General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIt's Consequence Culture not cancel culture.
Alex Winter (from Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure) wrote on the internet that it's "consequence culture."
From another website
https://www.hercampus.com/school/msu/why-fallacy-cancel-culture-so-toxic-and-no-founding-fathers-aren-t-getting-cancelled
"...cancel culture does not exist. Its a logical fallacy perpetuated by people who would like to keep making excuses for ignorant and hurtful behavior. In the twenty-first century, people are held responsible for their actions in the public sphere the way they were never previously held...."
Also from that website:
" we have a responsibility to hold each other accountable, because nobody is above treating other people with dignity and respect. When youre about to moan and groan because your favorite singer/actor/writer/athlete got cancelled, stop for a second and ask yourself what peoples reaction wouldve been if youd said or did what they said or did. If you think that you wouldnt have gotten away with it, then they probably shouldnt get away with it either."
You may have heard the Trump lawyer today bringing up the term cancel culture (slinging several phrases against Democrats-- a practice called gish gallop--as if an ad hominem attack would help). It's time we set the record straight on this. If there is any other phrase that people use against us, look it up on the internet as I did using "cancel culture fallacy." People smarter than me have probably already written about it.
BTW. Thanks so much to the kind person who gave me a heart! Happy Valentines Day!
d_r
(6,907 posts)It existed in the 1920s when the daughters of the confederacy were so embarrassed by what their grandfather's did that they put up confederate statues every where as if they were not traitors. It is exists when somebody flies a rebel flag and says it is about their history.
Silent3
(15,148 posts)I think there definitely is such a thing as overreaction, such a thing as an excessively zero-tolerance attitude, and such a thing as consequences that are too severe for the trespass committed.
Of course, a lot of consequences are quite richly deserved as well, and people who have lucked into fame and fortune shouldn't act as if they're entitled for that fame and fortune to continue.
I bet a whole lot of us here wish Al Franken hadn't been "cancelled", and would love to see him back.
bamagal62
(3,244 posts)But if we keep it, Theres a lot of cancelling that needs to go on.