Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member


(39,164 posts)
1. The right to bear arm is independent of militia service
Thu Mar 25, 2021, 06:39 AM
Mar 2021

According to the Supreme Court, presidents Biden and Obama, Bernie and HRC. It was actually put into the Democratic Party platform. Your position is not even in line with mainstream Democratic thought much less the country as a whole.

Sanity Claws

(21,682 posts)
2. I actually agree with the OP
Thu Mar 25, 2021, 06:57 AM
Mar 2021

What happened to the well-regulated militia part of the 2nd A? The mainstream version of the 2nd A seems to have landed us in a mess. It is time tr rethink things and go outside the generally accepted.


(39,164 posts)
3. Nothing happened to it
Thu Mar 25, 2021, 07:29 AM
Mar 2021

You, the OP and many others are simply misinterpreting what it actually means.

Here is something to consider - if the founding fathers meant what you think the militia clause means, why, in the entire history of the US, has there never been a law linking gun ownership to militia service? Can you show me a single instance where an American was forced to give up their guns because they were not members of a militia?


(5,042 posts)
4. armed citizens were always on call , led by local officials,
Thu Mar 25, 2021, 08:14 AM
Mar 2021

to defend their communities and to form posses and such. maybe if these mass shooters were part of such communities they might not be so alienated and would recognize the members of their fellow citizens as more than moving targets

well regulated might not mean, in every case, disarmed.


(39,164 posts)
7. In the context of the 2A regulated means "well equipped and trained"
Thu Mar 25, 2021, 08:22 AM
Mar 2021

regulated in the sense of laws and regulations is a more recent meaning of the word.



(54,770 posts)
5. Because in much of the history of the USA, we didn't have gun-humpers like this --
Thu Mar 25, 2021, 08:20 AM
Mar 2021



(39,164 posts)
8. Which has nothing to do with my post.
Thu Mar 25, 2021, 08:28 AM
Mar 2021

The 2A allows you all the freedom in the world to pass the laws needed to ensure those men can't carry assault weapons in public.


(5,484 posts)
6. the originalist interpretation make the argument that well regulated had a different meaning in 1776
Thu Mar 25, 2021, 08:21 AM
Mar 2021

One very different than what would be the modern read. They argue that in 1700s in that context it would be more synonymous with capable, well trained, or even well armed. In digging into it, that argument might hold some water.

However, the 'well trained' interpretation does offer an interesting avenue to restriction. Require the nuts to train and demonstrate proficiency before they can own an assault weapon. Would add months of delay to buying one and a lot of them probably wouldn't want to put in the work.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»"a well regulated militia...