. They want to eliminate aid for children. And so on. This isnt an offer of compromise; its a demand for near-total surrender. And the consequences would be devastating if Democrats were to give in. But what about bipartisanship? As Biden might say, Cmon, man.
snip
First of all, a party doesnt get to demand bipartisanship when many of its representatives still wont acknowledge that Biden won legitimately, and even those who eventually acknowledged the Biden victory spent weeks humoring baseless claims of a stolen election. Complaints that it would be divisive for Democrats to pass a relief bill on a party-line vote, using reconciliation to bypass the filibuster, are also pretty rich coming from a party that did exactly that in 2017, when it enacted a large tax cut legislation that, unlike pandemic relief, wasnt a response to any obvious crisis, but was simply part of a conservative wish list.
Oh, and that tax cut was rammed through in the face of broad public opposition: Only 29 percent of Americans approved of the bill, while 56 percent disapproved. By contrast, the main provisions of the Biden plan are very popular: 79 percent of the public approve of new stimulus checks, and 69 percent approve of both expanded unemployment benefits and aid to state and local governments.
snip
In short, everything about this Republican counteroffer reeks of bad faith the same kind of bad faith the G.O.P. displayed in 2009 when it tried to block President Barack Obamas efforts to rescue the economy after the 2008 financial crisis. Obama, unfortunately, failed to grasp the nature of his opposition and watered down his policies in a vain attempt to win support across the aisle. This time, it seems as if Democrats understand what Lucy will do with that football and wont be fooled again. So its OK for Biden to talk with Republicans and hear them out. But should he make any substantive concessions in an attempt to win them over? Should he let negotiations with Republicans delay the passage of his rescue plan? Absolutely not. Just get it done.
JustAnotherGen
(31,781 posts)Then tell them "no" - it's that simple.
The American people have spoken - and our Senators represent at least 20 million more people than theirs do.
No goal - no need for Chuck or Nancy to consider offers that will NOT work.
Next up - Chuck and Nancy telling the President these aren't workable options - let us pass with budget reconciliation.
We will still have another one as Trump/McConnell didn't pass a budget last year.
I'm in a good place, making great money while working from my home office in a business that has thrived during the Pandemic. However, we are helping family members who are not faring well - and they need financial relief RIGHT NOW.
Nothing that Mitt is offering is workable.
Make sure to call your Senators and House Members and tell them to pass only a workable option. I've already lit up Booker, Menendez, and Malinowski's phones and email today. Tweeting doesn't work - Calling, emails, and snail mail do.
Oldem
(833 posts)the repug plan is consistent.