Chauvin defense cross-examination of Dr. Tobin.

[madaboutharry]

Nelson off on his Don Quixote search for confusing hypotheticals.

Seems he is arguing there weren’t any “experts” with Chauvin explaining how he was killing Mr. Floyd.

This seems rather futile to me.

[Dawgman49]

1. Defense by confusion

Trying to confuse the jury....pulmonary expert ain’t having it

[nolabear]

2. And now blaming Mr. Floyd for being "hysterical"

and that being the cause of him—what, erroneously thinking he couldn’t breathe? One seldom dies from asphyxia out of hysteria.

[Budi]

3. Meanwhile the jury is still sitting there examining their necks

There is no moe evidence to enter into this trial.
Prepare the closing & hand it over to the jury.

The image Dr Tobin left for the jury, is Chauvin's knee on their own necks & the pressure points that leave man or animal vulnerable to death.

That image will remain in the forefront of their thoughts everytime they see the pic of the final minutes of George Floyd's life.

Time to deliberate, deliver Chauvin's fate & get some ptsd therapy.

After Dr Tobin's testimony, we all became George Floyd in the final 9 minutes of his life.
That will not be forgotten.

Rest in peace Mr Floyd ~

[Dawgman49]

5. Defense needs a bigger shovel

Keep digging your hole...or shut up ...this expert is owning you

[Budi]

11. Guess he has to say something. Tobin blew up the entire defense today

He's gotta start over & it's not looking promising.

Wish we could have watched a side by side screen of Chauvin & his Atty while Dr Tobin was speaking.

[wryter2000]

8. Yup

Dr. Tobin is not only an expert, but he's an excellent witness. His presentation is riveting, and his explanations are easy to understand. He even made his testimony tactile.

Redirect now.

[Maru Kitteh]

4. This is some of the lamest shit yet.

[Siwsan]

6. They said there were more defense objections to this witnesses' testimony than to any other

Which makes sense. It's been authoritative and conclusive, IMHO.

[Grammy23]

9. I'll say. I can't imagine a better witness for the prosecution.

He explains complicated things in terms we all can understand. He demonstrates on himself and encourages the jury to do the same. Anyone who views this as anything other than an intentional killing by Chauvin is just not paying attention.

[halfulglas]

7. Basically he's trying to say that Mr. Floyd killed himself with pills we don't know he took.

No chain of custody.

He's really getting on my nerves.

[wryter2000]

10. Redirect now making fun of the defense attorney

"seconds, milliseconds, nanoseconds."

[Budi]

13. Is Chauvin crying yet?

"He fked around & found out"

[wryter2000]

17. I don't think he's been on camera

He has to know he's effed. Bastard. I only hope other cruel cops learn a lesson from this. (Not intended to insult all police officers.)

[Budi]

21. Indeed. Enough is enough.

[wryter2000]

23. They have to know everyone can record them now

They can't hide their cruelty any longer. (again, not aimed at all police officers.)

[halfulglas]

12. Oh, WOW. The redirect.

THIS. Pound the nail in. Hitting every point defense has tried to make.

[wryter2000]

18. Yup

Today has been a thing of beauty. I honestly think I'm in love with Dr. Tobin.

[Budi]

19. This final address should last 9 minutes.

George Floyd’s 6-year-old Daughter Says Her ‘Daddy Changed the World’

JULY 2020


"Former NBA player Stephen Jackson, who was friends with police killing victim, George Floyd, shared an Instagram post of Floyd’s daughter resting atop his shoulders."
As Gianna Floyd smiles, she is shown raising her arms and saying, “Daddy changed the world.”

[wryter2000]

22. I thought that was wishful thinking when she said it

Now, I'm convinced it could be right.

[malaise]

14. To be kind

the lawyer was way out of his depth

[Midnightwalk]

15. Is it reasonable for an officer to interpret a death spasm as resisting arrest?!?

What a disgusting premise.

The re-examination is good. Where was chauvin’s knee during the nanoseconds milliseconds and the entire 5 minutes you focused on. On his neck and back.

Would you expect bruising. No it was a static force. When I sit in church I don’t have bruising on my buttocks.

[wryter2000]

20. The church comment was a stroke of brilliance

Folksy and light humor.

[mobeau69]

16. Yes, that redirect was a bomb.

[Darwins_Retriever]

24. The defense has given up on getting a not guilty

Now trying to get manslaughter. He's not an expert, how was he supposed to know he was killing him? Don't think it will work.