General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsLegislators beg Biden administration to evacuate LGBTQ Afghans before the Taliban kills them
Gabir, a 26-year-old gay man living in Afghanistan, was dining at a restaurant with his boyfriend of eight months. The two met at university, became friends and dreamed of moving to Europe to get married. But a few hours after their meal together, Gabir learned that the Taliban had picked up his boyfriend.
The Taliban beat his boyfriend bloody, killed and dismembered him, and then threw his body parts in the street as a warning of how the Islamic militant group handles LGBTQ people. His boyfriend was 24 years old.
Later, a person claiming to be with the Taliban called Gabir.
I know you are gay, the caller told Gabir. Before capturing Kabul, we knew everything about you. You have three or four friends who are gay. You have a boyfriend. Once we settle here in Kabul, we will not let you live. If we find you, we will kill you.
Gabir has since gone into hiding, dropping out of university and cutting off all contact from his friends and family to avoid being caught.
more...
This shouldn't just be Biden's concern!!! ANY fucking democratic nation with even a shred of decency should help the LGBT flee if need be.
snowybirdie
(6,747 posts)Moving goalposts. The United States can not help everyone. Our Military Personnel are at risk.
BeyondGeography
(41,198 posts)Additionally, the lawmakers asked the Department of Defense to ensure that LGBTQ Afghans receive uninterrupted access to the Kabul International Airport so theyre not harmed while trying to flee.
While we appreciate that the situation in Afghanistan is fluid, you have the power to protect the lives of countless LGBTQ+ Afghans from the horrors they face living under a regime that threatens their very existence, Pappas letter to Blinken stated.
What is the problem?
snowybirdie
(6,747 posts)Americans in jeopardy. Enough!
FloridaBlues
(4,683 posts)Due to trumps malfeasance.
FreeState
(10,702 posts)Really? Because that is 100% what will happen to them.
Behind the Aegis
(56,209 posts)It is asking for humanitarian relief.
SMC22307
(8,090 posts)We have a moral responsibility to evacuate as many as possible.
Response to snowybirdie (Reply #1)
Post removed
Aristus
(72,514 posts)"All Afghan LGBTQ people! Here! Right here! Get your ticket out of this bullshit country right here!" - ?
I really don't think members of Afghanistan's LGBTQ community are wearing signs, so we know to get them out of there...
Behind the Aegis
(56,209 posts)Mocking a humanitarian situation with flip rhetoric.
Aristus
(72,514 posts)I'm pointing out the very difficult obstacles to evacuating a portion of the populace that not only are not wearing signs, they don't want to attract attention to themselves.
Practical reality suggests that that it would be almost impossible to mount an effort to evacuate specific individuals for specific reasons.
I think, in an effort to point accusing fingers, you missed the point of my post and pointed one at me.
Duncan Grant
(8,938 posts)Your defensiveness is a tell. We see you, baby.
Aristus
(72,514 posts)a certain specific subset of the populace will attract huge amounts of unwanted attention. Keeping as much of the evacuation on the down-low as possible is the best thing we can do for LGBTQ Afghans.
leftstreet
(41,247 posts)Godz knows I'm done that myself here
There's nothing in the snips you posted that pointed to the remedy called being called for. So it could appear there was a plea to remove a sensitive population without knowing who/where they are.
Everyone would agree to that as an excellent solution, probably also the poster
SMC22307
(8,090 posts)Only this isn't the first time.
FreeState
(10,702 posts)Gay rights are human rights.
Aristus
(72,514 posts)Please see my post above. It plainly wasn't in opposition to gay rights. It was a practical reminder of how difficult it would be to evacuate Afghanistan's LGBTQ population with the entire Taliban standing by and watching.
"We're opposed to the Taliban and we want out" is going to have to be the reason. As if that by itself wasn't going to put a huge target on their backs.
Duncan Grant
(8,938 posts)And heres where your lack of sensitivity collides with your rainbow striped plane: Rep. Pappas is asking that LGBTQI+ people be included in the State Dept.s refugee admission program. Thats it.
Theres no request for special rainbow striped planes or queer detection/screening protocols at the airport. These are terrorized and traumatized people. Frankly, Im surprised to see you taking this tone. I thought you were more enlightened than this.
Aristus
(72,514 posts)from a highly dangerous region with lack of enlightenment. If there are no screening protocols at the airport, that's going to have to be the way it is.
I'm finding it hard to articulate my point of view without sounding like "All Lives Matter" (because fuck those guys). It's just that the OP sounded a lot like "Let's make a highly-visible, attention-drawing effort to evacuate at-risk people who are really better off concealing their sexual orientation until they reach safe ground."
Obviously, I stirred up a hornet's nest, which was not my intention. It was just my intention to point out that right now, everyone is better off if the Taliban doesn't know who's gay and who's not.
NickB79
(20,403 posts)When it comes to LBGT freedom, the US foreign policy is to turn a blind eye if it's inconvenient.
chowder66
(12,502 posts)FreeState
(10,702 posts)rockfordfile
(8,742 posts)Johnny2X2X
(24,433 posts)If he moves it, people will just think they have more time.
Now I believe we'll hold that date until the last moment and then extend it a few days if needed.
I feel for the LGTBQ community in Afghanistan, I really do, if it was up to me we'd go to war simply for their rights, but no administration is going to start bombing countries to save LGTBQ people alone. And that's what it would take right now to help them.
Right now, we're still getting a ton of Afghanis out of the country, let's hope most of the LGTBQ citizens there are among them.
marie999
(3,334 posts)There isn't anything we can do for them without invading the country. This will not happen and shouldn't happen.
Sympthsical
(11,106 posts)Show of hands. Who is surprised?
Duncan Grant
(8,938 posts)The inhumanity and ignorance on display in a few posts of this thread is despicable.
bluedigger
(17,449 posts)That's nearly 6 million people...
JudyM
(29,785 posts)No words.
Kick in to the DU tip jar?
This week we're running a special pop-up mini fund drive. From Monday through Friday we're going ad-free for all registered members, and we're asking you to kick in to the DU tip jar to support the site and keep us financially healthy.
As a bonus, making a contribution will allow you to leave kudos for another DU member, and at the end of the week we'll recognize the DUers who you think make this community great.