General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMinnesota Rep Munson Proposes Anything West of the Twin Cities is Now Part of South Dakota
GOP representatives in both California and Oregon have proposed merging with Idaho. Now a GOP state politician in Minnesota is trying to do the same thing with having western Minnesota being incorporated into South Dakota. More below
The bill would allow rural Minnesota counties to secede from the state and join neighboring states like South Dakota.
Munson tweeted an image of his vision on Thursday that showed nearly every county west of the Twin Cities metro becoming part of South Dakota, and encouraged residents to sign a petition to join a neighboring state that he says respects freedom and liberty.
Bettie
(16,130 posts)How about making North and South Dakota become one state? That is about as likely.
NickB79
(19,274 posts)Try keeping your roads paved, hospitals staffed and lights on without Twin Cities tax payers. We've got over half the state's population in MSP alone, 3/4 of it in the greater metro area.
We get the half of the state with Duluth, all the refineries and rail lines to Chicago. Think of all the duties we could impose!
And I say this having grown up in a deep-red rural west-central part of Minnesota.
turbinetree
(24,726 posts)ShakopeeDakota, Upper SiouxDakota Reservations how they feel about this?
And has for Idaho and Oregon, did the racist's POS ask the Natives in those states, like the Klamath Indian Tribe .............nope they probably went to the Bundy school of shit.........and will they also honor treaties..........don't see that in the cards either.......
RicROC
(1,204 posts)A couple years ago I viewed a proposal for redrawing state lines based on equalizing population for each new state. I am open to any suggestion to modernize the effect of governance. In the end I might totally be against the proposals, but I see nothing wrong with thinking 'out of the box'.
I do remember a suggestion for the East Coast, combining Upstate-Western New York State with northern Pennsylvania based on their similar cultural backgrounds.
Blue_Adept
(6,402 posts)Sadly, yes.
Thunderbeast
(3,424 posts)from the urban parts of their state. Eastern Oregonians think Idaho would be a friendlier environment. Many in northern California and southern Oregon have longed for years to create the "Free State of Jefferson" where taxes are low, guns are a religion, and brown people are unwelcome.
https://www.oregoncapitalinsider.com/news/capitol-chatter-former-oregon-speaker-set-to-back-moving-oregon-idaho-border/article_4c5a574c-8dc2-11eb-a129-93db12c08fee.html
If lines are re-drawn, each new state should have equal populations.
https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/58809/us-map-redrawn-50-states-equal-population
Midnight Writer
(21,816 posts)Claire Oh Nette
(2,636 posts)If Minnesotans aren't happy with Minnesota, they can pick up and move to the Dakotas. Same with the Rural Northern Californians and Eastern Oregonians--don't like the state you are in? Then move.
They are children. They lost. So they're going to knock the chessboard over and scatter the pieces.
Your side loses? Then your side needs better ideas.